If I'm going to self-insert, it's Nikki all day for me. She checks just about every box I look for in a partner.
Assuming the Erynn situation went down the same, I wouldn't put myself in a situation to be hurt like that again (even if it was a misunderstanding). I wouldn't date Alexis because that's too close to Erynn. Layla is alright physically, I just don't like her naivety so I'd probably try to be friends. I'd 100% be friends with Elena because of the banter. Val I'm unsure of because I think MC got extremely lucky in being able to break her shell, and I don't know if I'd put in that much effort or be able to reproduce what he did. Cara does absolutely nothing for me. Can't imagine a scenario where I'm hooking up with my teacher so Gabi is out. Iris wouldn't happen cause there's no way in hell I'm taking a pic of someone topless in public like that. I wouldn't be into Tori, she's too bitchy. I don't know enough about Mira yet to make a call.
Man if I would self insert this would be a very hard one for me to pick. If Erynn didn't have the Ethan problems id probably pick her as i really like her playful nature and alot of things about her however I don't have enough backbone in me to deal with Ethan.
Lexi I would like but I feel like she is a much stronger independent person than me when she needs to be and I would hold her back. As I think should would want to do things or have fun in ways im not comfortable with. Then there is Nikki while she and Lexi would have the same problems for me the difference is I think Nikki would actually be good for me and be able to get me try new things at my pace and be very understanding without pushing me to much. While I think Lexi would probably be just as understanding but I think she might get me to do to much to quickly.
Cara I like how sweet and kind she is , she feels like she be perfect for a first girlfriend or a high school relationship. She seems perfect on paper for me but the problem is I think we share to much of the same problems both are really shy and introverted , and that can cause some issues when some serious problems arise unless one of us gets over it.
Layla and Elena both just feel like good friends to have but I just can't see myself getting involved with either of them in a serious relationship beyond fuck buddies. Elena I can see a relationship with her being just as good with her as with Nikki but I think I would be to intimated to make a move on her. As I wouldn't want to ruin a friendship between her or Layla.
Valeria just to much of an athlete for me to keep up but I would love to be in a relationship with her and would be my pick if I could get her to let down her walls. While I see Nikki being someone that is good for me I see Valeria being a little of the same but someone I rather spend time with if I have to pick. Not just cause she is hot but she is just someone that feels like she is equally fun and playful and know how to have a good time now matter what we are doing playing video games , going for a walk or just watching tv.
But at the end of the day id probably go with Nikki unless I can get through Valeria.