jadepaladin

Well-Known Member
Mar 9, 2020
1,012
1,983
Thats what I'm feeling too. Do you think it'll be a straight up they all break up with you moment like with Alexis and Layla or your force to choose between them thing like with Valeria and Alexis.
I'm thinking choice. Erynn won't give up on the MC with a forced breakup. If it's Nikki or Cara that do the confronting I can see a scenario where they acknowledge that the distance was an issue and give you a choice. Both of them were reasonable enough to give you a choice way back in ep4 or whatever when you had to choose between them.
 

cooldevo

Member
Jan 30, 2021
476
602
Thats what I'm feeling too. Do you think it'll be a straight up they all break up with you moment like with Alexis and Layla or your force to choose between them thing like with Valeria and Alexis.
Honestly I'm hoping both, depending on the LI and scenario.

If MC actively lied/cheated/deceived in a relationship (say after daring Lexi to be your gf, officially dating Nikki/Cara, etc.) I hope it'll be anger/fire/heartbreak. Some would be potentially salvageable.
If it wasn't a fully committed relationship (such as Erynn who you never fully commit to yet), then everyone is just casually looking for people they find compatible. Then you'll be forced to make a decision.
 
Dec 1, 2017
80
75
I'm thinking choice. Erynn won't give up on the MC with a forced breakup. If it's Nikki or Cara that do the confronting I can see a scenario where they acknowledge that the distance was an issue and give you a choice. Both of them were reasonable enough to give you a choice way back in ep4 or whatever when you had to choose between them.
What about Layla cause their in a confirmed relationship now and sees the MC everyday so she's the one being done the dirtiest here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: valbitterb
Dec 1, 2017
80
75
Honestly I'm hoping both, depending on the LI and scenario.

If MC actively lied/cheated/deceived in a relationship (say after daring Lexi to be your gf, officially dating Nikki/Cara, etc.) I hope it'll be anger/fire/heartbreak. Some would be potentially salvageable.
If it wasn't a fully committed relationship (such as Erynn who you never fully commit to yet), then everyone is just casually looking for people they find compatible. Then you'll be forced to make a decision.
Wasn't their a choice to kinda commit to Erynn at the beach after the volleyball game?

I also fucking want to see the MC get fully bitched out, Nyx has done well with a lot of the break up scenes so far.
 
  • Like
Reactions: valbitterb

cooldevo

Member
Jan 30, 2021
476
602
Wasn't their a choice to kinda commit to Erynn at the beach after the volleyball game?
Ish?

Erynn, earlier in the date, starts to say "My boyf..." when you carry her to the beach. But then catches herself and trails off not completing it. Odd if they are bf/gf.

After the volleyball with the two other guys you can you can choose "Boyfriend", but all MC says is "She's mine". Erynn looks at MC but the two never talk about it after that. So I don't see that as a committed relationship, until at least one of them asks the other and they agree.
 

jadepaladin

Well-Known Member
Mar 9, 2020
1,012
1,983
Wasn't their a choice to kinda commit to Erynn at the beach after the volleyball game?

I also fucking want to see the MC get fully bitched out, Nyx has done well with a lot of the break up scenes so far.
Erynn and MC still aren't "official" and probably won't be until Ethan is handled.

I think anything with Layla is going to be some type of blowup mostly because of her temperament. You've either dated her sister at the same time (which warrants an explosion) or you literally told her you want her best friend over her right before she offers you her virginity (which warrants being emotional).

I just don't think Layla accepts being 2nd to anyone. Maybe it has something to do with her track performance. She's used to getting beaten by Tori.
 

ModiThorrson

Active Member
Jan 1, 2024
560
1,014
Ish?

Erynn, earlier in the date, starts to say "My boyf..." when you carry her to the beach. But then catches herself and trails off not completing it. Odd if they are bf/gf.

After the volleyball with the two other guys you can you can choose "Boyfriend", but all MC says is "She's mine". Erynn looks at MC but the two never talk about it after that. So I don't see that as a committed relationship, until at least one of them asks the other and they agree.
Agreed, nothing is official until stated plainly, everything else is assumption.
 

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
13,497
17,751
This is strictly my theory at the moment but I think Erynn is afraid of losing the MC again and she's willing to overlook things that should be red flags. Plus she already has enough drama on her plate so she might just not be connecting the dots yet. Alexis is a whole other deal since they are best friends, like you said. She can't glance over that.

im 50 / 50 on this cause if you play both Alexis and Erynn's path. When Erynn walks in on the MC she is the one that ends things first , then Alexis calls the MC the next day to do the same.


It should start to happen *soon* for the out of town LIs as most are moving/visiting MS "next week" (in game) so it's inevitable that people will start/continue meeting.

The in-town LIs will need to have events that put them all together at the same time. For example there's not a lot of Layla and Erynn meeting thus far. Perhaps at the BBQ or costume party, things will start to be noticed as it'd fit with a lot of the LIs likely being invited.
Hopefully if what we think is true there will be some chances at school too.

Ish?

Erynn, earlier in the date, starts to say "My boyf..." when you carry her to the beach. But then catches herself and trails off not completing it. Odd if they are bf/gf.

After the volleyball with the two other guys you can you can choose "Boyfriend", but all MC says is "She's mine". Erynn looks at MC but the two never talk about it after that. So I don't see that as a committed relationship, until at least one of them asks the other and they agree.
I honestly see them in an unofficial committed relationship with how Erynn changed sexually towards the MC in the last 2 updates and started to act more bold to do things she normally wouldn't do. Like the shower scene or the bath tub and changing room scene from this update
 
  • Like
Reactions: cooldevo

cooldevo

Member
Jan 30, 2021
476
602
I honestly see them in an unofficial committed relationship with how Erynn changed sexually towards the MC in the last 2 updates and started to act more bold to do things she normally wouldn't do. Like the shower scene or the bath tub and changing room scene from this update
Yeah, it's kind of an unusual dynamic. They are official in the way they act with each other. Kissing, making out, showering, bathing, and the such... but never actually made anything official. That was part of my "ish" reply, yes but no?

Erynn does clearly want it, even if you disregard her thoughts. On the beach date when she catches herself with the ".... my boyf..." and the MC was too stupid to hear and react to it. That'd have been a perfect spot to have sat down with her and at least discuss where they stand with each other. Instead of these awkward moments that crop up. He's more than happy to comment openly and brazenly about the bodies of the LIs and their boobs, but can't tell Erynn that he like her or wants to date her when she talks about him being her boyfriend?
 

jadepaladin

Well-Known Member
Mar 9, 2020
1,012
1,983
Yeah, it's kind of an unusual dynamic. They are official in the way they act with each other. Kissing, making out, showering, bathing, and the such... but never actually made anything official. That was part of my "ish" reply, yes but no?

Erynn does clearly want it, even if you disregard her thoughts. On the beach date when she catches herself with the ".... my boyf..." and the MC was too stupid to hear and react to it. That'd have been a perfect spot to have sat down with her and at least discuss where they stand with each other. Instead of these awkward moments that crop up. He's more than happy to comment openly and brazenly about the bodies of the LIs and their boobs, but can't tell Erynn that he like her or wants to date her when she talks about him being her boyfriend?
You could almost call them...hidden feelings. :unsure:
 
Dec 1, 2017
80
75
Yeah, it's kind of an unusual dynamic. They are official in the way they act with each other. Kissing, making out, showering, bathing, and the such... but never actually made anything official. That was part of my "ish" reply, yes but no?

Erynn does clearly want it, even if you disregard her thoughts. On the beach date when she catches herself with the ".... my boyf..." and the MC was too stupid to hear and react to it. That'd have been a perfect spot to have sat down with her and at least discuss where they stand with each other. Instead of these awkward moments that crop up. He's more than happy to comment openly and brazenly about the bodies of the LIs and their boobs, but can't tell Erynn that he like her or wants to date her when she talks about him being her boyfriend?
Yeah its kinda weird cause he's pretty forward in other routes. On the Alexis path he just straight up asks her to be his girlfriend pretty early on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LSC82
Dec 1, 2017
80
75
I'm hoping for one of 2 scenario's when the MC finally ask Erynn to be his girlfriend.

Either he recreates the original confession in the backyard minus Ethan

Or they are playing the 1000 question game and he uses that as one of his questions.
He could do both, ask one of the 1000 questions while doing the flower shit
 
  • Like
Reactions: cooldevo

anonnyscouse

Active Member
Jul 25, 2020
738
2,151
I'm not sure where Erynn's moral compass lands on cheating, yes obviously she was angry over the Lexi thing, but that may have been more towards the fact that she felt betrayed by Lexi rather than being pissed at MC playing the field before going official with anyone, and she may have felt the only way to keep her friendship with Lexi in the longrun would be to avoid getting closer romantically with MC.

It's worth remembering that on the ASP Erynn is explicitly encouraging Lexi to try and get MC to cheat on Layla.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jadepaladin

Kaskaze

Newbie
May 1, 2022
60
37
Yeah its kinda weird cause he's pretty forward in other routes. On the Alexis path he just straight up asks her to be his girlfriend pretty early on.
Only in this case nothing will be easy. Maybe both of them realize that if they enter the "Relationship" level they will lose a friend if something does not work out. So it will be winning everything or losing everything. And both of them are afraid.
 

cooldevo

Member
Jan 30, 2021
476
602
You could almost call them...hidden feelings. :unsure:
On Erynn's end, I'd say she is fully aware of how she feels. Sure there's a nervousness in her intimate moments, but why? MC clearly has his thoughts we can read, and he more or less fully admits to wanting more. Neither just seems to want to admit to the other what they actually feel.

The longer the story has gone on, I'm less inclined to believe it's the Ethan story that's keeping her internalizing. There's very little thoughts of hers that we (game player) are privy to, that makes me thinks that's it's related to Ethan in any way.

I'm thinking that it's fear. She expresses concern at least once, possibly twice?, that she's scared he'll take off again. She was already hurt/devastated when he cut her out of his life the first time and left town. She says as much when her and MC are in his room and she asks why he hasn't decorated his room, and that she's concerned/worried he'll leave again. As it's something she actually says directly to the MC, I'm thinking it'll probably be the, if not one of the, top reasons.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jadepaladin

mike12013

Member
Oct 3, 2024
312
554
On Erynn's end, I'd say she is fully aware of how she feels. Sure there's a nervousness in her intimate moments, but why? MC clearly has his thoughts we can read, and he more or less fully admits to wanting more. Neither just seems to want to admit to the other what they actually feel.

The longer the story has gone on, I'm less inclined to believe it's the Ethan story that's keeping her internalizing. There's very little thoughts of hers that we (game player) are privy to, that makes me thinks that's it's related to Ethan in any way.

I'm thinking that it's fear. She expresses concern at least once, possibly twice?, that she's scared he'll take off again. She was already hurt/devastated when he cut her out of his life the first time and left town. She says as much when her and MC are in his room and she asks why he hasn't decorated his room, and that she's concerned/worried he'll leave again. As it's something she actually says directly to the MC, I'm thinking it'll probably be the, if not one of the, top reasons.
there's also the fact her and MC are lifelong friends and if it doesn't work out then they could lose each other forever, there's also probably doubts in her head that it feels too good to be true

she also could just be scared that last time she fucked someone it was being recorded
 

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
13,497
17,751
On Erynn's end, I'd say she is fully aware of how she feels. Sure there's a nervousness in her intimate moments, but why? MC clearly has his thoughts we can read, and he more or less fully admits to wanting more. Neither just seems to want to admit to the other what they actually feel.

The longer the story has gone on, I'm less inclined to believe it's the Ethan story that's keeping her internalizing. There's very little thoughts of hers that we (game player) are privy to, that makes me thinks that's it's related to Ethan in any way.

I'm thinking that it's fear. She expresses concern at least once, possibly twice?, that she's scared he'll take off again. She was already hurt/devastated when he cut her out of his life the first time and left town. She says as much when her and MC are in his room and she asks why he hasn't decorated his room, and that she's concerned/worried he'll leave again. As it's something she actually says directly to the MC, I'm thinking it'll probably be the, if not one of the, top reasons.
yeah I think it's why she makes such a big deal about him decorating his room. That's why I think when the MC decided not to buy that poster for his room but get something online in this update. Erynn was kind of sad and disappointed in that moment , I do wish we saw them browsing the store for his room during the date however. It could of gave us a bit more insight and how she feels about him and abandonment issues she has with the MC and his room.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: LSC82 and cooldevo

cooldevo

Member
Jan 30, 2021
476
602
yeah I think it's why she makes such a big deal about him decorating his room. That's why I think when the MC decided not to buy that poster for his room but get something online in this update. Erynn was kind of sad and disappointed in that moment , I do wish we saw them browsing the store for his room during the date however. It could of gave us a bit more insight and how she feels about him and abandonment issues she has with the MC and his room.
When the scene happens, you aren't fully on her path, as it exists, yet but have already had the chance for some flirting and intimate moments. I always found it odd/cringey that if you pursue her solo path to that point, Erynn offers some picture of her for the wall and the MC says "but that'd be weird if I brought girls home" (paraphrased). If the MC/Me will be fully into only Erynn, as they've already flirted a lot even by that point, it was just pretty cringey moment for me. I'd have loved the chance to put those photos up, and could have been a step to say look I'm decorating and not going anywhere.....

Even if not on her path, cool action shots of Eryn in her gaming shots wouldn't really be any more awkward than having a photo of a random female singer, actress, model, or athlete on the wall. Well, if on Lexi's path, maybe not the MC's Enzo poster, as he already walks in on them at her house, why have him pretend there? ;):LOL:
 
  • Haha
Reactions: jadepaladin

cxx

Message Maestro
Nov 14, 2017
68,955
34,961
Don't worry, Layla and Lexi will be the ones to catch MC balls deep in Adriana and in their parents bedroom. You got to unlock the "All in the Family" achievement.
don't even joke about that, it'd be way too hilarious.

Any idea as to when this game could be completed? Just asking for a ballpark number if anyone has any idea.
neverending story but not on this or next year, possibly by 2030.

probably a few more years
and those aren't ingame years.


serious question: who are naomi and natasha? checked game stats and it says that "my" saves have 6 naomi points and that there's some natasha but no clue who either is.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
4.40 star(s) 301 Votes