DIRTY FILTHY Animal

Devoted Member
Jun 11, 2020
9,085
31,082
Just imagine how good the content will be once you actually start dating Melissa who has prior history with both emily and john and then there is the erynn. Like good lord we gonna be eating good, the drama will be delicious.
This would be great for Melissa, she can show Emily, “ok you want to date my ex one night stand, I’ll do you one better, I’m going to let your son fuck my brains out in your bed” :ROFLMAO:
 

cxx

Message Maestro
Nov 14, 2017
68,312
34,573
I hadn't been focusing on this constellation the whole time until the discussion started here.

Now I'm really excited to see how Nyx resolves it. And before anyone shouts, of course Nyx will give us a choice at some point, either mother or daughter, but how that comes about and what happens after that will be really interesting.
she will cry a lot in erynn's and mc's weddings. :p
 

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
2,446
5,071
Yea cant imagine that Melissa would ever hurt her daughter by competing with her over a man. Probs have to be on the friend path with Erynn to even think about unlike her love path
I have a hard time seeing it too, specially knowing what her daughter has been through and how happy she is now.
She'll probably remain in dreamland, furiously diddlying her cunny.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Like i just said... i don't think it will happen... But the prospect of this scene FOR REAL is fucking hillarious.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Malicre

Malicre

Well-Known Member
Oct 23, 2018
1,343
2,339
I have a hard time seeing it too, specially knowing what her daughter has been through and how happy she is now.
How happy Erynn is depends entirely on your playthrough. I know in mine iv done the bare minimum for her and that was just to not lose Melissa points.
 

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
2,446
5,071
How happy Erynn is depends entirely on your playthrough. I know in mine iv done the bare minimum for her and that was just to not lose Melissa points.
Everyone knows that if you keep Erynn at a distance the stakes are much lower, which is why we are discussing a possible Erynn-Melissa combo where the stakes are through the roof.
No relationship, i can see Erynn being surprised at the MC entering a relationship with her mom, but i don't see her opposing it really.

If you do have a Erynn relationship however, Erynn would be devastated if something ever happens, it would ruin her relationship not only with the MC but also with her mom.
So this is the big question we are asking, would Melissa dare to ruin her daughters happyness for her desires?

I'm letting Mommy Brooke touch her after all she isn't a LI so she needs some love to
Meh... no Mommy Brooke for me, i rather have her calling me Daddy :cool: .
 
Last edited:

sirlars05

New Member
Jan 19, 2023
3
17
Just finished the latest update with most routes. Just to get some theories right and to see what other say:

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Thanks for any answers, good update in which Val really shined. Still have to go for an Elena run and Nikki/Cara, however I honestly care about their storyline the least.
 

Justaphase

Active Member
Donor
May 1, 2024
964
2,714
Just finished the latest update with most routes. Just to get some theories right and to see what other say:

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Thanks for any answers, good update in which Val really shined. Still have to go for an Elena run and Nikki/Cara, however I honestly care about their storyline the least.
1. Yes it seems so.
2. Maybe, we don't know yet. She is the most likely suspect.
3. Levi was her boyfriend or a boy she liked anyway, when she was 16-17 who she met at nationals but he lived far away. Did you not listen to Val's story while on the beach date? She explains all of this and who those two assholes are.
We don't know who gym/park guy is yet, but is most likely Zane/Mr Donovan IMO.
4. I doubt it. Most likely he gave her a warning to stay out of his business if she helped the MC. Her phone was knocked out of her hand and smashed when Ethan bumped into her. This is most likely why the MC can't get a hold of her.
5. I wouldn't take too much notice of the tattoos. John is almost certainly going to be both Erynn and Iris's father.
 
Last edited:

anonnyscouse

Active Member
Jul 25, 2020
727
2,113
Yea cant imagine that Melissa would ever hurt her daughter by competing with her over a man. Probs have to be on the friend path with Erynn to even think about unlike her love path
I believed that until Nyx's recent Q&A where she gave an answer that could be interpreted as even main LIs could be there to spoil other relationships.

She gave the list of LIs then said that other girls might or might not become LIs or might only exist to spoil relationships with the LIs and then in brackets put "maybe even the main LIs", which most people think means that the non-LIs are there to spoil to relationship with main LIs, but then that's already happened in the story so didn't need to be stipulated.

But it could mean that an LI also spoils relationships with oher LIs, unless you count Elena path as spoiling the Layla relationship (again that's already happened so didn't need to be stipulated) the only real candidate for doing it amongst the confirmed LIs is Melissa only being available by spoiling the Erynn relationship.
 

Maccabbee

Member
Mar 26, 2024
375
469
I believed that until Nyx's recent Q&A where she gave an answer that could be interpreted as even main LIs could be there to spoil other relationships.

She gave the list of LIs then said that other girls might or might not become LIs or might only exist to spoil relationships with the LIs and then in brackets put "maybe even the main LIs", which most people think means that the non-LIs are there to spoil to relationship with main LIs, but then that's already happened in the story so didn't need to be stipulated.

But it could mean that an LI also spoils relationships with oher LIs, unless you count Elena path as spoiling the Layla relationship (again that's already happened so didn't need to be stipulated) the only real candidate for doing it amongst the confirmed LIs is Melissa only being available by spoiling the Erynn relationship.
What makes you think that they can't share? ;):p
 

MilesEdgeworth

Engaged Member
Nov 8, 2021
2,238
2,883
Everyone knows that if you keep Erynn at a distance the stakes are much lower, which is why we are discussing a possible Erynn-Melissa combo where the stakes are through the roof.
No relationship, i can see Erynn being surprised at the MC entering a relationship with her mom, but i don't see her opposing it really.

If you do have a Erynn relationship however, Erynn would be devastated if something ever happens, it would ruin her relationship not only with the MC but also with her mom.
So this is the big question we are asking, would Melissa dare to ruin her daughters happyness for her desires?



Meh... no Mommy Brooke for me, i rather have her calling me Daddy :cool: .
Yea, Melissa was scared of pissing off Erynn over a joke that went too far; no way do I see her even thinking about risking her relationship with her daughter over a boy toy. But yea keeping Erynn at arm's length is probs the most obv way to open the melissa path.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LSC82
4.40 star(s) 299 Votes