Because John was a father figure to MC, so trust was already built. It's why Emily asks MC if he's ok with them dating.
Again we don't know if she's only into women so there goes that theory also. As i said before some ppl was probably wanting Emily to be with someone so the Dev gave them John and made it an option for those that doesn't want it. I think Zak is the only person that you can score points for that isn't a Li or someone MC can Bang. And I already told you why we can score points with Zak. I think if Emily was actually Bisexual she would have done something in the 19 years since college. She kisses Mel in the pool after getting drunk and that's it.
I'm pretty sure Brooke mentions only being into women when laying on the couch with MC, in the restaurant locker room. I don't think anyone was actively calling for Emily to have any partner, apart from the gooners who can't play an AVN without an MC who bangs his mother. Once it was revealed that Brooke was crushing on Emily (Episode 10 i think), that's when people started paying attention and speculating on Emily/Brooke. You said it yourself, prior to that revelation hardly anyone discussed Brooke because there are better options for MC to pursue.
Discussed Zak and Emily, i forgot who Naomi is, Hey maybe Adriana could be something maybe her husband is always busy so maybe lol We don't yet know about the future of Sienna and Sha'Carri so they could be future LI or just somebody to bang who knows so i still stand by my statement on those. Maybe Brooke does say she is only into women i don't remember her saying but it wouldn't be a first time a lesbian in a vn to go Bisexual for the right guy. To me the A Emily and Brooke would have to be an arc by it self and i don't see the Dev spending that much time on side characters. They have to much against them to make it a quick side story, Emily is twice her age, plus you would have to reopen Emily's mind to going Bisexual she hasn't been with a woman in nearly 20 years. Plus like said why give us the option to be flirty with Brooke? And why give a side character multiple Li options? Why would the Dev spend that much time on a side character? I know it would probably piss of 95% of players if dev spent to much time on it when she could be spending it on the MC.
Naomi is the black teacher, you get points in her class and have a chance to peep at her in the store changing rooms. It is highly unlikely that Adriana would jeopardize her happy marriage to a multi-millionaire, former athlete husband, to bang a student who happens to be dating one of her daughters. This entire game is predicated on arcs for side characters, even Haley and Coach Mike, who have no real impact have a reconciliation arc and they are nobodies.
Yeah and while ago you was excusing mel for being intoxicated and Emily was stressed and intoxicated. And i just read the convo between Brooke and MC and he asked her if she liked his flirting and she said she liked it and he asked so your not 100% lesbian and she said i don't know. And she actually flirted back. And having a younger brother at 21 doesn't meant she's in her mid to late 20's she could be 22 or 23. And Emily probably in her late 30's to early 40's because we don't know what phase of college she's in when she got pregnant. Haley and Coach? They are barley mentioned so that doesn't count and i don't know of any other arcs of side characters. Like i said i just seen the scene with Brooke and there is more of a chance for MC getting with her than your letting on. It was admitted that she liked his flirting and that she flirted back and she didn't know if she is 100% lesbian. Her own words She did not know. and she flirted a bit with him when she was looking at his bike and kissed his cheek.
I wasn't "excusing" anything, merely stating Mel hasn't exhibited lesbian tendencies while sober. She may just like fooling around when drunk, but doesn't want a lesbian relationship, something you implied Emily and her "would have done a long time ago".
Let me ask you this. For those that has already hooked Emily up with John. What's the point in gaining points with Brooke? And your talking about a 1 time thing that happened 20 years ago in college. And every arc in this story has a LI attached to it Coach and Haley that arc has Nikki or Cara attached to it. and the friendly flirting to boost confidence i don't by that MC doesn't lack confidence and nether does Brooke and your forgetting that she said she didn't know about not being 100% lesbian. And also he was still flirting with her after the lesbian talk we just didn't get any options for flirting. Did you see how hew was still checking her out while she was laying on top of him on the couch?
I'm not going to go into it because there have been plenty of responses while I was away getting my beauty sleep, but you're doing a fair bit of assuming and speaking for all in this post (and speaking for the dev, too).
I don't see why it would matter if Emily had a date with John, one pump and they are tethered for life? It's been confirmed by Nyx a few characters aren't making it to the end. With John on Ethan's radar, I wouldn't be surprised if he goes.
I just don't see Dev spending that much time on Side characters. It's uncommon for side characters in vn's to get Li's Much less 2. Because most ppl don't care. evidence is on this site. out of 1864 pages there is only 31 pages which Brook is mentioned 50 about John half of those are not even talking about them as romantic Li just in general. So it shows how un popular that even is so why would Dev even spend time on that? You keep saying emily was sober i also said it was 20 YEARS AGO ONE TIME and hasn't done it since until the pool scene where she was drunk. Yeah and with your theory With John what if. Sounds like your doing a lot of what if with Brooke. But all we going to do here is argue and nether of us are going to win that arguement because it probably won't come to fruitation for another year or 2. You could be right and so can I. But i will say this your making assuptions and i'm taking mine from facts that's already been said and done in the VN. She liked his flirting and she flirted back. and she said she didn't know if she was 100% lesbian those are facts and has been said.
Yes wether you like it are not Emily is a side character and story progression with a side character having one LI is umcommon 2 would be unheard of because majority of players would feel robbed of content because Dev getting side tracked on side characters. PPl want either main story progression or sex scenes. They couldn't care less about story progression with a side character.
there is Side character ( just there for sex mostly) and then there is side characters that have a purpose be story or progression to the point they are kind of in the middle between side and main. I've seen a decent amount of games have the 2nd. I'd say Emily would belong to category 2. Tho she would be the more rare un -romanceable side character
There is only 1 MC or unless it is multiple MC which this is not. Your either side character or your main character. Now side characters can be almost as important to the story as the MC but they usually never have Li much less an option for second Devs usually don't go off track to far with side plot that don't involve MC because usually ppl don't care. Somebody was saying i'm making an assuption with saying that but look through this forum of 1864 pages and tell me how important is emily having a Li is.
Well my point still stands there is 2 different categories of side characters, that's all I was saying. There are ones id consider in the middle where they are almost a main or can almost be considered as one / they have alot of plot reasons but not romanceable or just there for sex or .
That doesn't change what I said, you're making assumptions and aiming to speak for others when you say "people want this" or "people don't want that". And constantly quoting pagecount in this game thread doesn't mean anything for your argument. There has been so much discussion on main parts of the game and theorising on future developments. That something smaller isn't discussed as much doesn't mean no one is interested in it.
I agree side characters aren't Irrelevant. They play a major role on how the story flows. Your absolutely right. They help the flow to the main story though, they don't go off on their own story. You say i am going off on assumptions and the page count doesn't matter, But it does show what matters to them and what doesn't. Sure there is some ppl a small % that wanted Emily to have someone and the Dev gave them John and like i said IMO that's it, you got what you wanted i don't see dev going off on 2 different routes like that for a side character when he's got Li for MC that hasn't had that much time like Elena or Val. I'm not completely crossing out Brooke for Emily because she did say she is a lesbian but at the same time the MC did get her to admit she "Does Not Know" if she is 100% lesbian. She did enjoy the MC flirting with her and that she was flirting back. Now wether something comes of it or not none of us actually knows, and we may not know for a long time because of the main story, or way may know in the next 1 to 2 updates if Dev makes her a Li for MC. And also the others i was talking to was throwing their assumptions at me as well and i was just addressing their assumptions. Also i read back on some old posts about Brooke and someone mentioned that the Dev did say there was a path for Brooke as a Li. I usually don't make comments on something unless i've looked it up first and if i go off base with facts i usually let them know if it's my opinion or a fact.
last update was only 1 day-2 days long update and not that short so if shorter then it'd be max 12 hrs time.
