I give you a "like" for the first half, but not the second
Mel isn't really my type, and to be honest, she's only hot for me because she has a good figure and her closeness to the family makes it a kind of taboo - she's practically MC's aunt. I'd still do her path just for completion's sake though.
Layla, on the other hand, is gorgeous and has a sweet personality that I like a lot. For me, she's maybe just a bit too much on the naive side, otherwise she could be close to perfect.