Ha...these debates on the girls character are still going on? That's drama for you. Let me jump back in. lol
I don't find much of anything that's complex about these girl's character/personality. They're prime examples of what you find everyday in "modern" women now. Nearly all of them in this story act incredibly stupid(opinion), make terrible life choices, and to top it all off...continue to make very bad choices, even after realizing they made bad choices. Most likely will, right up until they hit "The Wall". They have virtual fields of red flags telling you to run like hell. But this is a porn game so...meh.
Personally, if it weren't for being carried on rails down certain routes, I wouldn't have anything to do with either of the childhood friends. They are both train wrecks. You can't stop looking, even though you know it's going to be ugly. One goes full on thot in the first scenes of the story, while later the story is trying to convince you that she's so amazing, and the other, while cozying up to the one person who treated you like shit the most, literally jumps right into blackmail trying to chase that easy money and life. But she's supposed to love you. Right.
As far as Erynn goes, another reason why she seems the toxic type: I've personally witnessed 3 different women play blind to the guy friend(s) who were playing the friend card to get into her panties. These girls weren't really bad people, but they were absolutely horrible girlfriends to their supposed boyfriends. Why? For the attention. They craved and fed off if. How do I know that? 2 of them flat out told me after their relationships fell apart. Also, 2 of them cheated. For Erynn, I realize it was done when she was a young teen, but she continued it through adulthood, and it took blackmail to open her eyes. But again...porn game so...meh.
At least Alexis is more tolerable, despite being a shitty, back stabbing friend.
It's basic Soap Opera drama 101. Create characters that are the least likely for you to have a serious/successful relationship with, make em' a little sleazy (sex sells) and/or overly dramatic, then try and write the story to make you feel sorry for them.
To me, Layla I think her name was?, is probably the closest thing to a good girlfriend that you're likely to find here. But that's just my opinion. But, again, this is just a porn game/story, so...yeah. Still waiting for the drama bomb to ruin the others for me, but praying it won't.
Incase you haven't noticed, I prefer the story over the porn. And, yes, I draw parallels to real life. I can do that when the story imitates real life.