I hate blackmail so bad in this games, it's always so dumb.
Why the the person being blackmailed are never being blackmailed for doing something wrong that will actually put them in trouble if it comes out? It gets to a point where the damage done by the blackmail is far worse than the damage that would be done otherwise. That's so dumb.
What was Ethan going to do with the video, anyway?
...Was he going to show it to Erynn's family? Was he going to distribute a copy to every place she gets a job? Was he going to upload it to some amateur porn site?
It's not like Ethan have means to to publish the video on prime-time TV for everyone to see.
Erynn said Ethan pushed all her friends away growing up, she can just have a makeover, leave everything behind and start again somewhere else. No one would recognize her.
I doubt there is a guy out there that would recognize the porn "actress" of some movie recorded by a cellphone camera, that he watched once in a amateur porn site, even if he meet her on the street.