Dessolos

Board Buff
Jul 25, 2017
16,183
21,826
My interpretation of the kiss from Lexi was she didn't like the MC until after the kiss but wasn't until she was older and how often Erynn talked about him she started to like him more than a crush.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LSC82

Elduriel

Conversation Conqueror
Donor
Mar 28, 2021
6,159
11,820
My interpretation of the kiss from Lexi was she didn't like the MC until after the kiss but wasn't until she was older and how often Erynn talked about him she started to like him more than a crush.
I don't think that's accurate either... it was just an innocent thing, didn't mean too much for either of them at the time. Now that they are together it's a fond memory, but at the time it wasn't really anything. And I don't think Lexi did dig him before meeting on the plane, she didn't even remember him until he mentioned Erynn.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LSC82

byaaahh

Active Member
Feb 3, 2018
502
927
My interpretation of the kiss from Lexi was she didn't like the MC until after the kiss but wasn't until she was older and how often Erynn talked about him she started to like him more than a crush.
Yeah, Erynn's fawning over how great he was during the absence, coupled with her witnessing MC gifting Erynn a flower, which nobody had done or has done for her, clearly influenced Lexi's opinion.

Once she realised who he was on the plane, that the great guy who "stole" her first kiss was seated right next to her, the stars aligned and fate was telling her something.
 

MilesEdgeworth

Engaged Member
Nov 8, 2021
2,896
3,619
Yea while I think thats a good story now for their relationship, I don't think Alexis was too happy about MC being her first kiss at the time, she was just trying to console MC after what happened when that happened.

Im going to get controversial and say I don't even think Erynn was romantically into MC at that point, she wasn't going to humiliate him, but I don't think she was dreaming about his being her boyfriend either. The past is just romanticized because MC moved away for a while and recently returned.
 

Dessolos

Board Buff
Jul 25, 2017
16,183
21,826
Yea while I think thats a good story now for their relationship, I don't think Alexis was too happy about MC being her first kiss at the time, she was just trying to console MC after what happened when that happened.

Im going to get controversial and say I don't even think Erynn was romantically into MC at that point, she wasn't going to humiliate him, but I don't think she was dreaming about his being her boyfriend either. The past is just romanticized because MC moved away for a while and recently returned.
yeah I think Erynn just saw him as a good friend but also someone that was too young to think about seriously. It was only after he was gone and how shit Ethan was to her that she started to miss him more than normal and fall for him.
 

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
2,788
5,888
Yea while I think thats a good story now for their relationship, I don't think Alexis was too happy about MC being her first kiss at the time, she was just trying to console MC after what happened when that happened.

Im going to get controversial and say I don't even think Erynn was romantically into MC at that point, she wasn't going to humiliate him, but I don't think she was dreaming about his being her boyfriend either. The past is just romanticized because MC moved away for a while and recently returned.
Yup, it's "cute" now that the story came full circle, but they felt nothing for each other at the time.

And yeah, Erynn was very surprised by the declaration... she had no such thoughts regarding him, to her he was just the little boy next door.

I'll even say that from the perspective of an Erynn romance the 5 year break was a positive, for her to stop seeing him as the little boy next door and more like a man.
And the fact that he wanted her all those years ago, there's always that "does he still feel like that?" Question in the air.
 

Krytax123

Engaged Member
Dec 29, 2022
2,899
6,183
Yea while I think thats a good story now for their relationship, I don't think Alexis was too happy about MC being her first kiss at the time, she was just trying to console MC after what happened when that happened.

Im going to get controversial and say I don't even think Erynn was romantically into MC at that point, she wasn't going to humiliate him, but I don't think she was dreaming about his being her boyfriend either. The past is just romanticized because MC moved away for a while and recently returned.
Which is only fair and realistic. There arent a lot of 15 or 16 yo girls who fall in love with guys who are 3+ years younger lol, the maturity levels are entirely different at this age but it is still a fun setup for their relationship nowadays with both Erynn and Lexi imo.
 

cxx

Message Maestro
Nov 14, 2017
72,384
37,006
My interpretation of the kiss from Lexi was she didn't like the MC until after the kiss but wasn't until she was older and how often Erynn talked about him she started to like him more than a crush.
erynn and lexi 3some in version 15. :p
 

Elduriel

Conversation Conqueror
Donor
Mar 28, 2021
6,159
11,820
Which is only fair and realistic. There arent a lot of 15 or 16 yo girls who fall in love with guys who are 3+ years younger lol, the maturity levels are entirely different at this age but it is still a fun setup for their relationship nowadays with both Erynn and Lexi imo.
yeah, that ain't happening between a 13 year old guy and 16 year old girl, at least it's fucking rare. Sure, cute declaration of love or whatever, but unrealistic. 18 and 21 is a different story. There is still a gap, but it's way smaller.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Krytax123 and LSC82

cxx

Message Maestro
Nov 14, 2017
72,384
37,006
yeah, that ain't happening between a 13 year old guy and 16 year old girl, at least it's fucking rare. Sure, cute declaration of love or whatever, but unrealistic. 18 and 21 is a different story. There is still a gap, but it's way smaller.
some 13 years old or younger have gotten their teachers preggo, even in god bless murica.
 

Justaphase

Well-Known Member
Donor
May 1, 2024
1,877
5,860
And yeah, Erynn was very surprised by the declaration... she had no such thoughts regarding him, to her he was just the little boy next door.

I'll even say that from the perspective of an Erynn romance the 5 year break was a positive, for her to stop seeing him as the little boy next door and more like a man.
And the fact that he wanted her all those years ago, there's always that "does he still feel like that?" Question in the air.
I think that Erynn does/did love the MC, but back then it was more of a sibling love for her. There are a few times in the game where I question that though. During the confrontation with Lexi, Erynn says "But you know how I feel about him!" "You know how much I missed him and how happy I am that he's back" and implies that only Lexi knows her feelings about the MC.
I agree that the 5 year break was a positive for their relationship to take a romantic turn. As hard as it was for them, it was necessary.
 

byaaahh

Active Member
Feb 3, 2018
502
927
I think that Erynn does/did love the MC, but back then it was more of a sibling love for her. There are a few times in the game where I question that though. During the confrontation with Lexi, Erynn says "But you know how I feel about him!" "You know how much I missed him and how happy I am that he's back" and implies that only Lexi knows her feelings about the MC.
I agree that the 5 year break was a positive for their relationship to take a romantic turn. As hard as it was for them, it was necessary.
You're right, it was more of a sibling type love, but as the saying goes "Absence makes the heart grow fonder".

I don't think only Lexi knows how she feels though, Mel probably does and I suspect Ethan too, which is why he's antagonising MC after returning. Erynn never cared about him as much as she did MC, so he starts manipulating Zach to betray his oldest friend.
 

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
2,788
5,888
I think that Erynn does/did love the MC, but back then it was more of a sibling love for her. There are a few times in the game where I question that though. During the confrontation with Lexi, Erynn says "But you know how I feel about him!" "You know how much I missed him and how happy I am that he's back" and implies that only Lexi knows her feelings about the MC.
I agree that the 5 year break was a positive for their relationship to take a romantic turn. As hard as it was for them, it was necessary.
The 5 year break allows her to see him in a different light now that he's grown up, had they kept being neighbors it may have been harder for her to see him in this fashion.

I think even though she thought of him as a brother, that declaration in the backyard stuck with her(and she probably talked about it with Alexis, before and after the MC coming back into town, so Alexis knows).
screenshot0057.png

They talked about things since Erynn also knows about the stolen kiss.

You're right, it was more of a sibling type love, but as the saying goes "Absence makes the heart grow fonder".

I don't think only Lexi knows how she feels though, Mel probably does and I suspect Ethan too, which is why he's antagonising MC after returning. Erynn never cared about him as much as she did MC, so he starts manipulating Zach to betray his oldest friend.
Melissa knows even if Erynn never told her anything, simply mother intuition, she keeps pushing and teasing for them to get together, so she believes this is what her daughter wants, even if she doesn't vocalize it.

Ethan disliked the MC since he was a little boy, saw him as constantly getting in the way of his plans of conquering Erynn... and probably knows that the adult MC presents twice the problem.
 
Last edited:

MrD812

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2021
1,618
2,443
But when you are 16, dating a 13 year old or even looking at a 13 year old that way is just a....no. I usually have to say this in defense of Erynn and the MC's "confession" but I think that the same applies to Lexi as she was also 16.
Was actually dating one but to be fair, looked no where near my age.
Being taller then her wasn't just the case, worked out 3x a day.
Not unheard of when two genuinely long for each others company.

Sometimes most unplanned odd things can happen between friends.
 
  • Like
Reactions: valbitterb

MilesEdgeworth

Engaged Member
Nov 8, 2021
2,896
3,619
my favorite part of the 5 years apart is the 1000 question game Erynn came up with it's such a cute and wholesome scene.
I especially liked it when he tried to ask a perverted question to control the flow of the game, and she answered right away. I like the fact that it's their special game.

The 5 year break allows her to see him in a different light now that he's grown up, had they kept being neighbors it may have been harder for her to see him in this fashion.

I think even though she thought of him as a brother, that declaration in the backyard stuck with her(and she probably talked about with Alexis, before and after the MC coming back into town, so Alexis knows).
View attachment 4194884

They talked about things since Erynn also knows about the stolen kiss.


Melissa knows even if Erynn never told her anything, simply mother intuition, she keeps pushing and teasing for them to get together, so she believes this is what her daughter wants, even if she doesn't vocalize it.

Ethan disliked the MC since he was a little boy, saw him as constantly getting in the way of his plans of conquering Erynn... and probably knows that the adult MC presents twice the problem.
Erynn is the most independent character in the game, except for maybe Alexis. The only people who know how she feels are those close enough to her to figure it out, which makes sense in Melissa's case. Interestingly, being around MC causes her to open up more.
I wonder if MC returned and wasn't a model if those feelings would've remained when she saw him. She would've been his friend, but would she have had the same romantic interest in him? This is just an interesting question to ponder.

Here's another question that doesn't affect the game, but I figured I'd pull on this string. Since this is a small town, how did he not run into some of his high school people who were not named Zach before his return? Sure, some would've moved in during the past five years, but at least Mckayla was there before Zach moved.
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: LSC82

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
2,788
5,888
I especially liked it when he tried to ask a perverted question to control the flow of the game, and she answered right away. I like the fact that it's their special game.
Yeah she immediately knocked it out.
And the questions, more than a month later, are still ongoing lol.

Erynn is the most independent character in the game, except for maybe Alexis. The only people who know how she feels are those close enough to her to figure it out, which makes sense in Melissa's case. Interestingly, being around MC causes her to open up more.
I wonder if MC returned and wasn't a model if those feelings would've remained when she saw him. She would've been his friend, but would she have had the same romantic interest in him? This is just an interesting question to ponder.

Here's another question that doesn't affect the game, but I figured I'd pull on this string. Since this is a small town, how did he not run into some of his high school people who were not named Zach before his return? Sure, some would've moved in during the past five years, but at least Mckayla was there before Zach moved.
Melissa presses and pushes her towards the MC and every time she keeps denying there's anything to her mother, so Melissa is 100% doing this out of her own interpretation.

Just like she wasn't really interested sexually in the 13 year old MC... maybe she wouldn't(she immediately notices that he grew up nicely), but that would also apply to every other girl that falls for him right away... Layla, Alexis...

Yeah that's a good question why no other friends at that age?
 
  • Like
Reactions: valbitterb

valbitterb

Well-Known Member
Apr 11, 2022
1,170
3,762
Yeah that's a good question why no other friends at that age?
UHHH .... "I am pretty you are pretty so let's be ..."

screenshot0001-crop.png


Melissa presses and pushes her towards the MC and every time she keeps denying there's anything to her mother, so Melissa is 100% doing this out of her own interpretation.
screenshot0002.png screenshot0003.png

Just like she wasn't really interested sexually in the 13 year old MC... maybe she wouldn't(she immediately notices that he grew up nicely), but that would also apply to every other girl that falls for him right away... Layla, Alexis...
screenshot0011.png screenshot0009.png screenshot0013.png
 
4.40 star(s) 306 Votes