Elduriel

Resist the Kaiju!
Donor
Mar 28, 2021
8,399
19,464
854
While she's got the looks to become a fan favorite, it wouldn't make a whole lot of sense, Dani and her family are from Madison Springs... Darryl has known her for sometime... this flashback takes place in Riverside.
I'm also not sure if Nyx should be tossing new LIs this late in the game.
nah not as an LI, I meant she wouldn't remain a nameless background character forever. She is taken anyway.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LSC82

glaslow

Member
Aug 3, 2025
399
848
144
Changing Cara's personality might end up backfiring, while Nikki with her confident, outgoing, personality(plus big ass and tiddies :devilish: ) seems more popular, i'm sure a number of players liked the shy, virgin Cara better... trying to make her more confident might drive some of them away.
Making her more like Nikki isn't the answer, there's a Nikki already.

For old players like us i think Cara has a mountain to climb...
It's going against preferences almost set in stone... What are the odds Kaskaze suddenly goes "I like Cara now"? Damn near zero :KEK:
Maybe it works on new players who knows?

For me the best thing Nyx did for Cara was adding a NSP.
This gives me a (evil :devilish:) reason to play Cara... i'm always a fan of getting sisters to fight :KEK:

While she's got the looks to become a fan favorite, it wouldn't make a whole lot of sense, Dani and her family are from Madison Springs... Darryl has known her for sometime... this flashback takes place in Riverside.
I'm also not sure if Nyx should be tossing new LIs this late in the game.


There's also that... until it gets revealed that the Mechanic is called Rafael Ramirez, brother to Dani and Gabi :ROFLMAO:
Then we can have one more sisters catfighting :devilish:

Ultimately i think she'll be used to tell us about other stuff that will end up mattering down the line, her accident, Gabi's failed marriage, and who was Gabi's husband(because dumbass couldn't figure that out himself :cautious:).
I think Cara can gain more substance as she comes out of her shell more. I like seeing growth in characters. I find it boring when they stay the same. A good character should grow. I hope to see Cara gain direction in her life and become more assertive like any person becoming an adult should do. I like Cara. She actually fits my body type preference physically more than Nikki. I just think Nikki has the better personality starting out. Cara has the petite fragile girl kinda beauty.

I hope Dani isn't another LI just shoe horned in late. We already have enough! It would be nice to introduce her to start drama with Gabi or add another layer of drama to it cause she get weirded out or upset by it. It would be nice to have a girl around that is just a friend that doesn't wanna bang us to just keep things down to earth a bit.
 

Justaphase

Engaged Member
Donor
May 1, 2024
3,598
12,566
650
I think Cara can gain more substance as she comes out of her shell more. I like seeing growth in characters. I find it boring when they stay the same. A good character should grow. I hope to see Cara gain direction in her life and become more assertive like any person becoming an adult should do. I like Cara. She actually fits my body type preference physically more than Nikki. I just think Nikki has the better personality starting out. Cara has the petite fragile girl kinda beauty.

I hope Dani isn't another LI just shoe horned in late. We already have enough! It would be nice to introduce her to start drama with Gabi or add another layer of drama to it cause she get weirded out or upset by it. It would be nice to have a girl around that is just a friend that doesn't wanna bang us to just keep things down to earth a bit.
That's the thing, Cara already was progressing and coming out of her shell on her path IMO. She starts as innocent and she's the first girl to be curious enough to have an anal scene, as well as the changes in her confidence we see.
Now Nyx seems to be planning to change her personality and make her more like Nikki from the start.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LSC82

LSC82

Forum Fanatic
Jul 27, 2020
4,026
8,963
688
I think Cara can gain more substance as she comes out of her shell more. I like seeing growth in characters. I find it boring when they stay the same. A good character should grow. I hope to see Cara gain direction in her life and become more assertive like any person becoming an adult should do. I like Cara. She actually fits my body type preference physically more than Nikki. I just think Nikki has the better personality starting out. Cara has the petite fragile girl kinda beauty.

I hope Dani isn't another LI just shoe horned in late. We already have enough! It would be nice to introduce her to start drama with Gabi or add another layer of drama to it cause she get weirded out or upset by it. It would be nice to have a girl around that is just a friend that doesn't wanna bang us to just keep things down to earth a bit.
I do think Cara grows and gains in confidence throughout the game(not just sexually), she was super shy and passive at first, which suits her lack of experience, but she grows and becomes more confident.
And she might need to become even more of a fighter once she learns the mess the MC has been up to in MS.

Making Dani a full LI would be the worst choice... hard to say, because the model is so hot, but it's the truth.
Both as a friend or a uber hot monkey wrench, she can work.

That's the thing, Cara already was progressing and coming out of her shell on her path IMO. She starts as innocent and she's the first girl to be curious enough to have an anal scene, as well as the changes in her confidence we see.
Now Nyx seems to be planning to change her personality and make her more like Nikki from the start.
Fully agree, that was already happening, she wasn't poorly written, she was fine.

But Nyx decided to make it her personal mission to enhance her popularity...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Justaphase

glaslow

Member
Aug 3, 2025
399
848
144
That's the thing, Cara already was progressing and coming out of her shell on her path IMO. She starts as innocent and she's the first girl to be curious enough to have an anal scene, as well as the changes in her confidence we see.
Now Nyx seems to be planning to change her personality and make her more like Nikki from the start.
Well they are sisters. So there is going to be some similarities. Cara is still going to like reality TV and Watch romance movies. She hasn't shown much interest in sports still or working out. We don't really know much about Nikki at her age other than her love for sports. Which we figure out comes from their Dad. Cara is Mommy's girl and Nikki is Daddies girl. Cara is just going in a different sexual kink direction than Nikki that I guess can be viewed as more daring. Nikki is way more affectionate in public than Cara.
 

Justaphase

Engaged Member
Donor
May 1, 2024
3,598
12,566
650
I do think Cara grows and gains in confidence throughout the game(not just sexually), she was super shy and passive at first, which suits her lack of experience, but she grows and becomes more confident.
And she might need to become even more of a fighter once she learns the mess the MC has been up to in MS.

Making Dani a full LI would be the worst choice... hard to say, because the model is so hot, but it's the truth.
Both as a friend or a uber hot monkey wrench, she can work.


Fully agree, that was already happening, she wasn't poorly written, she was fine.

But Nyx decided to make it her personal mission to enhance her popularity...
It's purely the case of a great girl up against too much competition, it happens. In many other VN's she could well have been a fan favourite, especially with her original hair style.

Well they are sisters. So there is going to be some similarities. Cara is still going to like reality TV and Watch romance movies. She hasn't shown much interest in sports still or working out. We don't really know much about Nikki at her age other than her love for sports. Which we figure out comes from their Dad. Cara is Mommy's girl and Nikki is Daddies girl. Cara is just going in a different sexual kink direction than Nikki that I guess can be viewed as more daring. Nikki is way more affectionate in public than Cara.
Similarities yes, but it's also okay to be different from your sibling. Many people have a more outgoing and confident sibling while they are more reserved.
Speaking about Cara's issues with her Dad, I feel like aside from feeling resentful at Nikki being his favourite there may be more going on history wise. Was there more to him losing his last coaching job? Does he have history of fucking around with his students?
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: LSC82

LSC82

Forum Fanatic
Jul 27, 2020
4,026
8,963
688
Was there more to him losing his last coaching job? Does he have history of fucking around with his students?
We know he shits where he eats right?
He's probably pumping Zach's sister on the regular and still took a trip down memory lane with Hailey...
Would he nail Tori given the chance? We know she wants to...


At first sight Cara can't really complain about him "favoring" Nikki, Cara doesn't try to engage in his activities while Nikki does.
All the way to going for a similar job to his.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Justaphase
4.40 star(s) 317 Votes