Whelp, with the hell of Scrappy's walkthrough mod I have separated my saves into 3.
1. Layla and (hopefully as a threesome) Elena only
2. Lexi, Erynn and Iris (the jealousy trio) w/ Nikki still going
3. Val and (I'm betting her aunt) Gabi (plus I kept my relationship with Cara in case this blows up in my face.)
Val and Gabi just look so much alike, but give that we've seen Val's mom, and she's too young to have a married daughter like Gabi, I'm going with Aunt. (probably on Val's father's side. Her mom is a little on the whiter side.)
I feel like these are the 3 storylines Nyx has broken it down into.
-Emily's points are pure for being a good son
-Melissa's points seem only to fuel her imagination
-Brooke seems like a forgotten side at this point with no momentum
-Sienna just feels like a cheating opportunity that will get you "End Path" moments, like Julia was with Cara/Nikki
-While I love Iris, she's a white name, which means she's not a true path. And if things workout between Emily and John, possibly she's the future step sister you banged. (like Nikki and Cara would have been), plus she's probably Erynn's sister and so on
-Tori is a non path, just a bunch of putting up with her shittyness.