Oct 10, 2022
4,348
7,783
571
And Erynn never once thought to mention to the MC who has his poster on the wall....

Not...once,....not even a passing comment...

or Alexis for that matter...hey that's my dad....

*shrugs*
I am not trying to say otherwise but I don't think Blondie-no-brains is a reliable source in any case.

Alexis was never in to MC's house before and MC took down all the posters including Zo posters at the first day. He even said sorry Zo but you are going down too or something similar.
 

Dark Silence

Devoted Member
Jul 17, 2021
9,617
14,844
811
I am not trying to say otherwise but I don't think Blondie-no-brains is a reliable source in any case.

Alexis was never in to MC's house before and MC took down all the posters including Zo posters at the first day. He even said sorry Zo but you are going down too or something similar.
Which house? His mom's? Because Alexis has been there. At least in my save.
 

Raziel_8

Forum Fanatic
Dec 4, 2017
4,828
12,684
719
Honestly, I don't think their father is anyone remotely interesting. I think is a massive red herring.

I guess we shall see..eventually heh.
Entirely possible, but then a lot of things aren't mentioned until they become ''relevant'', creating the most shock value.
That being said, i really don't care about who their father is, or about Santi, Gabi's husband, who Val's mother is...it's too boring and irrelevant to even speculate about it :sleep:
 

Jacowboy

Well-Known Member
Aug 8, 2022
1,074
1,207
286
Entirely possible, but then a lot of things aren't mentioned until they become ''relevant'', creating the most shock value.
That being said, i really don't care about who their father is, or about Santi, Gabi's husband, who Val's mother is...it's too boring and irrelevant to even speculate about it :sleep:
I'm with you... who gives a shit who the father is? that was never an interesting question, because we've always known there's no incest in the game, so it's not like it's gonna have any effect in any relationship.
 

Maviarab

Doing Mafia Helmet Things....
Donor
Jul 12, 2020
14,407
35,643
997
Entirely possible, but then a lot of things aren't mentioned until they become ''relevant'', creating the most shock value.
That being said, i really don't care about who their father is, or about Santi, Gabi's husband, who Val's mother is...it's too boring and irrelevant to even speculate about it :sleep:
This exactly. It really doesn't matter either way because ultimately, we still won't be related to them, they won't have a familial or 'legal' relationship with the girls...

So it's all fucking moot.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Raziel_8

crunchycake

Member
Jun 3, 2020
194
373
187
This exactly. It really doesn't matter either way because ultimately, we still won't be related to them, they won't have a familial or 'legal' relationship with the girls...

So it's all fucking moot.
Or... the other way around....
Because this is not an incest game, the MC has to break up with all the LI in the end and there is no "good ending":poop:
 

cxx

Message Maestro
Nov 14, 2017
76,618
39,474
1,519
Or... the other way around....
Because this is not an incest game, the MC has to break up with all the LI in the end and there is no "good ending":poop:
while nyx could do that and smile like cheshire cat while doing it she ain't that evil. besides there's nikki and cara.
 

anonnyscouse

Active Member
Jul 25, 2020
976
2,846
397
while nyx could do that and smile like cheshire cat while doing it she ain't that evil. besides there's nikki and cara.
Could actually kill those relationships by Patreon's rules pretty easily, simply have their mom forgive Andres and marry him, even though Andres is not MC's biological father he is still legally his father so if that marriage went ahead then Nikki and Cara legally become MC's stepsisters even with zero blood relation and that's against Patreon's rules.
 

cxx

Message Maestro
Nov 14, 2017
76,618
39,474
1,519
Could actually kill those relationships by Patreon's rules pretty easily, simply have their mom forgive Andres and marry him, even though Andres is not MC's biological father he is still legally his father so if that marriage went ahead then Nikki and Cara legally become MC's stepsisters even with zero blood relation and that's against Patreon's rules.
yes but nyx won't go that far.
 

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
3,690
8,033
637
Aye.



How can you people not see that would be the laziest writing ever. No one would stay quiet...there's a huge fucking poster on the wall while she has her legs spread in his bed.

I just love (like Nyx does) you try to come up with fantastical bollocks theories to make up a narrative that doesn't fit just so in your head it does fit.

Again, I criticize Nyx perhaps more than anyone here, even she isn't that lazy and/or that bad of a writer. That would be DPC levels of ridiculous plot armor.
It can't be Zo, not anymore.
He was my number 1 suspect until recently, but people need to learn to move on from their personal theories once it gets proven wrong.

Zo is Santiago's college buddy and his meal ticket into becoming an agent.
It's stated that Zo retired to be with his family.
So... he retires to be with his family, only for his college buddy and agent to steal his wife and Zo's daughters start calling him dad?
Even in a game where ludicrous things happen like this one this is simply too much.

More likely scenario is that "Mr Monroe" died when Alexis and Layla were very young and Santiago has been living with them from a young age which is why they call him "dad" without any qualifications and are very used to his presence around the house, grab his car...

Still weird that Brooke refers to them as the Monroe's, but maybe she doesn't know any better...

It will probably be something I don't like to talk about my dad cause I want you to like me for type of thing. Since knowing her dad is famous MC could treat her differently. There's a lot of indication of that. Damn Santiago is Gabi's husband and's pretty clear.

Am I the only one that thinks the foreshadowing of how they're all connected was a little bit too evident ?
I don't think Gabi is married to Santiago, here's what i think:

Santiago was Gabi's agent back in the day, that's how they met.
Santiago had a long affair with Gabi.
Gabi probably wanted/expected Santiago to drop Adriana for her(and he probably promised he would), but it never happened, Gabi has had enough so now they are broken up.
 
4.40 star(s) 314 Votes