Certainly agree that she gets off easily from Erynn. As the MC I'm ok with forgiving Alexis. She should have told MC who she is and she messed up, but I don't think she did anything really bad by him. It's Erynn who should be properly upset and take longer to forgive Alexis.Yes, a character being flawed can be a good thing
Sometimes games, not just this one, try to erase flaws a little too much, make girls "too pure" and good natured...
I don't think Alexis set out to hurt her friend, but she certainly took a risky gamble on a whim given what we are told she knows and have heard.
So while i do understand she got there by mistake and not because she deliberately wanted to hurt Erynn, i do think she gets off too easy on her path.
Although it's not clear how much Erynn really tells Alexis about her feelings. Alexis doesn't know about the blackmail or that Erynn is unhappy, which has been going on a while. Alexis might not really understand Erynns feelings before she makes a move on MC, can't remember exactly...