Ren'Py Lessons in Love [v0.42.0] [Selebus]

4.20 star(s) 297 Votes
Discussion Reviews (297)
JelF547

JelF547

Active Member
Mar 15, 2023
849
1,592
Moonflare said:
World. But I fail to see your point, as I included many other references, but you're only talking about this one. Please elaborate, maybe I missed what you mean.
Click to expand...
You werebasically saying that
1) There is a deity in LiY named Sekai, who was on the roof under strange circumstances (he was altering the world)
2) There is a character in LiL named Sekai, who was on the roof under strange circumstances (we have no idea why)
3) This makes LiY clone of LiL

Do I actually need to see other references, if first one is a garbage?
Moonflare said:
Now, I'm not about to dissect similarities because, again, I didn't like the game and barely remember it. I'd have to replay it in order to do that, and it simply didn't appeal to me. I will say though that the reason I didn't like the game had nothing to do with it being similar to LiL or anything like that, but because I had glaring issues with the plot.
Click to expand...
I get that you don't like the game, sure. Does it somehow proves that game is LiL clone? No. Neither does similar UI or even game icon.

gazgiz said:
I know I'm a lurker, and god knows I do also have my problems with this game that lives in my head rent free, but you do realize there isn't a LiL or a LiL to clone without Selebus, right?
Click to expand...
I don't get your point
 
G

gazgiz

Newbie
Nov 13, 2019
30
34
Moonflare said:
Yes, I agree with that as well. You could have cutting-edge graphics and the best game design on the market, the same themes and overall imagery, and at most you'd probably get a good porn game (which I'd play and probably have fun with btw). Or idk, something people would say "It's like higurashi or steins;gate, but with sex" or something like that.

Now, there are certainly very competent writers out there - but would there be very competent writers up to write this kind of story in the adult games genre? I'm not so sure. I hope there are. I wish for more games like this one in terms of writing. However, Selebus (the writer Selebus - not his persona or game designer) is the very reason the game is good, you take him out without a proper replacement and you get crap.



Yeah, I was appalled when I heard about what happened.
Click to expand...
I originally downloaded this game over a year ago because I thought it was a porn game. Having played though the first two chapters twice and gotten all caught up, I'm not sure I'm even willing to call this a porn game anymore?

It's a narrative that can only be told via the medium of a porn game in the same way that Understanding Comics MUST be written as a comic in order for it to make any kind of sense.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Apollo259 and Moonflare
G

gazgiz

Newbie
Nov 13, 2019
30
34
JelF547 said:
You werebasically saying that
1) There is a deity in LiY named Sekai, who was on the roof under strange circumstances (he was altering the world)
2) There is a character in LiL named Sekai, who was on the roof under strange circumstances (we have no idea why)
3) This makes LiY clone of LiL

Do I actually need to see other references, if first one is a garbage?


I get that you don't like the game, sure. Does it somehow proves that game is LiL clone? No. Neither does similar UI or even game icon.


I don't get your point
Click to expand...
Well not not when you order them in such a way that it seems LiL is copying LiY. Also look at LiL next to LiY!

Of course it's a clone!
 
Comiies

Comiies

Well-Known Member
Aug 27, 2022
1,248
2,181
JelF547 said:
You werebasically saying that
1) There is a deity in LiY named Sekai, who was on the roof under strange circumstances (he was altering the world)
2) There is a character in LiL named Sekai, who was on the roof under strange circumstances (we have no idea why)
3) This makes LiY clone of LiL

Do I actually need to see other references, if first one is a garbage?


I get that you don't like the game, sure. Does it somehow proves that game is LiL clone? No. Neither does similar UI or even game icon.


I don't get your point
Click to expand...
Its not "similar" its the same.A character model in the left of the screen,evennt and replay windows bottom right,The significance of the rooftoop(although you can techically call it a moot point) AND the use of Sekai.You can say that using the name Sekai isnt a copy paste,and you would be right.The problem comes when all of these things combine.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GR1MM, Pedro4545454, Fire Lord Zuko and 4 others
JelF547

JelF547

Active Member
Mar 15, 2023
849
1,592
Comiies said:
Its not "similar" its the same.A character model in the left of the screen,evennt and replay windows bottom right,The significance of the rooftoop(although you can techically call it a moot point) AND the use of Sekai.You can say that using the name Sekai isnt a copy paste,and you would be right.The problem comes when all of these things combine.
Click to expand...
So, what you are saying is that any game with UI similar to LiL and having character named Sekai is a LiL clone, am i right?
 
G

gazgiz

Newbie
Nov 13, 2019
30
34
JelF547 said:
So, what you are saying is that any game with UI similar to LiL and having character named Sekai is a LiL clone, am i right?
Click to expand...
They are when you put all those elements together on a school rooftop and something strange is happening in the world. And on top of it you do the whole "god God" thing, yes.

It's so obvious it's a clone that it's hard to grok how you're not seeing it?
 
  • Like
Reactions: GR1MM and Pedro4545454
Riolol

Riolol

Active Member
Jan 14, 2021
659
1,709
JelF547 said:
You werebasically saying that
1) There is a deity in LiY named Sekai, who was on the roof under strange circumstances (he was altering the world)
2) There is a character in LiL named Sekai, who was on the roof under strange circumstances (we have no idea why)
3) This makes LiY clone of LiL

Do I actually need to see other references, if first one is a garbage?


I get that you don't like the game, sure. Does it somehow proves that game is LiL clone? No. Neither does similar UI or even game icon.


I don't get your point
Click to expand...
I think his point was "I went to double check if it was a LiL clone and the first thing I saw was a character on a roof named Sekai". It's not proof on it's own but it is funny. He didn't say that's what made it a clone, he provided other examples.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pedro4545454, Fire Lord Zuko, Moonflare and 2 others
JelF547

JelF547

Active Member
Mar 15, 2023
849
1,592
Riolol said:
I think his point was "I went to double check if it was a LiL clone and the first thing I saw was a character on the roof named Sekai". It's not proof on it's own but it is funny. He didn't say that's what made it a clone, he provided other examples.
Click to expand...
So it leaves us only simillar UI. I think that guy should just open renpy without any configuration and see how it works. On advanced level, he might also think how would he make character screens and event lists (spoiler: he'd probably make them more simmilar to LiL, than to LiY)
 
G

gazgiz

Newbie
Nov 13, 2019
30
34
JelF547 said:
So it leaves us only simillar UI. I think that guy should just open renpy without any configuration and see how it works. On advanced level, he might also think how would he make character screens and event lists (spoiler: he'd probably make them more simmilar to LiL, than to LiY)
Click to expand...
There is a screenshot with "god God" in it. Are you arguing both are big Heidegger fans, and it's just a big coincidence?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Riolol
Moonflare

Moonflare

Active Member
Aug 23, 2023
989
3,487
JelF547 said:
You werebasically saying that
1) There is a deity in LiY named Sekai, who was on the roof under strange circumstances (he was altering the world)
2) There is a character in LiL named Sekai, who was on the roof under strange circumstances (we have no idea why)
3) This makes LiY clone of LiL

Do I actually need to see other references, if first one is a garbage?

I get that you don't like the game, sure. Does it somehow proves that game is LiL clone? No. Neither does similar UI or even game icon.
Click to expand...
No, I'm saying that the first save I loaded had this exact scene, and therefore I found it funny. And no, you don't have to do anything, but I'd expect you to read my post if you're going dispute what I'm saying. Cause what you're saying is "I don't even have to read most of your post, how does it even prove that the game is a clone?"

Well, I didn't say at any point it was a clone either. What I said is that it takes inspiration from it, and that my issue with it is that I found its writing to be lacking. I wasn't trying to prove any point either, I was genuinely curious after your comment and opened the game again to check. Then I presented what I found for any interested in reading, finishing by saying that if anyone enjoyed the game, I was happy for them.

I apologise if somehow you got the impression I was picking a fight with you. However, I don't appreciate you making it seem like I'm an idiot that has to be told what the word Sekai even means, just because that's an easy example to say it wasn't a reference to LiL, when I added things like this, which clearly is:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

And then, when I ask for clarification, you saying that you don't need to read my post beyond the second line to conclude all I'm saying is garbage. Anyway, I regret responding to you. I welcome being corrected when I'm wrong about something, and have often thanked people here for that. But this is not the kind of interaction I'm looking for.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GR1MM, aramaug, Pedro4545454 and 4 others
G

gazgiz

Newbie
Nov 13, 2019
30
34
When it comes to the whole "clone" thing, i just booted up Another World just to see, and instead of starting mid fall, I'm starting this game "floating".....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
4.20 star(s) 297 Votes