Antosha
Active Member
- Feb 28, 2018
- 723
- 1,289
- 347
I think what makes this feel like good writing is that Ami and Maya can each be read both ways: certainly, as you're playing through the first time, Ami seems completely oblivious (and strangely obsessed with her uncle) and Maya comes across as bitchy/tsundere and more than a bit weird. But looking at it with our current understanding of the two girls, it's also possible to see much deeper layers of intention and meaning beneath their actions. Maya is clearly playing a completely different game than we're seeing on the surface when we first meet her. That could, as Moonflare suggests, be true of Ami as well.I noticed the same situations with Ami but I interpreted them differently. To me, they were rather showing how oblivious the early game Ami is and how she reacts relatively naturally to Akira's situation (given her general character). I don't feel like she is manipulating him into any direction at all.
Some sentences and wordings do seem like foreshadowing, but in my opinion they were deliberately placed by Sel (I mentioned some of them in one of my earlier Replay posts) and not something Ami was supposed to be consciously aware of.
I'm no expert at psychology, but wouldn't you say a lot of these instances could fall under the concept of confirmation bias?
What I mean by that is that once you obtain future knowledge, looking back into the past, you jump to conclusion and interpret situations fitting a pattern that you already established in your head.
I'm not saying that all of your examples apply to that, it's possible that some of them might really be Ami being aware of resets and decides to hint at that fact. But why would she even do that? What's there to gain for her, other than risking Akira recalling prior memories and Maya becoming even more suspicious of her?
It doesn't really sit right with me and I personally registered them as either coincidences that I just forcefully connected with current theories and knowledge or simply as Sel beingan egomaniacSel who wants to prove to people who replay the game that he was so wise and mindful to hint at future events and developments early in the game.
Now in terms of Maya, definitely, she is hinting at that stuff constantly, almost teasing Akira with it in the hopes to awaken his memories and challenging him to become more than the boring niece-fucking husk of himself that she had to endure for the pastGODgod-knows-how-many cycles.
Anyways, keep the posts coming!
I will try to continue my run hopefully today as well.
Or maybe Ami is really as empty-headed as she seems at first and her later... complications are the result of other beings (Sekai, various gods, etc.) messing with her mind. I'd want to go back and compare the pre-rewrite Ch. 1 scenes with the ones we now have to see what Sel changed, to find the breadcrumbs he's laying out for us.
Or this could all be, you know, pareidolia.
Last edited: