Well, I can think of a few things:
- not everyone likes the art style, in my time on this site I have seen multiple comments that if the game is not made with DAZ some people don't even look at the game.
- the very first version of the game already turned a ton of people away from the game.
- the sandbox many people hate it.
- the general story with enslaving the girls and the tags that follow the premise.
Judging by your preferences for tags, this game is not for you and will never be. Which is fine, plenty of other games out there.
- This game is a sandbox because I've played lots of Adult VN's here and coincidentally most of them were sandbox games.
I personally like sandbox games. Nothing wrong with linear VN's either, I'm pretty neutral on the subject.
- The story is really awesome with a ton of stuff going on, it's way more than "enslaving the girls".
- It was the first version for a reason, a lot has changed since then:
• Lewd Town has 10+ locations on the town map & multiple sub-locations within each... Have fun and make your own choices where to go.
• 200+ events, 10+ hours of game-time, special hidden scenes, easter eggs, and secret endings — Spend time and build relationships with the girls you like.
• Fully uncensored lewd animated scenes — Enjoy 400+ 'mild' and 'wild' animations.
• In your down-time, there are multiple side activities — Relax with a beer on the beach, Get some action in the city alley-way, Peep on girls at the university, Train chicks for money, Mess around on your computer, and much more!
• Story-based character progression — Well-paced, entertaining storylines for each of the main characters and several side girls - will you seduce them or corrupt them?
• Diverse character designs with distinct personalities — Uniquely designed main characters and side characters with different physiques and attitudes.
• Main Story path choice - become the ultimate PIMP to tame the town's female population or be a HERO to build your own harem...
• Quality of life features — Scene replay gallery, hints journal, day/night system, cheat codes, developers very active on discord, 85 different sound-tracks, NO GRINDING for stats or cash necessary! And much, much more...
The above counts for v0.8* It will be publicly released within a few weeks.