I check updates every day and look for something I have not tried yet that has significant content so I can get immersed in the story.
My recommendation is to pick something in a genre you like and decide whether or not you strongly prefer the completed tag (which you can use as a search criteria).
The four AVNs in my sig are all good - only one is actually complete though.
I won't make more specific recommendations on this thread - going too far OT.
I will also recommend looking for people who you respect as posters - people who have the same/close to the same POV as you and see what AVNs they recommend in their signatures.
Another option is to search looking for the highest rated AVNs on F95.
One final thought - be patient and don't judge a book by its cover - there are some great AVNs that don't have top of the line graphics, but they tell a great story and/or have wonderful humor.
Sometimes you have to do the download and take 1/2 - 1 hour to really try out an AVN to see if it is something you really enjoy.
Cheers!!