This would have been a solid 4-star if it were not for its rushed endings, the wasted possibilities offered by the different characters and the disappointingly low quality of its sexy scenes.
PROS:
- Render quality is above average. There were no weird grimaces or poses, and all girls are gorgeous (especially Simone.)
- The love story with Mary builds up nicely in the beginning. The MC is neither a creep nor an asshole and allows you to relate in a way.
- The UI and menus are really polished.
CONS:
A lot. I'll summarize them.
- The story was clearly rushed in the end, leaving some questions unanswered and lacking any content with some of the characters.
What became of Mark? Did he learn about you and Mary?
Why can you go to the movies with Jessica and then she just vanishes? That choice set a variable in the script that had no impact later. She was one of the sexiest models in the game, it would have been nice to get closer to her.
- The writing was extremely superficial. Little insight into the chars' feelings, simple descriptions, sudden jumps in time that seemed repetitive, everything about the ex seemed off (did anyone think anything of what happens with the ex made any sense? The way they interact? Their "conversations"?)
Also the MC is always cold as fuck; most of the time he doesn't seem to have feelings and answers in monosyllables.
- No music or sounds. This is a minor complaint but I think nowadays all devs can grab some free music to add to their games. It helps to set the atmosphere and I personally miss it when it's not there.
- The sex scenes were, IN MY OPINION, absolutely disappointing.
The only scene I found really hot and sexy was that one with Mary when they visit her father's house. From then on all sex in this game is reduced to those crappy animations, the least exciting thing you could use in a game and the bane of my f95zone existence.
I beg all devs, please stop using shitty looped animations instead of still renders. I'm tired of saying the same thing over and over but if a dev hasn't the knowledge or the gear to produce good quality realistic animations, stick to your still renders, for God's sake! I want to see different angles, I want to see Simone slowly taking her clothes off and flaunting that ass before the action starts. I want to see more facial expression and reactions. I want to see something attractive and hot, not 2 robots fucking in a loop and then it's over.
- The endings were mediocre. Short, with almost no information, not even an extra sex scene but just a few renders and that's all.
- A replay gallery is needed. I have been using the mod linked in the OP and it's totally necessary in order to know what content you're missing. If I hadn't been using the mod I'd never have known I was somehow missing a Simone ending.
I'm guessing the dev wanted to move on to their following game and just wrapped this up the best way the could. All in all this game is OK and deserves those 3 stars but it could have been way better.
EDITED: Nasty typo