Recommending List of my favorite Honey Select 1&2 games [upd 6.11.25]

[iIIusory]

by the way, did you miss this progress report of Eternum?
Also Penelope's bubble butt...

View attachment 5170297

is Caribdis a team of devs? i jus noticed that they sometimes refer to themselves as "we"

 

[Padorublad3]

is Caribdis a team of devs? i jus noticed that they sometimes refer to themselves as "we"

afair,it's him and since 0.6 update there is another guy making animations,not sure if there is someone else

 

[Opa Wants]

is Caribdis a team of devs? i jus noticed that they sometimes refer to themselves as "we"

I know NiiChan works with him, But in what capacity I don't know.

 

[Darreau91]

afair,it's him and since 0.6 update there is another guy making animations,not sure if there is someone else

Probably including all the modders in “we” as well. He’s pretty good about giving them credit.

 

[Padorublad3]

btw,I had some features in mind,that probably will never be implemented,cuz it seems like really a lot of work to do
1.Dev trust score [0-1],where 1 means the dev never breaks any promises,doesn't milk,and creates updates asap and 0 means exactly the opossite.Raw examples:
Caribdis:1
MoolahMilk:0
Irphaeus:0.2
2.Having some exact criteria for overall score,maybe points like:

• render quality
• animation quality(visuals and a scene setting)
• sfx
• story
• story pace??
• ui
• character design(visuals and writing)
• etc

Seems like a lot of work again I would need to calculate the weights,so render quality has more impact than ui,etc

 

[iIIusory]

MoolahMilk:0

is it possible to give a negative score for him?

 

[MagnusTempestus6]

btw,I had some features in mind,that probably will never be implemented,cuz it seems like really a lot of work to do
1.Dev trust score [0-1],where 1 means the dev never breaks any promises,doesn't milk,and creates updates asap and 0 means exactly the opossite.Raw examples:
Caribdis:1
MoolahMilk:0
Irphaeus:0.2
2.Having some exact criteria for overall score,maybe points like:

• render quality
• animation quality(visuals and a scene setting)
• sfx
• story
• story pace??
• ui
• character design(visuals and writing)
• etc

Seems like a lot of work again I would need to calculate the weights,so render quality has more impact than ui,etc

Yeah, that's a lotta work, especially in the background with a de facto review for the score. Your AVN PhD should you do it I suppose

 

[Padorublad3]

is it possible to give a negative score for him?

I miss Deviant Anomalies tho After all these years,nobody made anything like this

 

[Jaike]

Yeah, that's a lotta work, especially in the background with a de facto review for the score. Your AVN PhD should you do it I suppose

I think it's a lot of effort for little pay off, and there's the risk it derails the discussion because some rando thinks this dev is a milker or that one's lazy. And Icstor doesn't use HS.

Besides I want that he writes his PhD thesis about Nancy in Eternum.

 

[srfsmrf_]

btw,I had some features in mind,that probably will never be implemented,cuz it seems like really a lot of work to do

Well, doable if you use Google Sheets for this or smthng. So you can keep your table here uncluttered, serving as a summary/overview, and ppl that are interested in more details can visit your sheet? (Did you abandon the one you were working on btw?)

Oh, a tip:

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[srfsmrf_]

Twisted memories, Isekai Paradise and Inanna Revenge are my favorite games.

I concur, Inanna Revenge is (really) cool/fun, would rank it A. My only gripe with it is that there is a certain (optional, but still) rape scene that felt (not only to me, there's some ranting about it in the thread) totally out of place/character (depending on the character you decide you want to be). I wasn't inclined picking the option, but was curious still what was behind it (leave no content behind? ), and although it was good animation wise 'n such, it was one of those 'I wish I didn't click / hadn't seen that'. I'm not ruling out dev will still address it somehow though.

IP has its charm too, definitely, but it has, say, less depth to it, and I noticed that I got a bit bored with the animations at some point. Yeah they're pretty good, but also kinda the sameish, felt a bit formulaic to me (and perhaps sex is a bit (too) easy and/or abundant). (And/or perhaps I got sea sick already? (IYKWIM )) IR does a better job in that regard I feel. I'd rank IP B.

 

[Padorublad3]

So you can keep your table here uncluttered, serving as a summary/overview, and ppl that are interested in more details can visit your sheet?

btw,did you see what happened to koikatsu list?Google just nuked it,and there is a pretty big chance something like this could happen to mine.So,google sheets are not really safe

(Did you abandon the one you were working on btw?)

yep,mostly,because I think it's not really required,since,judjing by my experience,not many people would check it out anyway.I still have it saved,so maybe someday,I will return it Now I use it only when make weekly recaps,cuz I have entires sorted by a-z order there

 

[Padorublad3]

And I also want to move Lewdcraft back to the checklist.The dev's patreon is silent for 3 months,and having like 100 renders overall you barely can call it game for now.Having it here is a bit unfair to a lot of games I didn't include
Another question is Slatford,there are a few devs making it and all of them dissappear sometimes.As I read now in ds,the main dev just left discord and probably left the team,the other devs can't say anything,so,a good game without any sex scenes after 3 updates that probably will be marked as abandoned soon makes me want it to down it to b
The next one is Maids and Maidens,here,I just want to remove it,that's it
The same goes to V.I.R.T.U.E.S.,pretty outdated fucking sandbox game,with the pretty weak setting as of 2025
And briefly,a bit updated possible tier changes:
My bully is my lover A -> S ?
Once in a Lifetime A -> S ?
Sicae A -> S ?
Between Humanity A -> S ?
Stray Incubus B -> A
Reconstruction B -> A
60 Days Of Us B -> A
Inanna Revenge B -> A

Cross Realms S -> A
Astreon A -> B?

The biggest problem with S tier is,since S is the highest tier,it has to be perfect with everything,visuals,story,etc.Cross realms,for example,doesn't match animation quality as of S tier.Games like mbml,gets much better with visuals,but at the beginning,they looked poor

 

[Padorublad3]

Changelog 23.08:
Removed:
Lewdcraft
Maids and Maidens
V.I.R.T.U.E.S.

 

[srfsmrf_]

@Padorublad3 Are all your B's actual B's now? I recall when you just set up the table you just labelled a whole bunch 'B', meaning to process them later IINM (augment the data & possibly change the tier as well?) I mean IR is an A game

-edit: oh, wait..

And yeah, S should be sparse. If you get too many, perhaps you need a 'C' tier as well? (But hey, when it's excellent, it's excellent )

 

[Padorublad3]

Are all your B's actual B's now?

weeeeellllll,you can say so.Like,there are like just a few games that should be higher.

-edit: oh, wait..

you noticed

And yeah, S should be sparse. If you get too many, perhaps you need a 'C' tier as well? (But hey, when it's excellent, it's excellent )

I also thought about it,like,I want to up that new teacher,but how it could be on the same level as sicae or mblm for example,having C tier simplifies that

 

[TRICKSTΞR]

And I also want to move Lewdcraft back to the checklist.The dev's patreon is silent for 3 months,and having like 100 renders overall you barely can call it game for now.Having it here is a bit unfair to a lot of games I didn't include
Another question is Slatford,there are a few devs making it and all of them dissappear sometimes.As I read now in ds,the main dev just left discord and probably left the team,the other devs can't say anything,so,a good game without any sex scenes after 3 updates that probably will be marked as abandoned soon makes me want it to down it to b
The next one is Maids and Maidens,here,I just want to remove it,that's it
The same goes to V.I.R.T.U.E.S.,pretty outdated fucking sandbox game,with the pretty weak setting as of 2025
And briefly,a bit updated possible tier changes:
My bully is my lover A -> S ?
Once in a Lifetime A -> S ?
Sicae A -> S ?
Between Humanity A -> S ?
Stray Incubus B -> A
Reconstruction B -> A
60 Days Of Us B -> A
Inanna Revenge B -> A

Cross Realms S -> A
Astreon A -> B?

The biggest problem with S tier is,since S is the highest tier,it has to be perfect with everything,visuals,story,etc.Cross realms,for example,doesn't match animation quality as of S tier.Games like mbml,gets much better with visuals,but at the beginning,they looked poor

Update those tier changes. They deserve it and also make Realm Invader S -> A

 

[srfsmrf_]

having C tier simplifies that

Yeah, and since it's still a list of your favorites (nothing less than 'good' right) I guess it would be something like Super - Excellent - Very Good - Good then?

Say you're going to update the table, you could perhaps consider an 'author' column (after 'title')? (Linking wouldn't be necessary though I think.)

btw: I think (within these tiers) OiaLT is A. MBimL I tried once, but kinda meh for me? (-> certainly no S) BH: good / like it, haven't played for 2 updates or smthng, not sure about 'S' though (but maybe it got reallly good... )

And I still have to play / sit down properly for Eternum...

So if Eternum is S (I believe it is alright loved OiaLT already) are those others also S?

 

[wannaseeadeadbody?]

Astreon A -> B?

it seems that the latest update really didn't delivers to everyone
however, even as a fan, it's hard for me to deny that the dialogues have become much drier, which doesn't fit, god forgive me for saying this, the cyberpunk? setting, and the characters themselves have become less engaging, what makes the game go from good to normal

upd:
although now, after a week has passed, when i thought about it again, i can say that it is still good xd

 

[Padorublad3]

So if Eternum is S (I believe it is alright loved OiaLT already) are those others also S?

Ripples and Pale Carnations are S without any doubts