LOP's main problem, which has been discussed at length, is that they're kind of skating on their past work. Too many of the stories are carbon copies of each other, the quality of their renders hasn't changed a whole lot, and as several have mentioned the gameplay hasn't improved really at all.
I was really disappointed with the Halloween with Veronica game. All of her renders had a glistening sweaty look to them . . . which if they were going for sex in a sauna would work. But, that really wasn't the vibe they were going for. The game was ultimately lame and I've seen much better renders from developers with a smaller team and fewer resources.
It's telling that
khumak's observation about Living With Temptation is literally a mirror image of comments made nearly a year ago when this thread first started.