Ah, I didn't remember that. It's a shame, as while mind reading is a neat trick, it would be nice to be able to learn some others. I guess we can hope that she was wrong ("a character said so" isn't 100% definitive proof of something, didn't she
also say she hadn't seen anything like MC before?), but it does seem less likely.
That's the thing, she's there for people that are into that, the others are there for those that aren't.
Just like not all games are for everyone, not all characters are for everyone.
If someone was asking for Claire to lose the piercings and get bigger boobs, I'd agree with you; even though I would actually
like those changes I don't expect every character to be for me. However in Amy's case, it's pretty clear that she isn't all that fond of her dick and most likely
wants to go back to having a pussy. I expect if she finds the way to turn back that she appears to be looking for, people who
are into her as she is would prefer she didn't do it.