The discussion is enough to get me through even the terribly-written boring bits like this most recent update.
Fair and true; I don't mean to sound ungrateful towards the people who DO spend the money and post updates. That's of course appreciated. And the camaraderie of having a laugh when it does get bad makes the bad more bearable, lol.
Yes that makes sense. We never did find out who paid for the original surgery Andrew went through and would the money he earnt be enough to undo everything?
Is the original surgery not being paid for by Nikos? After all, it sounds like the sisters set it up, and the "twist" was that the Doctor took it too far? After this all plays out, I'd think that unless Nikos is actually the bad guy, he should be able to afford additional surgery if Andrew wishes to it.
Going through that scene again reminded me of another question: Did we ever get an explanation of why Andrew blanked out and vision blurred during the discussion with the Doctor? I was pretty confident with my explanation of it not being a distinct Elena and Andrew but rather behavior getting "locked" into place... but this is a blackout that preceded the BIG blackout.
Maybe we've (or I've) gotten it wrong, and it's not Elena and Andrew being two different personalities. Andrew is becoming the Elena personality, and the actual split "Aphrodite" personality has stepped in to feminize the Andrew personality into being Elena?
Or I suppose the other way of looking at it is there actually is an Elena personality, but we've never actually seen her on screen. It's always been Andrew, and we've just seen stages of the Andrew personality becoming more feminized into being like Elena.
I'll say, the second one doesn't make sense to me because some of the actions of this "Elena personality" would seem to be way too early in the story. If I list the major moments where I think another personality might have taken over:
- Before the story, and did something that caused a fight between Andrew and Marina.
- During the meeting with the Doctor.
- After the surgery.
That first one would have preceded Andrew even knowing about Elena. Now, to counterpoint myself, I suppose you could argue that the Elena personality (or rather, middle aged Greek woman) manifested maybe as early as him meeting Marina. I guess that could make sense, although that starts to be on the "too many coincidences" side of things for me.
The flip side is the first idea, that there's been a female personality that has taken over a few times to "nudge" Andrew into becoming Elena, would fit with these events and explain who "Aphrodite" is... I can accept that easier than it being literally an Elena personality, but it's still kinda hard for me to swallow.
In summary, I think we'd settled on (and straight up confirmed) method acting for explaining Andrew's femininization and "integration" of becoming Elena. We'd assumed he'd gotten lost in roles before in the past, and that's what caused the argument with Marina. But we've also had another instance of him blacking out...
To be frank, I dunno. I think this theory of mine might violate Melissa saying that there's no "mind control or hypnosis" since I'm basically arguing that there's another personality that's conditioning Andrew. Yes, Andrew was at some point method acting, but the fact he can't break it once consciously aware of what's going on is a bit weird.
I have to say, with a bit of work-shopping, I'd love that story: There's a female split personality the reader doesn't know about and a real world excuse for the main character to be feminized, so the personality starts taking over at times. The main character starts noticing it's harder and harder to stop acting feminine because unknown to him, the female side has been conditioning him. That said, while I'd keep the mystery/horror element of the main character getting more and more paranoid as to why he's becoming female, the main thing I'd change is not trying to write it as if it wasn't a form of hypnosis/mind-control/conditioning and straight up embrace it being that, rather than also having a method acting explanation. I'd also have had the story not be with people immediately familiar with the main character. That way, we're not meant to have any reason to trust or not trust these strangers. And as the story progresses, he gets more and more concerned because he can't figure out who's feminizing him, with the twist being that it's been his split personality.