You know, I really want to give five stars to Midnight Paradise for one reason. The models and animations are absolutely stellar. Nicely varied models, the mother/aunt actually look older and the younger sister doesn't look 12. Every single one is incredibly hot, and that alone makes it a worthwhile investment of time.
Also, the story of Midnight Paradise is developing nicely as well. The MC has a nice arc, starting as an unlikable twit and growing through the updates. There's a central mystery that's gradually unfolding and every character has unique motivations that are woven into the plot.
Where I knock it is lack of game play growth from LL's previous game, Dreams of Desire. My gripe with that game was endless update after update, where the sex plodded along a particularly long Stairway to Heaven chain.
LL is one of a group of developers who've finished at least one major release. They're all at the top of the F95 rankings, and all their subsequent games show universal improvement in models, story, game play and pacing. Midnight Paradise has great models, a well thought out story and better game play, but the pacing is torturous and a little nonsensical.
I mean, every character has their own motivations. Mom is desperately lonely, older sis is very gradually realizing she has feelings for the MC, the younger sis has *always* had feelings, there's a crazy ex that wants to jump his bones and a sexy best friend who is crushing on him. Yet somehow, with all these different levels of accepting their feelings, they all proceed kiss, light petting, heavy petting. handjob, etc. at the same pace, such that we're at the 0.9 update and still getting hand jobs and blow jobs. I mean, why not have the sexy ex jump the MC in 0.1, so you have some fucking out of the gate? Or the younger sister says, aha, this is my chance and jumps him? Stagger out the full blown sex, with the more reluctant couplings unfolding more gradually. Ultimately, fap games are for fapping, and the pace of this one makes that pretty damn frustrating.