Ren'Py - Completed - Milfy City [v1.0e] [ICSTOR]

The fact that this slop is so popular and is highly regarded is incomprehensible. Pretty much the only and the main thing this game has going for it is models, animations and stage direction in the scenes, so i'd recommend to just unlock all the scenes with the corresponding patch, get familiarized with them and then delete this waste of time.

• World map lacks visual clarity
• Bad pacing - experience feels boring, unrewarding and uneventful most of the time
• Unfinished character stories and their lack of impact on the environment - for example Delilah. Your ridiculous bets with her produce no reaction nor consequences on the surroundings and the worst thing is, when her story is at it's climax and is about to take a romantic turn - it just ends and she literally disappears from the game and all we get is an embarrassing motivational speech from "Chad" character. All other characters, events and interactions exist in complete vacuum
• Speaking of "Chad" - for how much there is literary content (simply put - text), the game has way too much 4th wall breaking and cringe comedic dialogue
• Time management (sandbox) part of the game is boring and is just a waste of time
• Audio bugs out and tracks start overlapping themselves
Following claims may be subjective, i don't care:
• Way too much foreplay - you have to grind through like 50 blowjobs, thighjobs, footjobs, buttjobs, boobjobs and so on, before seeing the main action
• Way too many lesbians and sexually ambiguous characters
• Way too much femdom

Overall: bad writing, bad pacing, bad design, lots of blue balls, feels unfinished, looks good tho.

Just the GOAT, all in these game is very nice, the animations, the history, the characters, ALL, just give a oscar to icstor for this game, really.
It's for me, a game to everyone plays, this game come me to this " world " of +18 games, it's my favorite off all time, rlly? No questions, JUST PLAY...

Kind of a meh story, with bad pacing, and zero relationships between characters, mind-reader storytelling is always stupid since it acts like a spoiler, kinda of broken translation maybe, every character has the same style of dialog or monologue makes every character feels like the same being, and became boring pretty fast.

Secret cards feel like a spoiler, they just burn their time on that render instead of making the story and dialog more interesting.

The only good thing is just the CG, that's it.

The game has great renders and animations without any coding errors. It has a straightforward storyline involving incest and various fetishes. There's also gameplay with secret cards and tasks, making it interactive.

I understand the frustration in many negative reviews due to the developer's broken promises and excuses. However, up until version 0.5, it was undeniably outstanding.

Many players felt let down after eagerly awaiting updates. Linda and the other girls are undeniably attractive, which boosts the game's appeal.

The problem started when the developer, Icstor, initially delivered five attractive characters but then realized that frequent updates might not bring in as much income, especially with new patrons pledging regularly. As a result, he disappeared for a long time, first promising a complete edition but then releasing updates in small doses, likely to maximize revenue.

While I understand his business strategy, I can't fully support his actions.

Despite these issues, as a game or visual novel, Milfy City offers a very satisfying experience for its intended purpose.

i had this review waiting for while now. thought id wait fr a finished version so here it is. still a 5* game.

Despite it being sandbox, this is one of the hottest games ever made. the girls are incredible, the sex scenes are amazing there's plenty of content great choices of camera angles. the story is whatever but who really cares it gets the job done. can't wait to see whatever this dude makes in the future

Well, I really liked this game. Renders are excellent. I really like that you gave choice whatever to develop relationships with characters or not, or maybe partially develop (make a revenge for example, but not develop further).

I usually don't like pointless clicking on the map with dozens of empty locations, but you make it right. I wait for continue. Personally, I like Sara the most, but I also will wait for Macy's and neighbor girl's routes too.

I have played many VN but this game one of the best among many. Great game play, excellent graphics and an awesome story line. I think this is the best game by ICSTOR so far. Keep it up guys ......Great Work

I gotta say, the writing and dialogue in this game are fantastic! Not to throw shade at other authors, but using proper grammar really does make for a better gaming experience. Who knew, right? The artwork and renders are top-notch, with an impressive level of detail. No performance issues here—the animations were smooth as butter. It’s clear they put a ton of effort into this game, and it totally shows. Big kudos to the entire ICSTOR team!

This was the first adult game I ever played. Also, in the recent past, this game was a bit of a hit.

Its development was great, with good characters and excellent female character models, but its conclusion, wrapped up in a series of problems with the creator, was disappointing, with female characters not being used much or with a rushed ending.

Even so, I still think it's an average game.

One of the most disappointing "completed" games.

Some characters had way more development put into them and it shows. A lot of characters routes end suddenly without any kind of satisfying closure which was incredibly annoying. Some characters felt like their route was meant to be twice as long but got cut half way without changing anything else.

It's sandbox elements and minigames are tedious and unrewarding. Other games have done both much better.

I didn't like the MC of this game much at all but stuck through only to be disappointed as he experienced next to no growth. All that changed was him drowning in pussy suddenly for no reason.

This game does a lot of things but other games beat it by a good margin in those same things. There are better sandboxes, better incest games, better games with a school setting and so on.

Some people will be able to enjoy this but to me it's just a let down and is undeserving of the attention it has received over the years.

Some nice animations and the girls are rendered very well but the game now feels incredibly outdated with it's sandbox elements and offers the most barebones of story.

MC looking like a child puts me off and the mini games are pretty tedious, you're best off just downloading a 100% save file and watching the sex scenes to be perfectly honest.

The creator of this game pretty much gave up with this and shoehorned in an ending to appease his patreon's after basically releasing nothing for almost a year and it tells.

Not bad but a little disappointed. I feel like the game was abandoned before it was actually finished. For some characters, you have to go see them several times even several days and others, where there is not much and it ends quite quickly.

grindy, animation is good, story pretty mid the characters are nice tho
incest is good teacher arc boring

just rating it to have it on my profile

3.5/5 not gonna play again

not very memorable

Sister was very hot

Sorry, but the story and gameplay is just poor. I'm not very sure what exactly is the story about, with no actual endings with any of the LIs. Characters are one dimension, with little to zero character growth and development. Also, for Delilah's path, you would always lose > train > win, three times over, and that's just pretty stupid to me.

Pros:
-Some animated scenes
-Able to go after any LI that you want
-Some music
-Mini games are okay

Cons:
-Boring and uninteresting story
-Lack character development
-Some girls just lacks scene/progression
-Stupid MC

A sandbox game where you do the usual leveling up of relationships.


It being a sandbox, that inevitably lacks story, immediately takes away 2 stars for me. The way I see it the ideal VN is a bit like a 'Choose your own adventure' book, only with added sex and varieties of kinks. Trying to make up for the lack of an engaging story with fun gameplay is a lost cause because then its competing with conventional videogames, and it will always fall short in comparison. Unfortunately this game IS a sandbox...

But for a sandbox it might be one of the best ones out there. The mini-games weren't too bad and other aspects like graphics, dialog (there wasn't really any depth, but the english is fine) keep the game afloat at average rating.

This probably used to be one of the best games in production (started in 2018?) but since then others have raised the bar substantially.


I do recommend this, but only to those who can stomache a sandbox (now I'm imagining someone diving headfirst into a sandbox to eat its contents).

The game is good however the story is missing at the end and isn't really complete. That's the only problem with it.

H-scenes are good and animations are good as well. Without the money cheat it is more than a bit of a grind.

Overall 4/5 or 7.5/10.

Pros:

Incest story and also a little bit of blackmail with the female teacher.
The sex scenes in this game are really good, and the bodies of
the characters are very lifelike, tits are normal size and while the
mother has very large breasts they are not the gigantic breasts
of ridiculousness often seen in games that look like massive
amounts of helium in ginormous overinflated balloons.


Sex scenes are not the typical quick wham bam thank you
mam either, as they are built up slowly telling a story and when
the MC finally does the deed you are left thinking he finally did with
[insert female character name] so it's a good build, and the scenes
are long and played out.

Sandbox element makes it even more fun to play, since you get
to run around on the map to various places such as to college, the sex
shop for toys, the store for a webcam or wine etc.

And at 9.5 GB you're going to get a long game.

Cons:

I'm disappointed in some aspects of the game, I feel MC sister
Sara was under utilized, I honestly expected a lot more content
from her, there was a large amount of content with the Mother
but not much from Sara, more story could have been utilized
like maybe ice skating with Sara, bowling with Sara, going
to the movies with Sara etc. And showing a deeper connection.
If I'm not mistaken there are a total of 2 times MC has
vaginal sex with Sara before her story ends.

Main Character's neighbor was another area that was done
poorly, he knocks on her door meeting her several times
for her to announce sorry I'm a lesbian and I don't want
your dick, then content for character ends with him doing
nothing with her. This was strange, as we all know guys who
a crush on their next door neighbor, but the developer chose not
to go this route and have her appear several times only to say no
dice and for her character to be closed.

Story 2/5
Well not really sure if there is main story at all, its more alot of short novels with each LI with no real endings to them, which is the main reason i cant rate this higher, it just feels pointless and unfinished.

It does promiss that you can go after what ever girl you want and this seem to hold true which supprised me alot, normaly most sandbox game dont offer this kind of freedom and your normaly forced to follow a set kinetic questline where LIs are locked untill you progress in some set order, but it dosent seem to be the case here, i went with the sister and sister only and it worked fine, so it does seem like girls each has their own story that you can choose to follow or not.
But that comes with a price to and thats very short stories for LIs and no endings which is really what kills the hole game.

I did the sister and after you fuck her 2 times i belive story is done, it ends with MC and sister talking about how hot it would be for the sister to become pregnant and then story ends, leaving you with a meh feeling thinking was that really it....
Same with Dee you just leave her crying on a bench after fucking her and talking to her....i mean whats the point of the stories if none of them as any kind of real ending....It just feels unfinished and rushed.

When sister story is done she tells you, you can always call her to your room or come visit in hers, but you cant call her and going to her room is just some boring options where you cant even fuck her? feels like dev forgot to put in repeat scenes for that, i also couldent find a way to get those extra dialogs with her after her main story finished, phone has a lock on it so no clue.

One thing that was annoying is all the talk about pregnancy without it being in the game, its a huge fail talking about it and how risky it is cuming inside when there is 0 chance of getting anyone pregnant, they really should have added that to the game when making it such a big deal in dialogs.

For the virgin/deflower fans its not the best scene since you see MC fucking her but 0 blood untill later when sis ask for him to check and he dick is covered in blood, which is a bit weird considering hes going in and out and you see hes dick clean while he does that, but atleast they did remember to put some blood in the scene even though its a bit of a werid way of doing it, it almost feels like it was added after making the scene where they forgot about it first then tried to fix it.
The second virgin scene with Dee was a big fail, talks about her hymen but 0 pain 0 blood so yeah not great just a normal sex scene.

Girls 3/5
I would like to see a better diversity in builds, for some idiotic reason most devs thinks a milf has to have big/huge tits but heres a free hint, tits dont grow one stop untill they are considered milfs....but yeah....in any case there are a few normal/small tits girls atleast but main focus is big tit fetish in this game which just isent my thing its just one turn-off after the other, but i did enjoy the few normal girls atleast.

Animations 5/5
They really are some of the best ive seen, very nice BJs and face movements and good sex scenes as well.

Music 3/5
Its ok just background stuff nothing special or great in any way, but its good enough so it dosent get to annoying to listen to.

Choices or maybe i should say Sandbox 4/5
Well its not really choices since its more do questline or dont do questline with a girl, doing some questlines you can lock out some girls if you want to stay faithfull, which also seems a bit weird since doing other girls quest after a faithfull run with the sister you wont stay faithfull at all, so they really are just small seprate stories for each girl where a few side girls i guess can be tied into the main girls questlines if that makes any sense.

If the stories had real endings game could proberly be 5 stars, but doing girl after girl and see no ending ruins the hole point of playing which is why i cant give this more then 2 stars since its mostly just a waste of time reading a story that just stops in the middel of nowhere.

Visually the girls are good, and there are variety in their stories.
What is most lacking is the story : as a sandbox game it's expected that the story will be the weak point; but here, it goes well beyond "weak point" : the story is like a number of chapters from a book depicting a life of someone and their love interest. No conclusion, no feeling of achievement when you play all.
Basically, it's missing the fullfillment part of the story after an introduction and long journey.

Also, the mini games are usually useless and repetitive in their core concept, and I don't really understand why have so much of them, or the respective length of each time it has to happen.

One of the OG games of AVN genre. Even though it has beautiful characters, great animations; this game fails at story and character development. I finished this game twice, the second time was to make a decent review. Characters are one layered and they all want to have intercourse with MC without we even try to do anything. That is a huge turn-down for me because I generally like stories where you can build relationships that evolves around the storys.

Also the game is grindy I mean huge grindy. I don't like using cheats so this review is based on a person who plays the game like the developer intendet.

Even though I make some harsh feedbacks, if you are into AVNs, this is a must have played game.

This games lewd scenes and the pace to chase them was draining me!
I love this game!
It is hard incest and I would love to see an continuation done by INCSTOR ...
Or another masterpiece like that

Lewd 5/5
Graph 3.8/5
Story 4/5

This:
"It's hard to describe, but time is a lot like a car sitting at the top of a hill with the handbrake left off.
One day, that car will start to move. It'll begin rolling its way down the hill. At the start, it'll be slow and steady. Yet, with each passing minute it'll become faster and faster. A person's perception of time grows faster as they grow older. Each year goes quicker than the last.
Firstly, make plans for yourself, and commit to doing them before it's too late.
I envy how each minute you spend with me, feels longer than the minutes I spend with you."