Ren'Py - Completed - Milfy City [v1.0e] [ICSTOR]

Great game, although it's story is kinda lacking. Scene are good and characters are great. It would be better if all of the weekend events were repeatable, and if it were an "easier" way to grind the money events (towards the end, it's kinda draining to repeat the mini game for 100th time)

The intial premise is not a bad one, however the structure and the writing itself is unenjoyable. The main character grandstands a lot, I feel how the MC is written is cringeworthy and i don't use that terminolgy often. I have played since early on with hopes that it would get better but ended up disappointed. The MC character acts like a childs wet dream. He is very dislikable. they storylines themselves have potential but with how they are written involving the MC, I find myself rolling my eyes. I'm not looking for a super indepth character when it comes to MCs but at least add some substance and make it seem like it is not just some loser's fantasy. For example just look at the whole delilah and older sister storylines. Hell even the aunt and neighbor. I think that if the game started as the MC who doesn't know much, but then expands his knowledge on how to talk and interact with women it would be better. All in all the only reason i kept coming back was the model. The female were very attractive and that's is why i did't give it a 1.

You are motivated me to develop games with some others games (nlt media, summertime saga etc.) I think this game is brillianf of nsfw games. It is surprised for me that have only 3 stars rating. Nice plot, characters, locations. Absolutely love your work!

Overall - 7/10
Very hot models + renders + animations save this game - everything else is kinda meh
Go around helping women progressing with their plots -> sex -> help -> loop. Not much logic, but porn game with good images + animations brain like.
Must use mod - from infinite money to know where you have to go to progress
Story - 4/10
MC - inconsistent thinking, but can do no wrong -> all women like you
All characters have their storylines - help them -> sex -> loop
Some much better than others, overall still kinda meh
Nothing really captivating -> skipped/fast skimmed through most of it
Renders/models - 9/10
Characters and game looks amazing. best part of game easily (Caroline in particular)
Animation/Hscenes - 8/10
Smooth animations + hot models
Mostly vanilla stuff, some sprinkled bdsm
No moans or sloppy sounds just BGM
Sound - 4/10
simple bgm + sfx - could've been a lot better
Playability - 4/10
MOD REQUIRED - Location + time to progress a characters' storyline
Uses time: Morning, noon. evening and night -> annoying thing many things occur at the same time. A lot of skipping time and sleeping to progress. Also weekend events only can do 1 per weekend.
Simple puzzles, no combat.

Pros

1. Excellent quality of image renders. Highlighting the skin tone flaws at elbow and knee for the elderlies are too realistic.
2. Excellent quality of animations. Overall quality of renders and animations is pretty damn high.
3. Huge content with lot of female characters of various attitude.
4. Sound: Fairly good; more focused on door operating sound mostly.
5. MC’s worry / reluctance about his father being betrayed is impressive but we players are forced to do so.
6. Females lip biting expressions are well expressed.

Cons

1. Incest approach with mom being bit casual, no impact, not so effective. Generally, mom’s reluctance to give-up the morality will be more effective/interesting; unfortunately, we miss that in this story/game.
2. Clashing of schedule is lot; waste of time and leads to frustrations. Luckily some of the schedules are able to perform two events.
3. Navigation to various location is not so effective; needs to click a lot. Restricting the map activeness is limited to certain location only is not good.
4. Some sound needs improvement; for example, most of the cases the scene change will end up with door closing sound; but such sound must be eliminated for sneaking actions like MC sneaking to his parent’s room in night also end up with such sound is no logic.
5. Some BSDM being unavoidable is not good.
6. Playability/performance: Often the change scenes are pretty slow, as well the starting of the game (while launching the game) is damn slow.
7. Huge number of hidden cards which doesn’t give any value / purpose.
8. Lack of seductiveness in sexual approach.
9. Some error for me that I couldn’t get the ‘Mom’s week end event’ – Maybe it’s due to the cheat (by 0x52_URM) I used.

- About the story, let's be honest this story is just to have fun and laugh about it, its different plots are not to be taken seriously, except for maybe Delilah's plot (the best one IMO) and for some reason the developer decided to cut it short, xD I can only imagine what happened through the developers minds "Hey... this is getting too interesting and too serious... fuck no! lets cut it short!" xD.

- MC's behaviour is inconsistent. At times He is bold, very confident and other times he becomes shy for stupid reasons. Girls are average, but they look good.

- Renders and animations are great.

- Music / Sounds: I liked most of the tunes.

- Playability: I like Sandbox games and I think it was properly implemented here. I liked the idea of looking for secret renders, also the minigames (most of them).

- Others: I'm not sure if this game should be tagged as "COMPLETED", I mean... Main Plots were clearly rushed with a lot of loose ends and other plots were just cut short.

Overall I'd give this game a 7.5/10, despite its issues I laughed a lot due to its ridiculous plots with good animations and nice playabilty.

Initially showed a lot of potential, before the dev became unpredictable. The post hiatus update seems rushed or not in the same creative level as before it.

I mean my watch thought I was having a heart attack when I was playing through Linda lifting Sara's skirt in the kitchen.

Some of the harem routes should have been built as teased.

I had pretty much dropped this game off the radar after dropping my patreon sub for ICSTOR. The guy could not meet a single deadline he committed.

Still think had it not been Onyx, this would have never been complete.

Navigation is not the best I've seen, but the game is really responsive.

I have no hopes for Milfy Mafia

When this came out it was the GOAT. Amazing animations, models, the works.

At about the 4th update the dev lost steam and the next ones were...painful.

After the 6th or so he completely gave up.

The game right now plays like an amazing beginning with a terribly disappointing end. For me it'll always be a 1/5 because of how much we loved it and how badly it let us down, but I'm trying to be objective - it's still pretty ok.

Graphics still great, has aged well, the minigames are bearable, most of the storylines are readable, totally fine I guess.

To be honest, I frickin fuckin love it really much!

I wish the developer of the game still making updates to the game but luckily I saw their post that they going to release the Impregnant update and more exciting updates (I'm really crazy psycho for it nah Just kidding) I'd play the game straight but now I didn't finish it still but some character of them I finished them. I like his Sister and his mother. Very hot and sexy it feels like Harem really Harem every girls in the town has a interested with on you. (God I wish that was me)

Big kudos to ICSTOR

This was the first VN I ever played, and it’s where I fell in love with this type of game.

I even made sure to give a special shoutout to ICSTOR in my own game.

Playing Milf City was an awesome experience. Big thanks, ICSTOR!

Cons: Numerous unresolved plot points, characters all over with majority of them not interesting minus a few (Caroline is the best of them all), numerous delays to the point I feel the dev was milking supporters, and some characters who look and feel generic.

pros: great animations, great music, the hot AF Caroline as well as her story, funny moments, deep emotional moments, and great dialogue.

due to the dev’s history as well as an unsatisfactory ending that feels more like the dev just stopped caring about all these plots, I can’t give it a high rating.

I've recently did another play-through of this after discovering that v1.0e had been released. I think the one I previously played was v 0.7 and I wanted to see what was added in the final release. I've loved this game the last time and to my surprise it was also by one of my top favorite artists/developers of all time icstor (which somehow I didn't notice before).

Anyway the last time I'd played I maybe didn't notice the Mother was so set on fucking MC from the beginning. I think I remember her attitude towards his being more ambiguous but maybe I'm misremembering it (since most other games of this type go the route of you having to somehow move the love interest into fucking you). I actually think it might be better if we couldn't literally read her mind at least early on.

I was not really a fan a Sarah's story before but now I completely hate it. She went from being really insecure to paranoid psycho. And actually I like the Lily path much better than Sarah's. (I followed the walkthrough/cheat mod's suggestion in not cheating but was able to play Lily's path on the "computer".)

I loved the added Judy, Celia and Violet content. I also enjoyed the new Delilah stuff too. I was disappointed that Sidra/Isla story was jettisoned. I really would have loved to see that one finished.

This time the ending with Linda/Bob really grossed me out. I think I remember this from my last time too but I wish there had been an option to have him just leave the house permanently or something.

I noticed when playing this time that the dialog kind of tries to be cleaver and funny but over does it a bit. I enjoy humor in these porn games but only if it's actually funny and doesn't get in the way of the porn. This time I think the dialog got in the way, quite often, even for parts of the game a previously enjoyed.

I think Cindy's dialog make her just too stupid and hard to be attracted to. Which is a shame because I always thought she seemed like a cool counter-cultural character. Also the even though I like the lily path more than the sarah one it does make the MC seem like moron.

All in all it's still a great game and I love all additional the scenes in it but I can't give this 5 stars.

This game had a chance to go down as one of the all-time classics. Instead it will go down in infamy as one of the all-time disappointments.

Milfy City gained a large following due to its renders and visuals being ahead of its time and featured some incredibly sexy character models–most notably, Linda and Caroline. The story was nothing special, but for a porn game it got the job done.

Unfortunately, as time went on, this game lost its luster (that's putting it kindly if you're familiar with this game's notorious development history) and is not worthy of the “completed” tag it currently has. The storylines for many of the characters are unfinished. There is no harem route even though the banner image for the game shows the MC with the three main love interests lying together in bed naked. Clearly corners were cut in trying to get this game “completed” and it is painfully evident throughout the playthrough.

As it stands, the only reason to play this game is to see the sex scenes with Linda and Caroline. Skip everything else.

Hopefully the legacy this game leaves is a cautionary tale not to be followed or duplicated by any other game devs.

Oh what could have been.

This game started my journey into the adult game foray. i had to double check the completed tag as i couldn't believe! Caronline is the best girl, she is the sister while linda, the hot mom is incredible herself! The story is blah but the renders and the animations are amazing. the music is catchy too. Its a sandbox, although im sure there is a vn version floating about. 5/5 game!

Despite being a completed game with hours of content, this game does not FEEL complete. There are some storylines that are thorough, but there are some that are thin, and others that are blatantly unfinished (the next door neighbor for example). You can also see some of the ladies got way more attention than others, and that sucks... It should be equal distribution imo. There is also a tease of a harem, but that never happens, so I don't know what the point of that was.

I feel the scope could have been lowered a bit so I didn't feel wanting closure from half the storylines...

In the end the game was still enjoyable, but also very tedious with the poor navigation and constant menu-ing.

It's not the cream of the crop for porn games, but it's worth experiencing at least once I think.

Great graphics. Good animation. Good story. Beautiful locations and city. Not a bad protagonist. Bad sex with other men.
Bad, too many women with little plot and sex. There is no big grind of relationships with girls and money.

Congratulations! From the moment I started playing your game, I could tell how much care and effort went into creating it. The mechanics are incredibly smooth and user-friendly, and the graphics look fantastic. I especially appreciate how well you've crafted the atmosphere. Every detail of the game seems to be thoughtfully considered, offering an immersive experience that draws players in completely.

Moreover, I was truly impressed by the depth of the storyline and the way the characters were developed. The plot is engaging, and the missions keep the excitement alive at every moment. The difficulty level is also perfectly balanced—neither too easy nor too hard, offering just the right amount of challenge. The sound effects and music complement the game’s atmosphere beautifully.

Congratulations again on releasing such a successful game. Your team has done an outstanding job. I’m eagerly looking forward to seeing what you create next. I’m confident that this game will be talked about for years to come and will leave a lasting legacy. Once again, well done on this amazing achievement!

I've never seen better asses in a game than in this one, the story progression and animations, renders and the gallery are excellent too. I hope there are some dlcs to come this is my top 2 game easy .

I played the game several years ago and thought it was good and now having played it i got to say the endings for most of the characters just suck and feel rushed and I found it ridiculous I had to install a mod to restore content so I cant really say how the base game is without it but its kinda stupid its needed the scenes are great and I like the characters but the ending ruins it

For what is here I'd say this was well made. If you enjoy these particular fetishes/kinks it is worth playing up to the point where it becomes obvious that development on this game seems to have ended before it should have. It was an ambitious undertaking and there is a lot to love, but honestly I got a bit burned out once the MC becomes an Alpha male. I much preferred the early stages of the game (when he wasn't fucking them all, all the time). The sexual tension was well done and I found it more erotic than the constant sex that inevitably cums later.