Ren'Py - Completed - Milfy City [v1.0e] [ICSTOR]

++ Good renders. The women are consistently hot.
- Laughably bad story
- MC is an asshole
- bare bones gameplay/mini-games

No updates for over a year. Creator working on a new game. Make your own assumptions.

Held out playing this for almost a year hoping for an update but it's still a great incomplete game with plenty of content. I would give this a 4.5 out of 5. The animations,characters and art are top quality.

It's been a while since I played Milfy City and there are few games where I still remember the plot or the characters. Despite a long wait to receive an update, I must say that even if we have to wait a few more months I can't wait to continue playing this game because I know ICSTOR will make its game a little diamond. He will just have to polish this diamond to make it a little jewel. The renderings are more than correct and being able to travel around the city is just as interesting. Even if at the moment we don't really know what to do in order to follow the plot.I am keeping my hopes alive that in 2021 this game will be finished.

Good game, Nice image and full of animation,great character on this game and good story but something problem in this game,great in the first year but late about a update on next, i dont know whats happen, but keep make a good game. thanks

Do I need to say why I gave it a 1 star? The game hasn't been updated in a year, and the game itself isn't that entertaining, most of the character's stories were boring. The main cast and character you can currently romance are pretty uncreative. One's just a normal classmate who games too much, and the gaming isn't even used as a creative gameplay feature, the mom's storyline made my uncomfortable, and the teacher plotline is just weird. Edit: forgot to mention Caro best girl by far

Definitely in the Top 5 of this generation even though the developer sometimes shits the proverbial bed in terms of updates. The characters are really well done in both appearances and personalities and there is a lot of content and mini games to keep you occupied and wanting more . Caro best girl

Top Tier Game with Update Issues

This review is for newcomers to the site. I discovered lewd games this year and couldn't believe how wonderful they could be. Milfy City is definitely a top 5 game on the site because of its incredible renders and animations - nothing comes close.

The story isn't anything groundbreaking, but it gets the job done.

The big problem that most users have especially the og supporters are the inconsistent and slow updates. There's been a lot of promises and failure to live up to those promises - but the majority of that in my opinion is ICSTOR having these really strict expectations, not quite making them, and working through the feelings of not meeting expectations. In the creative world, it's very easy to get pressured and depressed with failure since adherence to fidelity constitutes a lot of art.

That being said, the responsibility does lie on the Milfy City team to figure out how to handle timing and announcements to fans - that's just part of the business.

In the end, this is a game you absolutely need to play through, but it comes with the caveat that you need to be okay with missing content and not knowing what the future holds for the project.

Great graphics, and beautiful wording intertwining with a gripping story line. It doesn't matter who's story you want to pursue first, you will end up falling in love with the main characters . I would also recommend downloading the walkthrough, it does get a bit confusing if you try to jump between characters instead of focusing to one and completing it.

I've been keeping myself from this game for a couple of months, since I discovered it. I didn't know the reason of hype around it. But now I know

In a simple way it's a very cool, entertaining, funny and hot game, which will bring you tonns of fun !

I've enjoyed Caroline's story at most. It doesnt mean the other characters aren't good, she just has the Throne as for me.

It's a pity, developer can't/doesn't want to work on this masterpiece more.

This game got me hooked up for good. I admit it's my first Ren'Py title, but i loved it so much that i'm sure it won't be my last. I think it's a nice way to get introduced in this type of games. The story is very well written and rarely got me annoyed or bored. Renders are stunning and characters are very unique. I just hope that it gets finished and not abandoned as it looks like it's going to be..

This is without a doubt my top 1 game. The scenes, the characters, but without a doubt the scenes are incredible. This game has enormous potential, the work in here is beyond incredible, congratulations! I'm looking forward to the next update.

Pros:
- The art style is great, Caroline is probably the hottest girl I've seen in an adult game so far.
- Lots of different girls for you to pursue.

Cons:
- Incomplete, with no update in sight (at the time of this review)
- Not as linear as I'd like, you end up clicking through events to pass time.

Honestly I came across this VN a long long time ago. Got as far as you could go, and then waited until last December for new content. Played that and, just like every one else, have been waiting for almost another year for more.
PROS
Beautiful women
Nice renders
CONS
MC is pretty much a spinless character
Way to many under construction areas for being this long in development
Subpar story
Overall
I believe I started my play through sometime at the end of 2018. I could be wrong. But even so, a year since the last update is kinda long. I'm not knocking the dev. Maybe there were life things that have been preventing regular updates. I'm just giving my opinion here. I honestly got frustrated beyond measure with the MC. Tossing in a way to make more money would be pretty beneficial as well. Any way, I wish the dev the best of luck with this VN.

I like the game and enjoyed it so far, but being objective... this isn't that good. To keep it simple, if you are looking for a "good game" (good storytelling, good dialogues, etc) this is not your game. On the other hand, if you are looking for a quick-fap, unless you unlock the gallery (or just use the glorious Lain's Mod, which COMPLETELY saved the game for me)... this may not be your game neither.

Although renders are a solid 8-9/10 (animations could be 6.5/7 I think), the game absolutely lacks coherence, The relationship forged between MC and his family is JUST ridiculous. Caroline is by far my fav model, but the way MC and she interact is just not realistic. Dude, you can't fall in love for someone in such a derp way. The same goes for Sarah, who is just a geek that SUDDENLY craves for MC's dick. Not to mention Linda is ALREADY craving for D since min 1. Lmao.

I could say more things about the game, like the unnecessary grinding (which I avoided this 2nd time playing cause Lain's Mod. Seriously, worth every second) or the MC's senseless behavior... But let's keep it here.

I know this is an fap-only game and looking for emotional deepness is quite unfair. In my last review (BT The Manor), this was easily avoided cause the developer never gave romantic/narrative value to the family relationships.

In short, looking for some plastic coochie? Go, grind and end up fucking the girl in the most vanila way. As I said, renders are still A tier .

It's a beautiful and polished game. There are lots of activites, characters are well designed and animations are very good but unfortunately it's incomplete and seems that it will remain that way. Still enjoyable though.

Should easily be rated a 5. I normally break everything into segments but I'll just quickly summarize as The Dev of this game only deserves minimal effort and minimal responses as he only gives minimal effort and minimal responses to his patrons. Graphics, Scenes, Animations, and Characters are all the best on this site. Linda alone could have her own game with her sexy dirty dialogue during the porn scenes, the fact shes madly obsessed with you, and definitely the fact she a cuck queen who will share you with other girls and she doesnt giive a crap if you bang her in front of her hubby. Her situations are the hottest of any game I've ever played and that combined with her design....SHES PERFECT. So is Sara. AKA all the Characters are memorable.

The problem is The Dev. This game should honestly be finished by now. Last year saw virtually no updates. One of which he didn't even add the animations until later. He will ghost his fans in a heartbeat, barely responds. Always has bizarre trivial excuses. I MEAN ALL THIS AS A MEANS OF CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICSM BECAUSE DEV IS OTHERWISE EXTREMELY TALENTED PLEASE DO NOT DELETE. I want him to improve so I can Patron him. Its his first attempt at the RenPy engine from what I understand so Im not going to be negative or too picky. Game mechanics are grindy but not so bad with a walkthrough. If the Dev doesn't abandon this game from "BOREDOM!!!?" Ill change my review score. But I think it reflects not only the game but also the cliffhanger roller coaster ride this game has been for the last 2 years.

Near perfection, I go back to this game when all the newly released content from other games do not get me to the finish line. This is of one the best! I found myself rushing through the content in order to see what would happen next the first time through. Now I go back and play it slowly and BOOM. I really can not complain.

A good looking girl is a big plus.
But don't expect much other than that.
Story told too many times is a red light for me.
If you still say this is my ship then with a little search, you can find better games for your taste.

a juggernaut under the erotic games and the one of the most famous its a starting game for many new users its also compromised everything an eroctic game should have

story excitement
girls being sluty but shy
a sick MC who represents us
a good pace which slowly arouses you
not just sandbox you have to do something to get the reward so its not boring
the most important the animation its soo good and detailed you cant get enough
and it makes you want more and you hate it when it ends

overall icstor is one of the greatest game developer and I cant wait more of his work

Had it been 1 year ago I would have given 5 stars without thinking about it, but in the long run the ICSTOR project is turning out to be a Hunter X Hunter of erotic games. The success of Milfy City is mostly tied to the detailed and well-curated animations that are a nice slap in the face to the other games where the fucking has 3 and a half frames.
The second point is the girls. Space babes that make you want to stick your dick in the LAN port and cum inside.
Caroline is my waifu so I'm a little biased but oh well.
Now try to put the animations of an average game that is on F95 on Milfy City and you will get the cosmic nothing. The plot is non-existent and the incest ban (To which you can put a patch thanks to the Incest Patch available in the thread), takes away even more from the game.

Bottom line ... if ICSTOR were less choppy, MC would be the GTA of erotic games. But to date he doesn't deserve to be in the TOP 3.

#TeamCaroline

--

Per gli italiani:

Fosse stato 1 anno fa avrei dato 5 stelle senza pensarci su, ma a lungo andare il progetto di ICSTOR si sta rivelando un Hunter X Hunter dei giochi erotici. Il successo di Milfy City è legato perlopiù alle animazioni dettagliate e ben curate che sono un bello schiaffo agli altri giochi dove lo scopate hanno 3 frame e mezzo.
Il secondo punto sono le ragazze. Delle sorche spaziali che ti fanno venire voglia di infilare la cappella nella porta LAN e sborrarci dentro.
Caroline è la mia waifu quindi sono un po' di parte ma vabbè.
Ora provate a mettere le animazioni di un gioco medio che si trova su F95 su Milfy City e otterrete il nulla cosmico. La trama è inesistente e il ban dell'incesto (A cui si può mettere una toppa grazie alla Incest Patch disponibile nel thread), toglie ancora di più al gioco.

In conclusione... se ICSTOR fosse meno discontinuo, MC sarebbe il GTA dei giochi erotici. Ma ad oggi non si merita di stare in TOP 3.

#TeamCaroline