Hmm there are a few things that don't make any sense in this game, such as the girlfriend telling a creep about her amnesia. She immediately recognized who he was when he approached her at the pool. Having in mind that she acknowledged that he was a creep because she has her memories from 2 years ago and that she told him that she didn't go out on a second date because of how creepy he was...why on earth would she tell her about something as important as her 2 years amnesia, her short term memory, and even about her video?
That makes no sense at all, he's an "acquaintance" at best, not even a coworker, let alone a friend.
I'm still shocked about that nonsensical excuse the detective gave about the elevator rape footage.
Nowadays it's incredibly easy for non-tech-savyy people to recover anything erased from a computer.
He didn't even need to waste time burning it into a cd, nowadays it's faster to save something into a pendrive, send something to your email, upload it into the cloud, or even copy that video into another folder (changing its name, so that the creep denies the existence of the video and gets outsmarted by the MC). Why would he copy it into another folder and change its name? Because that way the creep would think he's out of the woods, but when he arrives with the detective, the MC could just as easily show him the video in another folder and voilà! The creep gets arrested and rots in Jail.
PS: Things would have been even worse for the creep, because of 2 facts:
1) He's an anesthesiologist, so it's absurd to think that he would mess up the anesthesia dose, so if the police ever see that footage, it would be clear that she was given a dose way higher than she was supposed to. That would mean that he decided to overdose her with anesthesia in order to rape her, so not only would he have been sent to jail, but also lost his license, and his job.
2) The elevator footage was recorded from a POV that makes it seem as if there was actual penetration, so he would definitely have been prosecuted for rape, and found guilty.