Kadajko

Well-Known Member
Oct 28, 2021
1,037
1,796
and for me its the exact same but different. I want the MC have a Romantic relationship with his harem girls, If he is just cheating on everyone than the MC is trash. If he is cheating he is lying to all of them. How can he claim to love them when he is treating them like fuckdolls? If they are not a Person but just Tits on a Stick for the MC I don't need the story and then I have zero interst in the sex scenes. If I just want to see emotionless sex I go to pornhub.
We are like two sides of one coin only with polar opposite tastes, but with the same conclusion. Only I don't know if you would play a game in which you are able to have only 1 monogamous relationship or you are also not interested in that?

Though this to me is sexier than pornhub even without the plot..
 
Last edited:

erkper

Well-Known Member
May 16, 2018
1,672
2,213
that's basically what I got from that. a harem would usually entail every girl knows what the MC is doing with other girls and they accept it. this just sounds like no matter what, MC is going to be a bastard
Agree with the common thought that BuuPlays mischaracterizes this game as harem when it should not be. But I would say "MC could be a bastard" instead of "is going to be." It sounds like you have total control over which LI(s) to be involved with.
 
  • Like
Reactions: battali0n

Simulacrum29

Active Member
Apr 20, 2018
891
3,250
We are like two sides of one coin only with polar opposite tastes, but with the same conclusion. Only I don't know if you would play a game in which you are able to have only 1 monogamous relationship or you are also not interested in that?
seldom, if the game is geared toward one special LI like Melody, and if it's really good, then I could bring myself to play it. But games with an expansive cast and only one Li fuck no, why should I play a game just to miss 3/4, 5/6, or 7/8 amount of content? I also don't play different routes. I don't have time for that.

Agree with the common thought that BuuPlays mischaracterizes this game as harem when it should not be. But I would say "MC could be a bastard" instead of "is going to be." It sounds like you have total control over which LI(s) to be involved with.
to answer that i will quote myselfe
true. But I play harem games for the harem, If it is no harem and you will miss LIs then I don't need to Play harem games. I could play everything else.
 

Kadajko

Well-Known Member
Oct 28, 2021
1,037
1,796
seldom, if the game is geared toward one special LI like Melody, and if it's really good, then I could bring myself to play it. But games with an expansive cast and only one Li fuck no, why should I play a game just to miss 3/4, 5/6, or 7/8 amount of content? I also don't play different routes. I don't have time for that.
Do you ever play triple A RPG's? Are you wasting time because you can't pick every companion due to their different alignments or can't align yourself with every faction? Isn't it cool to make your playthrough unique? How is picking a different LI different than picking whether you have a good or an evil playthrough for example? You choose only one right?
 

erkper

Well-Known Member
May 16, 2018
1,672
2,213
I am super confused where YOU got this from because at no point EVER have I talked about LI cheating on the MC.
Never mind then, apparently I was projecting why you would somehow choose to reject the game when it seems tailored to be exactly what you claim you want. Going by what the dev describes (not what he incorrectly calls it) the game is set up as a monogamous route with potential for cheating with consequences.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kadajko

Kadajko

Well-Known Member
Oct 28, 2021
1,037
1,796
Never mind then, apparently I was projecting why you would somehow choose to reject the game when it seems tailored to be exactly what you claim you want. Going by what the dev describes (not what he incorrectly calls it) the game is set up as a monogamous route with potential for cheating with consequences.
Once again, if it is, great, and I will be happy to play / support it in the future.
 

Simulacrum29

Active Member
Apr 20, 2018
891
3,250
Do you ever play triple A RPG's? Are you wasting time because you can't pick every companion due to their different alignments or can't align yourself with every faction? Isn't it cool to make your playthrough unique?
Sure I Play AAA Games, but only as long as they hold my interest. I probably have more games than I can cram into the rest of my life and that still does not take into account all the Movies, Tv Shows, Animes, Mangas, and (belive it or not) time spent with friends and family.

To compare AVNs to AAA games is like comparing Brazzer to Disney. Yes, the both produce Movies, that's it.

I Play a AVNs with completly different goals then a "Trails in the Sky"

How is picking a different LI different than picking whether you have a good or an evil playthrough for example? You choose only one right?
Wrong that's why I play a Harem game, and the emphasis is on HAREM. If I don't get a Harem I can go and play Baldurs Gate 3 it has better graphics, better story telling and it will be finished this year.
 

Kadajko

Well-Known Member
Oct 28, 2021
1,037
1,796
I Play a AVNs with completly different goals then a "Trails in the Sky"
What is that goal?

Wrong that's why I play a Harem game, and the emphasis is on HAREM. If I don't get a Harem I can go and play Baldurs Gate 3 it has better graphics, better story telling and it will be finished this year.
Yes, but what is the difference? Sure one has engaging strategic combat gameplay elements, but as far as story goes ( minus voiceover ) you just read through a story. Why is it ok to CHOOSE in BG3 but not ok to do the same in a VN? You can't romance everyone in BG3, you have to choose one or maybe a few ( who knows ) but it is definitely not a harem. You are not going ''Oh I can't have both Shadowheart and Laezel, what a waste of time, I don't want to replay the game!'' RIght?
 

Nelson4ever

Newbie
Oct 11, 2021
15
387
Can you guys stop feeding this anti Harem troll it's getting more off topic and it's not the first time he's doing and certainly won't be the last , he goes into most games that has harem ( optional or not ) ( saw at least 2 to 3 times in a week saw it in eternum , hot sands of antarctica to mention a few ) and in those games he complaints of LI that are willing to be share MC with other girls in harem path as tainted even though you can be monogamous with that LI and avoid those talks , that LI is tainted and he's not interested in them . This game has optional harem like dev said , if you can't deal with it stick to dating sim games and not cry about optional harem or expect dev to change their game to cater you just cause you don't like it .
P.S. Seems like trolls never learn , not gonna bother engaging those trolls and derail thread ,there maybe more games where he's doing the same but i just remembered another game " Tainted - which has optional harem along with monogamous routes " if you check that thread , you'll see same conversations over and over again . Like i said it isn't first time and it won't be last and if there is new another optional harem game , expect the same conversation / cry again . Why don't they play only dating sim games if they don't want harem and not complain about harem in optional harem games or want sharing and ntr in games that dev said they have no thoughts of implementing it and play games that have it .
 
Last edited:

Kadajko

Well-Known Member
Oct 28, 2021
1,037
1,796
Can you guys stop feeding this anti Harem troll it's getting more off topic and it's not the first time he's doing and certainly won't be the last
You think I am just going to let you chat crap don't you? You are very out of touch.

First of all I express my tastes and then move on, and only come back to the thread if someone replies to my comment and asks me questions or wants me to elaborate on something, sometimes I ask people questions related to their replies, I NEVER just randomly go back to the thread and ''complain'' about harem over and over again. I had 1 reply in a 68 pages Eternum thread that would've just stayed as 1 if people did not start quoting me.

he goes into every game that has harem ( optional or not ) ( saw at least 2 to 3 times in a week saw it in eternum , hot sands of antarctica to mention a few ) and complaints of LI willing to be sharing as tainted even if you can stay as faithful to that LI .
It's funny because in sands of antarctica, because I don't view it as a romance game - I expressed a desire for an option to share the girls with other men like in desert stalker. Have you even read what I wrote?

This game has optional harem like dev said , if you can't deal with it stick to dating sim games and not cry about optional harem or expect dev to change their game to cater you just cause you don't like it .
That was what we were trying to find out, because apparently not everyone including the dev agrees on the definition of a harem. Also I expressed on MANY occasions that the devs don't not owe me anything.

I will grant you that my discussion with Simulacrum29 went slightly off-topic but still useful in determining peoples tastes and where they come from, that is useful information for devs.
 
Last edited:

Simulacrum29

Active Member
Apr 20, 2018
891
3,250
What is that goal?



Yes, but what is the difference? Sure one has engaging strategic combat gameplay elements, but as far as story goes ( minus voiceover ) you just read through a story. Why is it ok to CHOOSE in BG3 but not ok to do the same in a VN? You can't romance everyone in BG3, you have to choose one or maybe a few ( who knows ) but it is definitely not a harem. You are not going ''Oh I can't have both Shadowheart and Laezel, what a waste of time, I don't want to replay the game!'' RIght?
Its simple about the fetish, nothing more nothing less. Same as you prefering swinging <- something I will never understand.
 

Justin monrow

New Member
Jul 4, 2022
10
47
Good game dev , there were few minor typos in the game and I noticed some dialogues and it was confusing and i wasn't able to tell whether they were thinking it or saying it and one dialogue where MC cousin dialogues shows as MC but overall loved fantasy aspect of the game . And loved the wholesome childhood story between MC and Alice . And my one suggestion would be don't overdo branching paths and focus on the story as too much branching like 10 to 15 paths will be difficult for a single dev .

Funny how people are complaining about the game , idk whether they have played it .This is more of a slowburn wholesome romance game and MC isn't a guy who is only for sex like in most games ( nothing wrong with it ) but here there is a story and he rejects a girl who flirts with him in tavern on his own and only 2 major LI on the banner are introduced and we are getting to know them and if you want to go monogamous you can and so far I love both Alice , Eliza and if we get option to pursue both in the future , I'll choose them without any doubt and with some more LI to be introduced in the future , if they are good I would love to add them to the Harem but that being said like dev explains in his patreon it's not going a typical Harem story where all girls wants MC for his cock , you have your work cut out for you if you want Harem ( which I like and looking forward to it ) or you can stay monogamous if you prefer it but some people saying / hoping things like that this game should never have a harem even as on optional is not an opinion it's just childish behaviour .
 
Last edited:

Simulacrum29

Active Member
Apr 20, 2018
891
3,250
Funny how people are complaining about the game , idk whether they have played it .This is more of a slowburn wholesome romance game and MC isn't a guy who is only for sex like in most games ( nothing wrong with it ) but here there is a story and he rejects a girl who flirts with him in tavern on his own and only 2 major LI on the banner are introduced and we are getting to know them and if you want to go monogamous you can and so far I love both Alice , Eliza and if we get option to pursue both in the future , I'll choose them without any doubt and with some more LI to be introduced in the future , if they are good I would love to add them to the Harem but that being said like dev explains in his patreon it's not going a typical Harem story where all girls wants MC for his cock , you have your work cut out for you if you want Harem ( which I like and looking forward to it ) or you can stay monogamous if you prefer it but some people saying / hoping things like that this game should never have a harem even as on optional is not an opinion it's just childish behaviour .
well and here on the forum Dev told us that there won't be a True harem path and that the most you can hope for is a lying slimeball MC that tries to fuck everyone.
This game will include a harem path, however you will be able to pick and choose the girls you want to pursue, there won't be any forced love interests, the girls are not into "Open" relationships either, so if someone wants a happy harem, he might not want to tell the other girls.
 

d_pedestrian

Engaged Member
Jul 18, 2020
2,073
8,410
So everyone thought MC was dead for 10 years and when his family met him for the first time in 10 years they were like "Hey, Hi there. Where were you?".

Dude, WTF? Is it really that hard to write family dynamics? This is how it should have gone:

After Learning about MC from Alice Cousins should have run around the Village searching for him and as soon as they saw MC they should have jumped on MC to hug him. Both MC and these cousins should have been weeping. After this they should have forced MC to meet his Uncle and Aunt.

I don't know what's wrong with dev nowadays. MC's romantic segments with Eliza is written so good but when it comes to family dynamics? MC didn't even meet his Family before leaving for capital.
 
4.10 star(s) 59 Votes