Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
14,916
19,717
Yeah I have both a story reason, and a I find them really annoying reason. Anyway, I’m looking forward to hearing what Brenda has to say - I’ll happily help her take Looter’s Bay and give her the Twins if that’s what she wants. I’m not really looking for story reasons for anything because this isn’t really a story-first game anymore.
I still consider this a story first game personally. ( no idea about Ch 5) but just cause there is alot of sex ( to much of it) doesn't really mean there is less story to the game to me. As I feel almost every updates has some kind of story progression to it. Tho really id say story and lewds are about equal I just don't know a better word than story first.

Eh, I tend to like fiesty women. Kira is the type of Li typically gravitate towards.
yeah she is the type I like when you get to know her I probably would if her cave scene wasn't way to much to quick for me I felt overloaded.
 

Grumpy Old Aussie

Engaged Member
May 6, 2023
2,461
5,179
wait you are telling me it's possible to like Eliza and consider her the best girl without wanting to kill the pirates or other characters ??? :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO:
Not possible :LOL:

For me Brenda id kill , Sylph I find to annoying can't stand her, The Barmaid isn't bad but she is nothing more than a wench to me if she a character was a with some character deveolopment id probably like her. Lucid is a tricky one for me not sure if she is a LI or not I like her character alot .

Overall id say I like Eliza , Amelia , Luna , Peral and Alice about the same

But honestly for me I just think killing the pirates twins is too harsh of a punishment at this point even if I didn't like them ( I don't like Kira) , only reason I would kill Brenda is because I can't trust her to betray the MC or the pirate twins and she did try to take over looters bay and kill the twins.
I agree with your post except, Eliza is way out in front, then Pearl, Alice, etc. Brenda and Kira can walk the plank.
 

storm1051787

Active Member
Mar 23, 2019
783
1,259
so even through the pirate twins are bitches who tried to kill you and even threatened you and betrayed you you'd trust them while Brenda did none of that and actually is trusting you enough where doesn't just kill two women who have killed hundreds of innocent people and literally betrayed their own family and basically city? yeah no they aren't trustworthy at all and one still trusted her dad after years of abuse and trying to kill her sister and even she tried to kill her sister like literally if she's willing to kill family she's willing to kill anyone

Pearl only tried to kill you when Kira's life was endanger and Kira never tried to kill you at all. Brenda never has a conversation with the MC either and I think you're confusing here with Diana. Brenda is the black haired pirate that trying to take over looterbay, tortured the bartender and threated to torture and rape the twins.


The twins also never killed any innocent people. They point out multiple times that they only prey on smugglers which is one of the reasons why their Dad hates them, because he doesn't view them as real pirates. And why are you upset about the fact they're willing to kill their super abusive Dad? I think family is important, but if you family is abusive you're better off without them.
 

Maviarab

I will have the penne all'arrabiata
Donor
Jul 12, 2020
12,076
29,457
so even through the pirate twins are bitches who tried to kill you and even threatened you and betrayed you you'd trust them while Brenda did none of that and actually is trusting you enough where doesn't just kill two women who have killed hundreds of innocent people and literally betrayed their own family and basically city? yeah no they aren't trustworthy at all and one still trusted her dad after years of abuse and trying to kill her sister and even she tried to kill her sister like literally if she's willing to kill family she's willing to kill anyone
where did i say I'm upset about them willing to kill their dad? I'm mad about one of them trying to kill her own sister. and its funny you have no proof they only pray on smugglers and even then that's not good since some smugglers actually smuggle supplies to cities that need it or people out of the kingdom that are trying to escape an abusive relationship heck and we have only their word to trust when both have tried to kill us once, and their dad threatened to kill Kira and pearl fell for it like a dumb bitch and then tried to kill Kira herself like a stalker ex who thinks if they cant have you no one can. and if you are gonna say something say it right because you cant even say threatened right and back to the point we still have only their word that their dad is abusive no proof or anything heck and they aren't real pirates either plus they don't

Steal cargo
Take hostages
Take over ships

they literally only attack smugglers which again isn't always good because some smugglers aren't even bad people and are just trying to help people and here come two pirates who are attacking it because its a smuggler ship that they have no proof or evidence is a ship that's doing anything bad they just assume. if its a slaver ship then id understand but even then just shooting it with cannons isn't good since the slaves are kept underdeck and would get killed by the cannon fire and if the smuggler ships are smuggling people without them being willing then the sisters are still killing people since i doubt anyone tied up person can escape a ship under fire.
you're a spaceball.jpeg
 

jadepaladin

Well-Known Member
Mar 9, 2020
1,251
2,565
I think Kira and Pearl make for terrible pirates but the blame falls on Buu's writing. They have this reputation built up but their actions throughout have either been naïve or just plain stupid. The smartest decision I've seen them make from a pirate standpoint is recognizing that Diana was not someone they could confront on their own.

Brenda has a reputation for being a snake and actively functions like one. She's only interested in the MC because the twins are and she hopes to get something out of him/use him to strike at the twins. At best, she's a survivalist.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rehwyn and Maviarab

storm1051787

Active Member
Mar 23, 2019
783
1,259
you realize how many people sold their kids to slavery and killed them in the age our mc is living in? thousand's to millions

The mc isn't living in "age". He's living in a completely fictional fantasy world that doesn't follow the same history as ours. Just because stuff looks medieval, doesn't mean the laws and everything are identical to what they were in medieval times, some of the clothing the characters wear wouldn't even exist in mideval times.
 

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
14,916
19,717
so even through the pirate twins are bitches who tried to kill you and even threatened you and betrayed you you'd trust them while Brenda did none of that and actually is trusting you enough where doesn't just kill two women who have killed hundreds of innocent people and literally betrayed their own family and basically city? yeah no they aren't trustworthy at all and one still trusted her dad after years of abuse and trying to kill her sister and even she tried to kill her sister like literally if she's willing to kill family she's willing to kill anyone
I mean each to their own you are entitled to your own opinion. I just find it hard to believe Peral or Kira killed hundreds of innocent people unless their father literally forced them. As they make it a point to go out of their way to only go after smugglers , slavers and go against their father's wishes and how he would do things when he is around.

Also when did they try to kill us? As far as I recall Kira only went as far as threaten us the first time and Peral just took the chalice. Peral did fight against Kira but never against the MC as far as I can remember. Also I doubt Peral was trying to kill Kira more like disarm her. However I wouldn't say they trusted their father more like they were afraid of him. So they made illogical decisions at times like Peral attacking Kira

Brenda how over attempted to take over Looters Bay , from the sounds of things used to be good friends with the twins if I recall correctly. Not to mention from the little bit ive seen of her I believe she is ruthless and is just as bad as one of the higher ranking pirates that worked directly under the father. To me she seems just to damn risky to let live , as I think if she see's a chance to betray the twins or the MC she will take it.

While the twins are extremely loyal to the MC. Peral's loyalty comes from her guilt of what she did and she wants to atone for her mistake ( tho imo I don't think she needs to feel guilty, as it is understandable why she did what she did and her sister forgave her) Kira's loyalty well that just cause she madly head over heels in love with the MC. to me Kira seems like she doesn't have a balance personality she either loves you or hates your guts and her slider is maxed out for said direction. I just don't see them betraying the MC of their own choosing. I could be wrong but that is my personal opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maviarab

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
14,916
19,717
dude pearl literally attacked mc in the cave to take the chalice and even if they did attack smuggler ships and slaver ships that still would cause innocent deaths seeing as how the slaves in the bottom of the ship would get killed from the cannon fire and if they do attack smuggler ships that could cause innocent people to die from hunger since they didn't get food that they are smuggling because of their king since not all kingdoms are good to their subjects or if the smuggler ships are smuggling people away from places to a different kingdom then they could get killed from canon fire and like the guys daughter we saved from smugglers what do you think would've happened if the sisters sunk the ship she was tied up on? she would've drowned or got burned alive or crushed.
Like I said as far as I can remember no one has a perfect memory. but look you can believe what you want im not trying to change your mind I said my peace and stand by my opinion.
 

jadepaladin

Well-Known Member
Mar 9, 2020
1,251
2,565
I don't really feel like to can compare fictional pirates to real pirates, especially not in fantasy ones. Kira and pearl could do a whole bunch of badass naval battles against other pirates and smugglers that we just don't get to see. Infact they took down most of the rebelling pirates on their own so that counts for something. I'm also not really sure I'd say they're naive either. The thing with their Dad seems more out of desperation than them being naïve. There is no logical reason to think that the mc had the ability to take him on.
Well, there's no "fantasy pirate" standard so real pirate is all we've got. The battle against their dad showed off their individual martial prowess, which, while nice for a pirate to have, isn't crucial. They aren't alone either, that ship is way too big for them but we've already noticed the rest of the crew has been a mixed bag of people. Kelly, cute but ultimately damsel in distress, and the other creepy guy that MC had to deal with to save Kelly one of the times she was in trouble. So it's either slim pickings in Looter's Bay, which is realistic, or they are terrible judges of character. I think the truth is a little of both.
 

MiltonPowers

Twins Basil! Twins!
Donor
Jul 26, 2023
12,820
27,931
dude pearl literally attacked mc in the cave to take the chalice
You really need to play it again dude, before you go sprouting nonsense.

Pearl arrived, picked up the chalice says 'Father's Orders' to Kira and 'I'm sorry' and 'Please forgive me' and 'Don't Hate me' to MC, and then used a transporter orb to leave.

There was no attacking literally or figuratively.
 

jadepaladin

Well-Known Member
Mar 9, 2020
1,251
2,565
You know...I do seriously wonder if I play differenty games to some of the folk on this foru...ohh look..pretty picture....eehh...what point was I trying to make again?

Ugghh...I despise having to take people off the list just to add new ones....
I'm 100% positive I've said something like this before and I'm less positive it was in this thread.
 

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
14,916
19,717
You really need to play it again dude, before you go sprouting nonsense.

Pearl arrived, picked up the chalice says 'Father's Orders' to Kira and 'I'm sorry' and 'Please forgive me' and 'Don't Hate me' to MC, and then used a transporter orb to leave.

There was no attacking literally or figuratively.
thanks for this that's what I thought to but didn't have a save to confirm as it's been awhile
 
  • Like
Reactions: jadepaladin
3.90 star(s) 97 Votes