To be fair, that´s what i think about a lot of the new LI´s as well as some of the other characters. The priestress who shoved MC into a pit with the intent to kill him, The pirate sisters who betrayed MC at first which resulted in their father trying to kill MC, the Admiral who didn´t want to listen to reason and went out of her way to try and kill MC, The King who belived Tarons lies, which ended with MC locked up in jail with a lycantrope trying to kill him... No offense, but judging by that logic, all of those characters deserve death.
And yet, Pearl and Kira are literally sucking MC´s Dick regulary, The Priestress either ends up in MC´s harem or just stays unfucked with no repercussions, The Admiral, also a potential LI instead... So, what exactly is the difference besides inconsistent writing? I know i keep repeating myself, but we had the choice to kill Selena and never saw her again after the Eliza scene, even though Selenas actions lead to the MC going on a journey to look for a cure for Eliza which turned her into a badass vamp. So why not give Selena the same option as all the others? She was literally the reason why MC is going to stay with Eliza for eternity.
Brenda was trying to redeem herself and even if she doesn´t know when to shut the fuck up, she definitely didn´t deserve death. Especially not when we decided to fuck her. So either stay consistent and let us kill all of em, or don´t kill them at all?