I actually skipped that one on the manwhore run because I knew the gist of it from the good guy run. But to me, what matters is who the MC is as a person.
The good guy MC is an honest real estate agent who wants what's best for everyone and supports his family. When Sheila approaches him, he just wants to do the right thing. So naturally, when that evil criminal bitch kidnapped him and tortured him, I was pissed. Plus, the whole Tris working for Katrina thing is much more dangerous for this kind of MC, because he isn't around for that and has less control.
Now, the bad boy MC is a guy who willingly went to work for that shady woman, even taking (admittedly minor) part in her criminal dealings, and allowed her and the environment to corrupt him into a rude asshole. Imo, he tried to rat out Katrina because he got scared of the law. So, when Katrina antagonizes him, I don't really mind, to me, that's two assholes fighting. Plus, his attempts to convince Tris to quit the Club were pretty weak; while his motivation was good here, it looks like he didn't understand he came across as hypocritical.