The style is black and white to help reach two objectives, one, give a manga/comic feel of the game, two, get a old atmosphere like an old horror tale.
i really like this game, ART for me is amazing, but i agree with you, every new update more and more bug come, i've already helped a lot sending saves and reporting bugs.Fucking hell, he's being doing this for years, how can he be THIS incompetent as a dev and coder? Everything new in this update is broken.
Exactly! solo project can be tough some times, you need to put a lot of efforts in a lot of parts, like art, coding, bug fix, writing and more and more the project become bigger, more complex its turn itself.It makes all kinds of sense. Solo project; if you want to produce any meaningful amount of new content then bug hunting and fixing can't be prioritized. It's not at all uncommon to leave bugs unfixed until you're closer to a finished game. If he'd done the opposite we would have people complaining that there was never any new content. I don't begrudge him that choice. But that doesn't mean it isn't frustrating as fuck to try to play the game in its current state. And I am worried that he might call the game finished without doing a few thorough bug fixing patches at the very end.
No one finds it fun to hunt and fix bugs. And while pushing that entire process in front of you until the very end can be a valid approach, I can't imagine the amount of willpower it would take to do all that extremely frustrating work after all the fun stuff is done. Especially when you're the only one working on the project and paid monthly. There's no incentive to finish the project properly since you already got most of the payment you are going to get. But time will tell.
There is nothing wrong with the game engine, godot is one of the best engines out there for 2D games (it's viable for 3D too, but it has a few serious problems in that area), it's also one of the easiest game engines to learn and use; Although this particular dev would probably have been better served with Ren'Py, which is even easier and perfectly suited for this kind of project.i really like this game, ART for me is amazing, but i agree with you, every new update more and more bug come, i've already helped a lot sending saves and reporting bugs.
I believe this occur because two points:
- game engine for this project;
- lack of professionals (lonely man);
There is nothing wrong with the game engine, godot is one of the best engines out there for 2D games (it's viable for 3D too, but it has a few serious problems in that area), it's also one of the easiest game engines to learn and use; Although this particular dev would probably have been better served with Ren'Py, which is even easier and perfectly suited for this kind of project.
Personally if I was making this kind of project I'd probably also use Godot, but it demands just a little bit more programming competency from the developer than ren'py does; plenty of devs manage to cock up the code in ren'py games too though, even if that's actually legit hard to do.
That all said, a game should not, indeed be a buggy mess, especially not features from recent updates, if they are it, more than anything, points to lack of testing.
The developer is clearly a very good artist but not quite as good a programmer. It's written all over the game, it's weirdly packaged (entire game in one exe, no experienced dev does this), pretty much all the bugs are the kind that should be easily resolved, a typo here, a bad reference there... It could be many of the problems even happen as a result of the binary packaging (especially if he tested the game and it worked properly in the godot editor)
This game is good, and fun, but all the bugs where the game freezes or crashes when you try to go down certain paths, effectively closing off sections of the game, are holding it back a lot. These are the kinds of issues that after encountering them during testing I'd solve in minutes each if I were making this. It's a shame the code isn't open source really, because if it was I might actually try to do just that, this game deserves it.