I've been using AI nsfw for 8 days. Here's the verdict: IT'S NOT READY YET.
IMO, it can produce some powerful emotions, but it's highly inconsistent.
Problems
1. inconsistent results
2. forgets important details too quickly, no matter how you program it
3. moves events forward too fast, even if you use code stating other wise
4. deviates from current task as if suffering from attention deficit disorder, despite using code to prevent this
5. if you want to pay $$$, one website's AI might give great responses but lack basic features, while the other website has lots of nice features but a shitty AI response.
AiChat's I've tried
1. crushon.ai - amazing response but you can't even delete or edit messages, so what's the point? Their ui looks like shit.
2. aisekai
3. yodayo
4. sakura
5. sillytavern +koboldhorde = what a fucking nightmare, hahah, the learning curve is ridiculous with documentation that doesn't cite any examples of usage, so learning it would probably take a whole month.
6. a lot of other ones that were just shitty quality
It has a lot of potential, and I think in about 1 year we're going to see some amazing things from it, but it's just not there yet.
There's also barely any documentation in regards to how to program the bot (you know via {{char}} and {{user}} and all that stuff)
Now, if you guys think I'm wrong, PLEASE prove me wrong, because I want to use NSFW AIChat bot's. When they do actually work, they're a lot of fun, but too inconsistent, still too many problems.
LONG STORY SHORT, if you try to use an AI NSFW Chat bot, you're going to get massively blue balled, because towards the end of the conversation, the AI will forget all the important details when it matters most, the CLIMAX, so you get fucked over every time.
Most of what you wrote is correct. They all stem from the same issue. The Token limit. It is the bot's memory. The bots have a limited amount of words they can use as context to create their responses, so regardless of how many Tokens you use to program the bot, there
will come a time when it cannot use the entire chat history as context. It will start dropping the earliest messages when this happens, and the amnesia will start.
The code that's written for the bot is basically its permanent memory. This is always available to the bot, whether it be its personality or scenario guidelines, but this ties up the tokens that could have been used for chat history context. So it's a bit of a trade off.
But again, regardless of how its coded, the bot eventually getting amnesia is inevitable. You need to remind it regularly and guide it along the narrative you want. You can do this pretty smoothly while maintaining roleplay through cleverly written prompts, but it does become pretty tedious.
Most sites I've tried had a token limit of 2000, which is pretty small. If you look at top end offline set ups, they can have like 32k tokens or more. Not sure how that will play out for chat AI functionality, but it would surely have a longer memory at least.
As for the AI escalating too quickly, that's kind of related but also it's own problem. With a higher token limit, you could conceivably code a bot that tries to pull off a slower build up, but I think these bots just inherently are not very good at telling an overarching story. They are not actual thinking robots. It's just a language model that predicts what words will likely come next.
In practice, what we see are basically all or nothing scenes. The bots just go to extremes. If you initiate sex, they will turn into sluts. If you act like a giga chad, they will all turn into submissive bitches. Even if they were programmed to be dominant or feisty, the player just has to keep on insisting that his giga chad energy is making her weak in the knees or whatever, and they will eventually flip into a submissive slut lol. And you can turn any bot into an NTR one if you just introduce an antagonist lol. That's pretty funny.
But yea, these chatbots can do individual scenes well, but it's a hard sell for them to tell a coherent story with good build up and gradual escalation, at least on their own. You can do it with a lot of rewriting and reminding them of shit, but at that point, it's mostly you who is writing the story and not the bot lol.
The rate at which this whole field is advancing is pretty amazing though.
