I'm in the same camp as the people who say Nyl was very tired by the time he did this one. He said in the post that it was harder than he thought to add sound to each loop and because of adding sound, he didn't have time to re-render these to get them perfect. I get the feeling that he decided to do the Challenge last minute as he usually has ideas laid out for each day ahead of time.
That being said, I'm glad P/W didn't win. I'd rather have a very well rendered video of them than something made "quick and dirty." And I'm sure he will come back to P/W eventually.
Oh and I'm sorry but I just gotta say that this is not "carry position." This is definitely a full nelson. Which is fine but as some have pointed out, JQ is pretty much covered up anyway. So we have two animations of her by Nyl where she is off camera. And that's really ashame. Other than that, I like it.