Their is nothing wrong with making mistakes, yes the captain was fresh out of the academy when the game started but he grew as a character and leader, I don't hate him as a character, I dislike the decisions he makes during any form of conflict, and I recently replayed the entire game from start to end and I can tell you he rarely shows any form of skill, during the first conflict in the game he takes down 1 enemy while Nyx eradicates them all, the next fight was on the Bellona(Sybil Ship) and you only use one attack against those monsters and noel saves you from getting hurt with her gun, the next one is when you go to Zara home world, you automatically surrender since your surrounded and the one after that is when you get harassed by 2 gangsters and Vann steps in and they go away, and the final one is against Kali which is arguably the worse, for someone like the captain who has trained hard in the military academy he couldn't even disarm her and got shot and the other option is giving up and joining her, you see what I'm saying? I am not hating on the game it is one of my favourite as shown on my top 10 list, I consider it the best of the best, Its just frustrating seeing the captain fumble fight after fight and not even getting a chance to get some action in.