So whats everyones ranking of the guys?
I sorta exclude Ian since he the MC and his personality and performance varies from loser to winner, cuck to chad etc., he is winning by default since you don't experience most sex scenes without him.
After that, best is Axel, he has a oppressive presence and its good that he is used sparingly. His sex scenes are prime domination and great for ntr and corruption. A bit of a shame that the redemption/bro ith Ian arc as dropped, but once Cindy and possibly Cherry get rolling, it will be better.
Jeremy is annoying for sure, but his range and the variety with how many women he can end up (or not) make him a great, if not needed secondary male character. You get bro sharing, competition, cheating, all necessary elements for the porn aspecs of the game. The Lena-Louise-Ivy angle can be fun to mingle with, but the Alison/Emma sharing also has its peaks.
Mike is currently a bit stale since the temptation aspect of him and Lena have run its course. His gf has to be adressed and damn if it isn't Gillian, that ranks the drama and interaction with other characters up.
Seymour dropped the ball after chapter 9, the game isn't really benefiting from an antagonist like him. The Lena content is a one-way road, he has much less range than Axel. Maybe a colaboration with Agnes and Agnes, or throwing in another girl?
Robert gets a few points just through quantity, the sex scenes are mostly fine and it leading to a bit of rivalry with Ian gives it some meaning. Curious how the Holly content works out, it seems Eva doesn't simply drop him.
Stan is awful on the romantic route, his saving grace is the pay pet route with exhibitionist stalkfap Lena. Exploiting him on that route can escalate even further and its a good take on the hot girl ugly dude dynamic.
Perry currently has low content, but wingmaning your less fortunate friend and granting him a girl or two over the course of the game can be rewarding, there is also the teasing angle with him and Lena.
Marcel and his scene came out of nowhere. I prefered the odd pairing with Holly, it is a much spicier chpice for a corrupted Holly than Lena fucking him just because of BBC.
Jack was a random cameo, I don't get dialogue hinting that the two of them may meet again and develop their "relationship". I'd rather have him fuck Ivy.
Mark is the blandest generic love option either, he has nothing to say, no personality, and yet Lena and Holly can develop a relationship with him going further than a one-night-stand. I rage if that bland piece of wood turns out to be Gillians boyfriend.