VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch.4 Up.5 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

4.80 star(s) 535 Votes
Discussion Reviews (535)
F

ffive

Devoted Member
Jun 19, 2022
8,286
19,728
To be invited on stage you need to attend Hana's previous concert, when she invites Edwin to it. Then just choose to cheer for Hana, preferably with Mina.

For the Hana/Mina scene to play out rather than fail you can't have Hana as girlfriend, but need casual relationship with both girls. Also, don't push Mina towards Veronica, because then she'll be too busy sucking faces to see what's going on between Edwin and Hana.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bateauivre
ModiThorrson

ModiThorrson

Active Member
Jan 1, 2024
652
1,176
bateauivre said:
I know this must have been asked multiple times, but what are the requirements to unlock the scene "While on a relationship with Mina and Hana, go on stage..."? Do I need to be Hana's boyfriend and cheat on her? Because in my Hana's fuckbuddy path, Mina stays with Veronica, and Edwin goes on stage alone.

Thank you so much to anyone kind enough to answer!^^
Click to expand...
Hana fuck buddy, mina lover, don't encourage her to go with veronica(you want her for yourself), kiss her, then you'll get up on stage.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bateauivre
crastock

crastock

Newbie
Aug 28, 2022
39
15
I'm asking again, anyone has stumbled across *this* bug? I can't get the scene with Mina...
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Game doesn't let you reject Mina
 
Last edited:
ManipuliereGlied

ManipuliereGlied

Formerly 'pv7'
Apr 30, 2018
63
114
Ottoeight said:
Just play while keeping an eye on the pdf walkthrough.
Click to expand...
Of course, but I don't really remember all the decisions. It's great that there is so much to discover and to decide but without looking up the variables in my old save I don't even remember who won each round at the exhibitions and especially small stuff like did I distract Mina at the Arcade or what choice did I end up with regarding Emma.

Obviously most stuff doesn't have an impact on the story but some small things do.
 
Last edited:
bateauivre

bateauivre

Newbie
Aug 26, 2023
34
70
Oh thank you, I went with the "Lesbian Push" choice, and that causes Mina to stay with Veronica. There's a crazy branching at the concert. Now I got it, thanks :D
 
Last edited:
Niuul

Niuul

Well-Known Member
Jun 25, 2022
1,057
2,577
does URM not work with this game? Try opening the menu to see if i can change the variables to get all the traits and it just errors a traceback.

not a huge issue but not something i've encountered before just trying to alt+m
 
  • Like
Reactions: ename144
M

Michkooo

Newbie
Jun 25, 2024
56
134
Hello everyone, I'm new to the game. It's pretty go so far.

Is there regular Dalia content ? I got to the sauna scene with her and I'm in love. I know she's a side girl but she's the hottest one in the club
 
D

Darreau91

Member
Dec 31, 2022
163
662
nonethatmatters said:
played the game for the first time

I just wanna know what is the take of people on the story and specifically the angle of Victoria. For me it was a rather "knife in the ribs" kind of situation that left me feeling like shit most of the times.

Kudos to the developers tho for such a great game.
Click to expand...
The story has a lot of nuance on morality and so far every character has some sympathetic points to them outside of Warren. Everything is leading to Veronica and Mina getting the best ends while Sophia will be in every single bad end in my humble opinion.

Victoria is probably the best written character and mom in the AVN world in all seriousness. She just feels so real as a character. Rendered hot as hell too and hope she gets a man at the end worthy of her perfectly rendered booty.
 
  • Like
Reactions: link18
N

nonethatmatters

New Member
Jul 24, 2023
12
23
Darreau91 said:
The story has a lot of nuance on morality and so far every character has some sympathetic points to them outside of Warren. Everything is leading to Veronica and Mina getting the best ends while Sophia will be in every single bad end in my humble opinion.
Click to expand...
I think we will have an option to push Veronica and Mina together or to keep them for ourself probably seperate paths or maybe a future harem tag where we remain in the club.

Moreover if MC learns the actual truth of what happened morally shouldn't he just talk to Chuck and tell him that he is quitting? No matter how much the college would cost if MC was disgusted by the memories of her mother doing porn, shouldn't all shit go to hell once he learns that the club was behind it?


Victoria is probably the best written character and mom in the AVN world in all seriousness. She just feels so real as a character. Rendered hot as hell too and hope she gets a man at the end worthy of her perfectly rendered booty.
Click to expand...
I agree.

On a different note, there is clearly a quite contrast between the films she did with Donny and the ones before. She was rather happy. And don't consider me saying "oh she is a whore who have sex for fun". Of course she had to act,coupling with the pleasure that sex gives it's inevitable.

I just thought it's weird that he reacts the same way to all of her porn.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Darreau91
ManipuliereGlied

ManipuliereGlied

Formerly 'pv7'
Apr 30, 2018
63
114
Niuul said:
does URM not work with this game? Try opening the menu to see if i can change the variables to get all the traits and it just errors a traceback.
Click to expand...
I tried editing a trait variable too with unren. One time it worked, one time it didn't. Right at the beginning when first meeting the hag I couldn't cheat the flirt option.
 
zandalari

zandalari

Active Member
May 4, 2019
523
2,563
TD1900 said:
I mean... the two spots where Edwin has blurry memories are separate animations. You guys haven't seen the unblurred animation for the Vicky prone bone. ;)
Click to expand...
And whose fault is it? :BootyTime:

nonethatmatters said:
On a different note, there is clearly a quite contrast between the films she did with Donny and the ones before. She was rather happy. And don't consider me saying "oh she is a whore who have sex for fun". Of course she had to act,coupling with the pleasure that sex gives it's inevitable.

I just thought it's weird that he reacts the same way to all of her porn.
Click to expand...
Is it the same though? I have not replayed the game for a long time now so my memory might be blurry, but his reaction to Donny stuff was quite extreme.

My personal theory is that it's a matter of image. MC thinks of Vicky as a martyr of sorts that was forced into bad circumstances and endured it for his sake. Her image is pure and unblemished by the actions she was forced to take.

But while it could have started this way, was she still being forced into it later on? The new vids certainly point to a bit different scene. Dare I say she looked quite.. satisfied under her new employer. And that's the thought that sent our MC into a fit. His perfect mother, enjoying getting fucked on camera? Such a revelation might force him to take another look at what is happening in the club. There could be some far reaching implications here and a possible split in MC's personality depending on if the player keeps or deletes the vids. Personally I keep the vids not just for content but also I don't think being in the club is healthy for anyone's sanity. MC is already on the fucked up side and it makes sense that this and other revelations make him worse in some way. We'll see how and where this goes.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Fapparition, ffive, Suntar and 3 others
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
4.80 star(s) 535 Votes