VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch.4 Up.5 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[TM | Twisted Games]

I always ask myself a simple question in these situations: Could I believeably write it into the narrative if I wished to? In this case the answer is certainly yes, plenty of potential paths are laid out. And TD is just as good if not a better writer than I am...so he certainly could as well.

Doesn't mean that he wants to, or that he will...but it's narratively plausible.

 

[Deleted member 4058859]

Apart from the fact, that every woman in the game is either openly or secretly a sex fiend, we also know that Kat and Doren are working on some kind of sex drug or aphrodisiac that turns people into sex maniacs. I don't know, how dark the game will end up being, but it certainly has the potential to get really dark, with someone like Warren and some of the patrons openly abusing women, Kat being a sadistic psychopath etc.

If Kath/Warren had more power than they actually do it would be more likely. But even half of August's stake in the club is more than what Kath owns not to mention that even outside of ownership, they are more powerful/influential than she is. She even mentioned that the club patrons dont respect her enough because she is a woman. She has the motivation but she does not have enough leverage. And warren is basically just a grunt - he is sadistic but he is a nobody.

Like I mentioned the only way I see this happening is Abel's sex drugs but unless Kath manages to drug everyone it will be hard.

 

[Takkatakka]

If Kath/Warren had more power than they actually do it would be more likely. But even half of August's stake in the club is more than what Kath owns not to mention that even outside of ownership, they are more powerful/influential than she is. She even mentioned that the club patrons dont respect her enough because she is a woman. She has the motivation but she does not have enough leverage. And warren is basically just a grunt - he is sadistic but he is a nobody.

Like I mentioned the only way I see this happening is Abel's sex drugs but unless Kath manages to drug everyone it will be hard.

She is powerful enough, to have a whole lab in the club, Chuck and August don't even know about.

Also her pushing Hana to take a stake in the Club doesn't bode exactly well for our Goth GF. We will see, were the story takes us...hopefully somewhat soon.

 

[brymont92]

You can thank /aco/ board from 4Chan, for that!

View attachment 2394210

Lovely

 

[ShadowLordV1]

She is powerful enough, to have a whole lab in the club, Chuck and August don't even know about.

Also her pushing Hana to take a stake in the Club doesn't bode exactly well for our Goth GF. We will see, were the story takes us...hopefully somewhat soon.

I think she doesn't understand the actual impact the Mc has on Hana, even on non sexual routes.

 

[RC-1138 Boss]

She is powerful enough, to have a whole lab in the club, Chuck and August don't even know about.

Also her pushing Hana to take a stake in the Club doesn't bode exactly well for our Goth GF. We will see, were the story takes us...hopefully somewhat soon.

My take is she wants to either corrupt Hana to her sadistic ways of thinking to make her a ally or failing that to try to buy Hana's share of the club. Either way Katheleen was already sucessfull in reducing August influence on the brothel's decisions by putting a fourth head there.

I think she doesn't understand the actual impact the Mc has on Hana, even on non sexual routes.

I think she does have some understanding, otherwise Kath wouldn't have pushed for Edwin to go after Hana. But in the end guess Hana's decision will depend on how Edwin's influence her about the Carnations club.

 

[Deleted member 3083868]

If it's not MC's penis that does the action, it's a waste. Therefore:

Kat and Warren abduct Victoria and tell MC there is a surprise waiting for him. Kat injects MC the fuck drug and then he sees a insanely hot naked body arousingly tied, gagged and masked. Being in a frenzy he fucks her senseless and cums in her many many times in all kinds of ways.

Being sober again Kat takes him to the tied woman and slowly lifts the mask. Kat: "Shouldn't have tried to fuck me over with Hana, MC."

(Bad End #01 - '

You must be registered to see the links

')

-

Since TD is a big movie enthusiast this is guaranteed to happen.

I can see this happening and Kat then getting the incest video to blackmail Victoria to work at the club. Ian and Chuck could also help to bring Victoria in the club either jointly or separately.

 

[MilesEdgeworth]

Kat is not gonna fuck over her protege and the mc is def her protege at this point.

 

[Deleted member 3083868]

Kat is not gonna fuck over her protege and the mc is def her protege at this point.

Mc is her protégé if you want him to be.There are different paths in this game I would suggest people to have different saves for different paths to understand why Victoria getting fucked by Edwin, Ian, Chuck, Warren and club members is possible. Victoria is moral compass my ass get her in on the action.

 

[Bill Temple]

Mc is her protégé if you want him to be.There are different paths in this game I would suggest people to have different saves for different paths to understand why Victoria getting fucked by Edwin, Ian, Chuck, Warren and club members is possible. Victoria is moral compass my ass get her in on the action.

I see (and hope TD does too) Victoria as a moral compass not only because she's Edwin's mother, but perhaps more so because she has flirted with corruption and been able to stay true to her goal of raising her son with minimal disruption to his childhood given the circumstances they were encumbered with. Having her let go of that goal even at this point feels like a loss. "Getting her in the action" would only make sense IMO if there's a "darkest path" ending option in the works from the devs.

 

[Sensei2000]

Netorare or Netori?

 

[dolfe67]

Netorare or Netori?

I like both.

But in game there is netori.

 

[subtitle]

If it's not MC's penis that does the action, it's a waste. Therefore:

Kat and Warren abduct Victoria and tell MC there is a surprise waiting for him. Kat injects MC the fuck drug and then he sees a insanely hot naked body arousingly tied, gagged and masked. Being in a frenzy he fucks her senseless and cums in her many many times in all kinds of ways.

Being sober again Kat takes him to the tied woman and slowly lifts the mask. Kat: "Shouldn't have tried to fuck me over with Hana, MC."

(Bad End #01 - '

You must be registered to see the links

')

-

Since TD is a big movie enthusiast this is guaranteed to happen.

your theory doesnt work because edwin has memorised every nook and cranny of victoria's body from all the children he's donated so he doesnt even need to see the face to know who it is

when kat does the reveal the big twist is the mc knew all along

 

[Zerorox]

Ahah, I think we're totally safe, there Will be no incest and Victoria scenes at all.*
*Cause we have more then enough motherly figures already, Rosalind mostly, Kath in some degree...

 

[Deleted member 3083868]

your theory doesnt work because edwin has memorised every nook and cranny of victoria's body from all the children he's donated so he doesnt even need to see the face to know who it is

when kat does the reveal the big twist is the mc knew all along

In Kathleen path Mc won't have much resistance to being drugged and if he does resist there is big Warren to subdue him.

 

[Deleted member 3083868]

Ahah, I think we're totally safe, there Will be no incest and Victoria scenes at all.*
*Cause we have more then enough motherly figures already, Rosalind mostly, Kath in some degree...

There won't be incest if you don't want to pursue that path but there will be incest if you want to pursue that path

 

[Nulldev]

Kat is not gonna fuck over her protege and the mc is def her protege at this point.

You made a mistake here by not thinking like Kat, her definition of fuck over is not the same as yours.
She view this like free the MC from the old, stupid morals, she sets him free to follow his perverted heart's desires.

 

[Sensei2000]

I like both.

But in game there is netori.

As much as possible i avoid ntr. Thank you!

 

[Zerorox]

In Kathleen path Mc won't have much resistance to being drugged and if he does resist there is big Warren to subdue him.

In Kath path, Kath is not interested roughly forcing MC to do something with Warden help or smth, cause there is no need in that, she Just guides his mind smoothly and more gently, MC at the end of current update is not resisting her and already working on his "moral shift" willingly
So, I think Kath Will not try risking to lose MC by forcing speed up the process to much.
edit: c'mon guys, she's evil sadistic hug but still character with Special stat "trust", it's easy to noticed, she had already changed her acting towards MC quite a lot
I dunno, maybe she wants to be his "Mother with benefits" in future

 

[BrockLanders]