VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch.4 Up.5 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[TD1900]

I know the point of contention of what qualifies as harem, but I've been clear on the subject over the years, and even recently:

And speaking to my taste, I just don't like harems or incest in stories.

Generally speaking, the MC convincing five women to love and be monogamous solely to him stretches my personal suspension of disbelief a tad too thin in most cases, outside of more shlocky scenarios. It CAN work, but it doesn't suit the tone I want for Pale Carnations.

Now, our potato MC casually banging multiple hot women probably tickles that harem instinct for some people, but to me it comes down to commitment, context, and ultimately resolution. Honestly, disregarding that my idea of what's romantic won't be universally shared (and depending on the heroine, will look wildly different from the next), getting Edwin into a loving relationship with just a single heroine in an organic and semi-believable way by the end of Chapter 5 is what I forecast as my greatest hurdle. In no way will Edwin knock up the entire cast while they all live in blissful spiritual matrimony, fulfilled and whole as one happy cohesive unit - and never mind the lack of a tag, I hope that's evident from the tone of the game.

That said, as a story, the imagined happenings after the credits is less important than what happens before IMO, and this game will have plenty of group scenes by the time it's done: MMF, FMM, and beyond. So if that's why harem games appeal to you, then it's something. Although I know, from personal experience, context is king when it comes to what powerpoint slideshow you jerk your meat to.

 

[Takkatakka]

I know the point of contention of what qualifies as harem, but I've been clear on the subject over the years, and even recently:

Oh yeah...right...I even liked the original post from...two weeks ago...

 

[Idontplay]

Buy her a peloton

A what?

 

[manu243]

Niceeee

 

[ename144]

The reminder of her darkest chapter is the real sticking point, buuut if he's the guy that helps her out of the trouble that lead her into this dark chapter, then I think there's a real chance that she's eternally grateful and will want to hitch her wagon to a young doctor's rising star.
To successfully write this pairing believably will indeed require care and consideration, but we're talking about T motherfucking D. He can do it.

Honestly, I don't think it needs to be all that hard. The thing about 'darkest chapters' is that they're very subjective and a lot of it hinges not on how the chapter develops but how it ends. Rosalind is unquestionably going through a miserable month, but I suspect that *if* she can walk away from it knowing she's given her daughter a 'normal' life, then she'll be quite able to make peace with her ordeal once it's all over.

Triumph over adversity is a powerful narrative. It has a way of accentuating the positives and downplaying the negatives when you look back secure in the knowledge that everything turned out well. And if the MC plays a big role in her success their shared suffering might actually draw them closer together, sort of like how veterans - even ones from opposite sides - can sometimes overlook the horrors of war and focus on the bonds they formed in the process. Sure, they'll need to come up with a cover story for how they met that's suitable for polite society, but that's easily done; the age gap isn't that big.

Of course, this hinges on Rosalind being able to look back from a place of success. If the month of being degraded and abused was merely the precursor to a life in hock to the Club and a permanent estrangement from her daughter then yeah, she's never going to want to look at the MC again. But while giving her (and/or the other Carnations) a relatively happy ending is certainly an uphill struggle, I think it's a plausible outcome if the MC pitches in. It will take a delicate touch to pull it off, but TD (and GIL!) have demonstrated they have the skill, planning and patience to pull it off.

I'm even cautiously optimistic they want to do so! <fingers crossed!>

 

[Bill Temple]

A what?

It's an exercise bike with a screen on it, so you can pretend you're riding through the Poconos or at a spinning class while you're in your living room. I think they make rowing machines with screens on them too. Basically, all I know is fashionable people are very happy while inspirational, energetic music plays in the background as they do cardio at home. That, and some fortunes were made and lost during the pandemic if you decided to hop on that stock's hype train.

 

[Pr0GamerJohnny]

It's an exercise bike with a screen on it, so you can pretend you're riding through the Poconos or at a spinning class while you're in your living room. I think they make rowing machines with screens on them too. Basically, all I know is fashionable people are very happy while inspirational, energetic music plays in the background as they do cardio at home. That, and some fortunes were made and lost during the pandemic if you decided to hop on that stock's hype train.

Which was at a meta level related to his quote for the ad that was a little too honest

 

[rippertipper]

It also gets into "alpha" bullshit which is just that. Bullshit. A theory about wolves that used wolves in captivity and even the original writer has rescinded it because it was flawed.

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

I had to

 

[Ungawa]

It's not clear if the author of that guide believes those things himself, or if he's speaking in the voice of [what the average harem enthusiast would want]. If it's the latter, indeed I'd say he's accurate. It's moronic, but it's accurate. They see anything less than a totally unequivocally committed harem of virgins as a cuck tale.

I get the fantasy, every guy at some point has dreamed of a rotating stable; but there can only be so many stories of that before utter boredom sets in. It's basically a guide on how to make WVM.

That's kind of the point of the guide: a harem guideline.

Not necessarily how to write each and every person or even to do everything it says but to help invigorate a few main archetypes within that type of story.

I certainly didn't see it in Oppai Oddyssey (and I'm slow walking that one even SLOWER than I am PC...) and not every dev is going to follow it.

Certainly there can be better guides (or stories like old ones on Literotica) but it's not to swear by every work done but look at them as ways the community can grow and learn just like the devs to make better writing a goal.

 

[Idontplay]

It's an exercise bike with a screen on it, so you can pretend you're riding through the Poconos or at a spinning class while you're in your living room.

I'm too paesant for that.

 

[Ottoeight]

Guys, let me turn the tables on the debate on Rosalind being interested in a relationship with Edwin:

if you were a 21 years old man, would you really favour a 36 years old woman with a 12 years old daughter over a 19 years old blond model?

Seriously, bros, come on...

 

[CorprealFale]

Guys, let me turn the tables on the debate on Rosalind being interested in a relationship with Edwin:

if you were a 21 years old man, would you really favour a 36 years old woman with a 12 years old daughter over a 19 years old blond model?

Seriously, bros, come on...

Well, lots of men are just boys who want a new mom who they can also fuck.
For them Rosalind makes perfect sense.

 

[Sleeping In Pieces]

if you were a 21 years old man, would you really favour a 36 years old woman with a 12 years old daughter over a 19 years old blond model?

Seriously, bros, come on...

It's a porn game, bro. The usual rules of logic don't apply.

 

[Bill Temple]

Guys, let me turn the tables on the debate on Rosalind being interested in a relationship with Edwin:

if you were a 21 years old man, would you really favour a 36 years old woman with a 12 years old daughter over a 19 years old blond model?

Seriously, bros, come on...

You're too cold, man! Not everything is a tier list. What about true love?
What if a sudden realization crystallizes in Edwin's mind in the middle of one of her next h-scenes:

Rose: "Mmmh...! *Chup Fwup!*"
Edwin (thinking): "I... I think I love this woman! "
Rose: "*Shlup plap...* Mmmh...!"
Edwin: "Mhh, ahh."
Edwin (thinking): "I don't want to imagine a world where I don't wake up next to this angel every morning for the rest of my life."
Rose: "Ngggg! *CHUP, CHWUP, FWHUP, THURP...!*"
Edwin: "Unhh."
Edwin (thinking): "Damn, It might not be the most romantic time, but I don't want to wait one moment longer to ask her to marry me."
"Wiping the heavy perspiration from my brow as I tenderly back out of her throat, I clear my own to speak human words for the first time in two hours of sticky, carnal rutting."
Rose: "*huff huff*"
Edwin: "Hey Ian, can you ease up on Rosalind for a minute, I need her attention to ask something..."
Rose: "*Plapp plap...* AAAHNN!"
Ian: "Wha? *plap* Oh, yea, anything for my Eskimo Bro! Just *plap* one *plap* second. *plap* She's... *Plap* almost... *PLAP* There! *PLAPP!!* "
Rose: "Gaaah! I'm comiiiiiiinggg!"

Did I change your mind?

 

[Brainfurt]

Guys, let me turn the tables on the debate on Rosalind being interested in a relationship with Edwin:

if you were a 21 years old man, would you really favour a 36 years old woman with a 12 years old daughter over a 19 years old blond model?

Yes

 

[Idontplay]

Guys, let me turn the tables on the debate on Rosalind being interested in a relationship with Edwin:

if you were a 21 years old man, would you really favour a 36 years old woman with a 12 years old daughter over a 19 years old blond model?

Seriously, bros, come on...

Accordingly with my experience most of the young men would love stay with an experienced beautiful older woman, just to learn how to fuck and then they would dump her to stay with an Hana or a Mina of their age.

P.S. If Ottoeight has tried to turn the table on, I think I have blew it up.

 

[Turret]

Guys, let me turn the tables on the debate on Rosalind being interested in a relationship with Edwin:

if you were a 21 years old man, would you really favour a 36 years old woman with a 12 years old daughter over a 19 years old blond model?

Seriously, bros, come on...

Well, that always depends on personal tastes! My Top 3 (in no particular order) are Hana, Felicia and Sophia: So the (not quite as gothy as she might look) Goth drummer girl, the epicurean artist girl and the amoral genius nerd girl. So what does this tell you?
One thing is that TD1900 and GIL3D are really good, because normally I do not find girls tattooed to the heavy degree Hana is attractive at all.

 

[DirtyMario]

Guys, let me turn the tables on the debate on Rosalind being interested in a relationship with Edwin:

if you were a 21 years old man, would you really favour a 36 years old woman with a 12 years old daughter over a 19 years old blond model?

Seriously, bros, come on...

Most guys probably wouldn't. Different (but similar) point, Rosa probably wouldn't favor Edwin either. There are certain social norms you just can't weasel around. She has to introduce you to the girls from her book club (basically, FRIENDS is what I mean), you have to introduce her to your mom and her friends etc. And in about 20 years Edwin is in his late 30s, Rosa is a senior citizen and you both got really weird looks all throughout your relationship. Rosas daughter has reached an age where she questions just how horny her mom had to be to catch herself a guy this much younger. Most people would not want to put up with any of that.
Yes sure it's a fappy game and milfs in a certain age range are hot. Whatever, but we're talking realism at the moment.

Rose: "Ngggg! *CHUP, CHWUP, FWHUP, THURP...!*"

Every time I read that stuff I almost want to claw my eyes out.
I love you TD but jesus christ.
CHWUP FHWUP

 

[Deleted member 4375198]

Did you guys think that we have the chance to see a "fucked up" love path with Kathleen?

I truly believe she is the only character who is wife material.

 

[Nulldev]

Did you guys think that we have the chance to see a "fucked up" love path with Kathleen?

I truly believe she is the only character who is wife material.

I truly believe she is one of the characters who is wife material.
Fixed for you.