VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch.4 Up.5 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[Biscardone]

The quote may not explicitly refute your point, but it certainly doesn't support it. If the ultimate goal of this game was to justify an incest story, why is there never going to be any incest in it? Even if TD decided to change tack because of Patreon rules or something, why would he base the revised project on a setup designed from the keel out to do something counterproductive?

It would be like claiming a submarine was originally designed to fly to Mars purely on the grounds it has a *really* efficient life support system; a quote from the designer disparaging the lazy design of most interplanetary rockets is hardly proof.

Well, what you are saying is entirely logic. Unfortunately, Axeleen's argument is that TD and GIL, possibly unbeknownst to themselves, deep down are writing an exploration of oedipal themes and as such it must be resolved, or at least motivated, by incest. Even, and I quote, "if they may never admit this to themselves (or to us)". Logic can't beat mind reading skills, or couch psychoanalysis, I'd say.

 

[Hahn1900]

I think He means (and I'm confused too) that this is the MC's mom

erm no? Well with really really bad eyes you might think that and of course if you skipped most of the game too (cause MCs mom and Mina meet each other in the game and know about each other)... but no they are not the same person, not even close.

Fuck Rosalind looks more like MCs mom than the woman on that picture aka Minas mom.

 

[Deleted member 6943714]

erm no? Well with really really bad eyes you might think that and of course if you skipped most of the game too (cause MCs mom and Mina meet each other in the game and know about each other)... but no they are not the same person, not even close.

Fuck Rosalind looks more like MCs mom than the woman on that picture aka Minas mom.

Wait what? Did Mina meet MCs mom? I think it was hana

 

[Hahn1900]

Wait what? Did Mina meet MCs mom? I think it was hana

Uff.... just.... uff, forget about it, start a new game, at the very beginning you can take a look at MCs mom already, and if you still think that she is the same person like on that picture, well.... *shrug* I guess Ronald McDonald will turn out to be my father, could be worse.

 

[CorprealFale]

I assume it's a transphobic person because someone posted a close-up at Minas pubic area.
It's just someone who doesn't know how a woman looks and assumes "has to be a dick hidden there that isn't there anymore".

 

[Takkatakka]

I really didn't get that post either...maybe it is just trolling/red-herring? If not maybe that user could enlighten us if he/she maybe so inclined.

 

[Bill Temple]

I really didn't get that post either...maybe it is just trolling/red-herring? If not maybe that user could enlighten us if he/she maybe so inclined.

I'm gonna try this in another game thread. I'll post a random but obscure image from the game, and caption it: "You're seeing this right!?! LOL! I won't explain. IYKYK"

 

[dolfe67]

Just ignore it, since he didn't explain what is wrong for him

 

[OUndrAnt]

Bonus Art: Where The Foxes Gather

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[Idontplay]

Only one woman with the right amount of clothes.

 

[Bill Temple]

Only one woman with the right amount of clothes.

Andrea.

 

[boy1208]

Is there any way for me to unlock the scenes i didnt choose without having to play through the game again?

 

[Xythurr]

I'm at the part where Kathleen is wanting MC to play with Harper as a birthday gift. I chose all the hardcore options and Kat blueballs the MC.
How do you get her scene?

 

[pinuz1]

I'm at the part where Kathleen is wanting MC to play with Harper as a birthday gift. I chose all the hardcore options and Kat blueballs the MC.
How do you get her scene?

I think she needs to trust you. I don't know what choice/choices you need to make for her to trust you exactly, but if you don't mind installing the cheat mod you can cheat and make her trust you using that mod. hope it helped

I checked the walkthrough, she needs to have 8 trust, you can see how much trust she has with the cheat mod. hope it helps

(cheat mod is in the first page of this thread)

 

[dolfe67]

I think she needs to trust you. I don't know what choice/choices you need to make for her to trust you exactly, but if you don't mind installing the cheat mod you can cheat and make her trust you using that mod. hope it helped

I checked the walkthrough, she needs to have 8 trust, you can see how much trust she has with the cheat mod. hope it helps

(cheat mod is in the first page of this thread)

You don't need a cheat mod to see the stats, there is a native screen in the in-game menu

 

[fred9320]

hannnaaaa ^^

 

[Xythurr]

I'm digging the game but I wish they would even out the audio. Some songs you can barely hear then others will blow your speakers out when the action starts.

 

[Avernesh]

Walkthrough Update


Hey everyone, here's my walkthrough for this great game. I hope you find it useful to navigate the game and get all the hidden gems.


If you want to support my work, you can:

You must be registered to see the links

Visit my thread to post suggestions for my next work.

Walkthrough is also available here:

You must be registered to see the links

Spoiler: Changelog

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Cheers,
Mr Bubu

Sorry for quoting you out of nowhere, Bubu, but I noticed something that it's not on your walkthrough. On Week 2 Part 1 you can choose to kiss Hana and as you point out it gets you 5 affection points but it also subtracts 1 anger point as well. Hope you don't mind me pointing this out but I just noticed and thought you would like to know.

 

[Gab1]

With how limited the audience is and how much actual work it is to write high quality characters, it makes little sense to do that for adult games, and further to answer to a bunch of horny pirates that steal your work anyway. I'd still like to see it of course, but my standards are far lower than what I'd expect in a non-adult game, and I think it's utterly unreasonable to expect any different.

Even if someone had a great idea for something and started that process, I'd only ever take it so far for an adult game, treat it like a demo or proof of concept, then save the rest of it for a mainstream Steam release.

I do understand, but in Last years there has been a grown in audience of AVN, i hope that one Day it will become mainstream enough so some of this games get recognition.

 

[Kintty]

With how limited the audience is and how much actual work it is to write high quality characters, it makes little sense to do that for adult games, and further to answer to a bunch of horny pirates that steal your work anyway. I'd still like to see it of course, but my standards are far lower than what I'd expect in a non-adult game, and I think it's utterly unreasonable to expect any different.

Even if someone had a great idea for something and started that process, I'd only ever take it so far for an adult game, treat it like a demo or proof of concept, then save the rest of it for a mainstream Steam release.

You're speaking for yourself, of course. Unless you can produce some sort of market analisys to back your claims, all you have is anecdotal evidence. For my own personal case, all I really know is that I've been avoiding visual novels like the freaking plague, and I was planning on doing the same for this game, skipping text and watching the sex scenes, until suddenly I found myself trapped by the intriguing story and charming characters.

You say it makes no sense, I counter with the fact that the devs managed to charm a determined VN hater into enjoying their game. Evidently, it must make some sense since, to some degree, it works.