VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch.4 Up.5 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[Simpgor]

1. goooooooooooooood damn what an update ive been super hyped for it since it was first mentioned in game and it did not disappoint at all the ending really gives me vibes that no other game on this site has come close too

2. Im obviously a fan/supporter of this game but objectively this game is the highest rated on the site (hasnt changed since both #1 and #2 released updates) despite the fact that this is heavily "non vanilla" and we arguably arent even at the "worst of it" yet compared to a game where the MC walks into a harem and wins basically every time with little thought (peak wish fulfillment)

yeah TD might not be making that Caribdis money but pirates REALLY like their game!

 

[Idontplay]

I wonder when someone will start to ask why this game doesn't has a gay tag, since there are a lot of lesbian scenes.

 

[Mr. Chatty]

the game almost has a 5 star rating here, close to 1300 supporters on patreon, so I'd say those stats support it's in fact, "fire". At least compared to a lot of other AVNs on this site. It may not be to your liking, but that puts you in the minority. And you haven't even played it, so I think I have a little more background on it than you do.
As for Felicia being involved with other men

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

A fact is something that's true for everyone, an almost 5 Star rating wouldn't cut it and about Felicia question, blame

Well with the exception of Felicia that is.

For it.

 

[Simpgor]

I wonder when someone will start to ask why this game doesn't has a gay tag, since there are a lot of lesbian scenes.

because " Lesbian [Sex act between two or more females.] " tag?

It wont get the gay tag until Edwin and Ian tag team someone and then their balls touch the high five is only bromantic not gay

 

[Skeltom]

I wonder when someone will start to ask why this game doesn't has a gay tag, since there are a lot of lesbian scenes.

Because gay is just guys obviously... In all seriousness I think it's kinda dumb how they separated it like it's two different things.

 

[Skeltom]

A fact is something that's true for everyone, an almost 5 Star rating wouldn't cut it and about Felicia question, blame

For it.

What? For what?

 

[MAGO-DAG]

It wont get the gay tag until Edwin and Ian tag team someone and then their balls touch the high five is only bromantic not gay

 

[Simpgor]

Because gay is just guys obviously... In all seriousness I think it's kinda dumb how they separated it like it's two different things.

if this wasnt a porn piracy site i would agree its a dumb separation

but your high if you think everyone who watches lesbian porn/scenes/games also want to see some dick on dick sword fighting

ian and edwin are ghey

its just classic porn game escalation at this point: MC helps LI grow as character, LI shows MC their naughty bits, MC and LI have some form of sexual touching (we are here), if it wasnt for that pesky "carnations" event im sure we would be getting Ian update next

 

[Randomguy3478]

Because gay is just guys obviously... In all seriousness I think it's kinda dumb how they separated it like it's two different things.

I just hope you are kidding.

 

[Skeltom]

if this wasnt a porn piracy site i would agree its a dumb separation

but your high if you think everyone who watches lesbian porn/scenes/games also want to see some dick on dick sword fighting



its just classic porn game escalation at this point: MC helps LI grow as character, LI shows MC their naughty bits, MC and LI have some form of sexual touching (we are here), if it wasnt for that pesky "carnations" event im sure we would be getting Ian update next

I just hope you are kidding.

Mostly just fucking around. I know it's for the filters, just technically not a separate thing. If your sticking something in a member of the same sex your gay... No?

 

[Randomguy3478]

Mostly just fucking around. I know it's for the filters, just technically not a separate thing. If your sticking something in a member of the same sex your gay... No?

not sure if two apache helicopters getting it on are called gay, but I think lesbian is a good word for two girls

 

[Idontplay]

Oh my God! I have made a joke about the fact that too many people thinks this game needs an NTR tag and you guys took it seriously.

 

[Skeltom]

Oh my God! I have made a joke about the fact too many people think this game needs an NTR tag and you guys took it seriously.

No one took it seriously. I didn't at any rate just pointing something out.

 

[Simpgor]

Mostly just fucking around. I know it's for the filters, just technically not a separate thing. If your sticking something in a member of the same sex your gay... No?

Technically? No because a kiss (without tongue) is still "gay" despite nothing "being stuck in".

I dont know if you saw it but before the update we had someone clamming that eating pussy (in any way) is more or less femdom so im sure they consider high fiving a bro while double teaming a milf as gay.... better to just stick to site definitions so you can easily deflect those types

 

[Skeltom]

Technically? No because a kiss (without tongue) is still "gay" despite nothing "being stuck in".

I dont know if you saw it but before the update we had someone clamming that eating pussy (in any way) is more or less femdom so im sure they consider high fiving a bro while double teaming a milf as gay.... better to just stick to site definitions so you can easily deflect those types

I didn't see any of that stuff but I can only imagine. A kiss huh? That's news to me.

 

[Simpgor]

I didn't see any of that stuff but I can only imagine. A kiss huh? That's news to me.

im pretty sure Mina/Felica have kissed really early maybe during the truth or dare game? Even if they didnt (or used tongue and technically went inside) it was more to demonstrate that your (jokey) definition could be worked around, which is all well and good among people joking about it but when someone takes it 100% seriously its nice to have "its the sites tags not my feelsings" to fall back on (which again this thread/site has shown is needed)

 

[Skeltom]

im pretty sure Mina/Felica have kissed really early maybe during the truth or dare game? Even if they didnt (or used tongue and technically went inside) it was more to demonstrate that your (jokey) definition could be worked around, which is all well and good among people joking about it but when someone takes it 100% seriously its nice to have "its the sites tags not my feelsings" to fall back on (which again this thread/site has shown is needed)

They can kiss during kings gambit and Hana and Mina can kiss if Ian wins never have I ever.

 

[Simpgor]

They can kiss during kings gambit and Hana and Mina can kiss if Ian wins never have I ever.

ah no wonder i couldnt recall the second.... ian doesnt get to win until he starts reflecting on his life choices

 

[Skeltom]

ah no wonder i couldnt recall the second.... ian doesnt get to win until he starts reflecting on his life choices

To be fair it not really a kiss. Their lips are touching and and their tongues are in each others mouths but it's not a kiss. Though I'm sure someone would call that lesbian content.

 

[Ottoeight]

Guys, why do you waste your time answering these no-ntr obsessed dudes?

The overview and the preview pictures in the OP tell everything they need to know.