VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch.4 Up.6 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[SharkVampire]

Great update as always! Romantic relationship with Mina is done so well, that it's really heartwarming to read. I know it well, cuz usually in other games, those fake characters can't make even a muscle on my face tremble.

It's get Recently people was discussing PC popularity and I thought it even viable choice to try release on steam? Or they not allow it because of the HS models and some dark themes in the game?

 

[Gavin Ray]

Nothing but respect to GIL and TD for their second exhibition update!

That being said, I left this update feeling just a bit disappointed at the lack of kinkiness within the events. It all struck me as just a bit...tame? I feel like the activities within this update were on par with exhibition #1, and with this being the second, I suppose I was expecting the ante to be upped considerably. Perhaps this is just a byproduct of playing the updates in isolation, without replaying the whole game each time a new release comes out...maybe they would have felt more weighty in that case?

Spoiler-y thoughts below...

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

In terms of length of update, no complaints. I know someone here is going to bitch about how long it took for one night of content...but when the numbers are crunched, this is your biggest update yet, so no issues in regards to length.
The animations and renders were ultra smooth and detailed, big kudos to you guys for the technical aspect. Very beautiful looking update! Also, I feel like the character tones were well handled this update (as usual), which is a big reason PC is one of my favorite VNs.

All in all, good work on Ch3Up4, GIL and TD! You all are the dynamic duo... just without the campy tights... right?!

 

[desmosome]

I wonder if Hana Mina combo is a disaster waiting to happen lol.

 

[desmosome]

I hope Ian isn't banging MC's mom (even it's quite possible), he's a total bro MC, even if he's an asshole, I wanna keep them together as total bros and possibly help get him a to a better light.

He definitely is not. MC's mom is the only female Ian treats differently. She is a genuine mother figure to him and the only woman he doesn't view as some trash to be used. You might infer romantic feelings from this, but I think it's more of a platonic love and admiration.

 

[SoulSwipre]

Well, tbh, watching an old lady screw the girls isn't my favourite way of ending the long wait for this chapter. But I understand the cinematic/story build-up point of view. Just wish we had a bit more content to last till the next chapter. But seriously though, great job on this game. This is probably the one and only game I chase fervently despite there being so many different variables, where one decision near the start of the game locks out scenes so far down. That's the highest praise I can give it, being a completionist and hating lockouts or differing paths. Keep up the amazing work Dev!!

 

[TinaLarsen]

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Bros before hoes or in this case i guess Tomboy's lol

 

[TinaLarsen]

Way to depress the shit out of people

Mia will probably get a scene with another girl since she got a stat for it, but either way think it's safe to say both she and Hana are the vanilla options. The carnations are a bit more sketchy, especially after the latest update, but i still lean more towards them being relatively safe too since up to this day no other guy has messed with them (obligatory fuck Kathleen).

Said that i guess there's the very real chance the main assholes might be given a go in the last exhibition, but let's hope and pray for good fortune

So far Ian is the only guy other than the Mc whos been able to get any action with the main girls and it's been optional so far and consider this game doesn't have the N tag i do think unless we want to see it there won't be anyone else touching Ros Ver or Fel at least no guys tho we still don't 100% know what Abel and Kath are planning so who knows

 

[XXXVAA]

how do i unlock the option to hang out with veronica at the end? thanks

 

[Ranting Old Man]

When is the public release? I would very much like to play but unfortunately i can only play on Andriod. I've come to love this game very much.

 

[runz]

When is the public release? I would very much like to play but unfortunately i can only play on Andriod. I've come to love this game very much.

How do you play on Android?

 

[RC-1138 Boss]

I want to be decent to them but also wanna keep his maledom sadist attitude as well, is it possible to get both?

I don't think that is possible considering the requirements to get a different relationship (other than being just co-workers) with Felicia, Rosalind and Veronica.

I wonder if Hana Mina combo is a disaster waiting to happen lol.

Well Mina does want to have sex with a girl so I guess it is either Hana or Veronica.

how do i unlock the option to hang out with veronica at the end? thanks

Be a decent human being.
Seriously, you need to treat her well enough to have at least a 22 affection score with Veronica.

 

[Deleted member 4058859]

I wonder if Hana Mina combo is a disaster waiting to happen lol.

I dont think so - both characters are open to it. During the birthday scene with Hana, she brought up the idea of Mina joining and was excited about it. Mina also mentioned she wanted to try sleeping sex with a girl - she has a bi-curious stat, she liked Felicia making out with her, she wanted hana to continue talking about her sleeping with the rockstar etc.

I think that there will be a scene with both of them.

 

[Turret]

I dont think so - both characters are open to it. During the birthday scene with Hana, she brought up the idea of Mina joining and was excited about it. Mina also mentioned she wanted to try sleeping sex with a girl - she has a bi-curious stat, she liked Felicia making out with her, she wanted hana to continue talking about her sleeping with the rockstar etc.

I think that there will be a scene with both of them.

I think such a scene would only happen with a) Mina high enough bi-curious score and b) Hana-MC full relationship established. Hana is certainly no prude, played concerts topless, had her own bi "test drive", has no problem with Prostitution as a job (game plays in America, here where I live, Prostitution is legal), likes that others can hear her having sex and is open to experimenting some things.
BUT that does not include relationships. When it comes to relationships inself, Hana does not play around. A threesome with Mina, yes, but only as fuckbuddies, not a trouple. The MC (and maybe Hana in later updates) might do sexual things in the Club, but that is work. Helping Mina having her bi test drive okay, but only if Mina knows and accepts that the MC is Hana´s lover and hers alone.

 

[realmine]

No, in a little while, we'll see Mina's scene.

 

[Daken9]

Nothing but respect to GIL and TD for their second exhibition update!

That being said, I left this update feeling just a bit disappointed at the lack of kinkiness within the events. It all struck me as just a bit...tame? I feel like the activities within this update were on par with exhibition #1, and with this being the second, I suppose I was expecting the ante to be upped considerably. Perhaps this is just a byproduct of playing the updates in isolation, without replaying the whole game each time a new release comes out...maybe they would have felt more weighty in that case?

Spoiler-y thoughts below...

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

In terms of length of update, no complaints. I know someone here is going to bitch about how long it took for one night of content...but when the numbers are crunched, this is your biggest update yet, so no issues in regards to length.
The animations and renders were ultra smooth and detailed, big kudos to you guys for the technical aspect. Very beautiful looking update! Also, I feel like the character tones were well handled this update (as usual), which is a big reason PC is one of my favorite VNs.

All in all, good work on Ch3Up4, GIL and TD! You all are the dynamic duo... just without the campy tights... right?!

Crazy how perception can differ. I'm not impressionable by any means, but everything Veronica kind of fucked me up this update. Shit was bad before but it all still fairly felt like shit and giggles; what happened with her, the shower and her feelings after, felt like perhaps the first example of forced prostitution and straight up rape in the game. Wilted me out, ngl. Kathleen must fall (from the stage and break her neck).

That's where I struggle. I want to play the MC as being true to himself, and he explicitly considers many of the affectionate actions as hollow gestures given the circumstances, e.g. his little inner monologue leading up to Veronica's friendship scene. On the other hand, it's possible for him to want to help the women without pretending to an empathy he doesn't feel.

So yeah, I'm playing this weirdly altruistic sadist, which may not be the optimal strategy if you want to game the numbers.

Think of it as Dexter, definetely psycho but overall ruled by a sketch of a moral compass Or at least that's how my newest main run is, 'cause fuck not comforting Veronica

 

[Kukipett]

That's where I struggle. I want to play the MC as being true to himself, and he explicitly considers many of the affectionate actions as hollow gestures given the circumstances, e.g. his little inner monologue leading up to Veronica's friendship scene. On the other hand, it's possible for him to want to help the women without pretending to an empathy he doesn't feel.

So yeah, I'm playing this weirdly altruistic sadist, which may not be the optimal strategy if you want to game the numbers.

The problem with this game is that you are supposed to be some kind of executioner recruited to help in a sadist show, but in fact you find yourself as some kind of snowflake who always excuses himself and doesn't want to be the bad guy even if it's only a role.
And about this show, the first event was quite good and kinky, but lately this game has turn out to be the classic romance game for pussies and the last event was absolute crap and looked like a show for wanabe bdsm old guys. When i played it last night i was quite disapointed, i was expecting something really heavy and it was some soft shit.
I think that the dev has gone this way so the MC can stay a good little boyscout helping those poor girls trapped in that shit!
You can even ask your friend to do the bad thing and play the simp.
So we better forget about the BDSM side of that game and just play it as any romance game and be the nice guy who helps everybody

 

[TD1900]

The problem with this game is that you are supposed to be some kind of executioner recruited to help in a sadist show, but in fact you find yourself as some kind of snowflake who always excuses himself and doesn't want to be the bad guy even if it's only a role.
And about this show, the first event was quite good and kinky, but lately this game has turn out to be the classic romance game for pussies and the last event was absolute crap and looked like a show for wanabe bdsm old guys. When i played it last night i was quite disapointed, i was expecting something really heavy and it was some soft shit.
I think that the dev has gone this way so the MC can stay a good little boyscout helping those poor girls trapped in that shit!
You can even ask your friend to do the bad thing and play the simp.
So we better forget about the BDSM side of that game and just play it as any romance game and be the nice guy who helps everybody

Ah, you. Last time you were upset Felicia didn't cry.

I just don't think the game is for you. The game has always been about the main character's corruption, not the sadism power fantasy you're looking for.

 

[Garen]

I wonder if Hana Mina combo is a disaster waiting to happen lol.

oreo good

 

[SuperPerv96]

hey could some one please show me if theres a landlady in the game?

 

[zh]

I just tried this game and I think it's very good
I'm usually not found of the 'pimp' kind of story, but here each character has a very compelling story.
I can't wait for more!