VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch.4 Up.6 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[Lykanz]

The biggest inspiration for this project is

You must be registered to see the links

Scat in PC CONFIRMED!

 

[gregers]

I'm new, does the mom get forced into anything? ( I doubt it because of the rating)

Not within the game's current timeline (she's done porn in the past to provide for the MC).

 

[ddaisy]

Ah, yeah. I went around and around on what number would be appropriate there. It can be hard to get a good feel of what is reasonably achievable in a blind play through (which is usually my aim for these things) given all the options in the game.

Spoiler: Affection number required for the big Veronica choice

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

I'd be interested in hearing how many other people found that threshold prohibitively too high.

Was a few points too high for me, but being unable to do it felt mostly consistent with the explanation given in Edwin's inner thoughts and my previous choices. With that said I think some players with 21, 20 or maybe even 19 affection points could reasonably assume their version of Edwin would try to comfort Veronica there, so not being allowed to do that could indeed be pretty frustrating to them.

 

[RC-1138 Boss]

Yeah, I just liked porn games. From the old flash games on Newgrounds, to all those crappy RPGM games in the mid 00s, and throw in a decade of reading eroge and I just always wanted to make one. I had no other previous experience to speak of, besides knowing what I liked and what I believed worked in VNs. Well, I did spend a couple years making comics using HS, but I don't do the visual side of things for this project.

The biggest inspiration for this project is

You must be registered to see the links

and to a lesser extent

You must be registered to see the links

.

I remember Newgrounds. Used to play some flash games there.
I also played Starless long ago.

 

[TD1900]

How many chapters are going to be there in total?

Five, plus some epilogue stuff. The prologue (chapter 1) and the fours weeks of the competition (chapter 2-5).

 

[MrBubu]

Walkthrough Update


I updated the walkthrough to fix an error in the free roam before week 2 exhibition:

Post

Direct link to the PDF: PaleCarnations-Ch3Up4Public_walkthrough-rev-1.0.2.pdf


Thanks to 321654 for reporting it.

Cheers,
Mr Bubu

 

[Dvnasty]

is it just me or all save is broken by the new ver?

 

[ddaisy]

My saves were not broken.

 

[Dvnasty]

not sure why my save is broken tho

 

[tricky17]

I did think the update was thin on Mina & Hana

 

[Dictateur]

Cheat button doesn't appear, unfortunately

 

[Jazzzzz]

Do we have a Gallery unlocker MOD for the latest update ?

 

[ddaisy]

No

 

[NateGrey]

I met the game now, downloaded and looked at the videos, saw some men having sex with women, would it be possible to avoid this, leaving them only to the mc, or is it part of the story?

Yes, even though the game takes place in a high-class brothel, all the women working there turn out to have just started, and after having sex with the MC reject all other clients!

But seriously: no. If seeing guys other than the MC have sex bothers you, this is not the game for you. There is loads (no pun intended) of sex all over the place, involving a large number of men.

 

[selberdreher]

Kathleen practically tells the mc that shes not sending the tape out, the purpose of saying that was to fuck with rosalind and see if shed do it.

Nice catch there.
I had to review the pre-shoot scene with Kat and Ian to get it. Originally i was as dim-witted as Edwin and settled with the "we blur your face".

 

[selberdreher]

Really? Damn, I missed more points than I thought then. Perhaps the issue isn't so much getting the points as it is knowing what a "high number" is. Like I was under the impression that ending ch3up3 with 20 affection was fairly high, when apparently it wasn't. And now I'm locked out of affection options for Veronica as I have no older saves I can reload to score an additional point.

In the current update you can gain +1 Affection by offering some validation to her in the pre-exhibition restaurant scene and another +1 by putting on a show for the crowd in her exhibition scene. Go for them!

 

[Hargan2]

In the current update you can gain +1 Affection by offering some validation to her in the pre-exhibition restaurant scene and another +1 by putting on a show for the crowd in her exhibition scene. Go for them!

Oh shit, I think I missed that first +1 then. Thanks!

Edit: Nope, I got both those points. I actually started chapter 4 with 19. Meh, I'll probably turn this run into "Edwin embraces the club" instead and go for Veronica in my next playthrough.

 

[UncleFredo]

Yes, even though the game takes place in a high-class brothel, all the women working there turn out to have just started, and after having sex with the MC reject all other clients!

But seriously: no. If seeing guys other than the MC have sex bothers you, this is not the game for you. There is loads (no pun intended) of sex all over the place, involving a large number of men.

Carnation candidates were not brothel workers. They've never been sex workers. They have been recruited for the competition. They don't just turn out to have newly chosen prostitution as a career. Since they have not made that choice.

 

[selberdreher]

Damn i was looking forward to finally read your summary, but i held back until the public release to avoid spoilers.
As always it is a invaluable Read, and i do very much appreciate your input from the "softer" side of PC players.
After catching up to the current status of this thread (still like 14+ pages to go) i would like to pick each others brains again, that is if i find something worthwhile to add, however just for now real quick:

(...)
Dalia's request we check up on Harper and Lucy.

Dalia's request is certainly interesting. AFAICT, it only happens if you turned down Kathleen's birthday gift.
(...)

In my Playthrough Dalia approached me with this request although i took Kathleens Birthday gift. So this doesnt seem to be the trigger.

 

[WhitishKnight]

While I absolutely enjoy the game, some moments make me also sad
Hope there will be a happy end option with Hana + Mina ^^