VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch.4 Up.5 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

4.80 star(s) 536 Votes
Discussion Reviews (536)
TD1900

TD1900

#701
Game Developer
Dec 8, 2017
878
8,687
Avaron1974 said:
Don't get me wrong, characters and renders are great and the story is good buuuuut, I remember when it started and this was going to be a humiliating experience for the girls and they would have tough challenges that were designed to break them down and it involve different forms of sexual competitions.
Click to expand...
That's an observation that's pretty much made every update and I'm not really sure how to feel about it.

There is a planned trajectory and escalation to the competition, and in my head everything fits together nicely in a satisfying arc, but I think exhibition 2 is what fuels that sentiment. I still stand by it on a conceptual level - a focus on mental humiliation over a physical approach - but I think I failed to execute it with enough bite in some areas. The Veronica event with the spider was perfect in my mind, but I think the other two focused too much on setting up Felicia's and Edwin's club arc. Ideally, Kathleen probably should've switched to a more physical approach when the interrogation element was a wash, but I also think people underestimate just how grueling it is to sit on bondage horse - that angle was sharp!

I feel you about the versus/gamey aspect being lacking. With a little more creativity, I probably could've accomplished the above in a more head-to-head-to-head fashion. Hopefully week 3's exhibition will be a return to form for the "competition" angle. The month is only halfway over, after all.

As for the club content in this update, because I assume that's what prompted your observation and not an update that came out a year ago:

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Or, perhaps the end of the day, I'm just a softy. :whistle:
 
Last edited:
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: temp614699b1, lunar517, ShepardWrex11 and 16 others
Skyangel007

Skyangel007

Member
Jan 14, 2018
257
352
This update wasn't really for me. I'm not into lesbian shit and Mina isn't one of my favo. I did enjoy the couch scene though only wish more action followed after that :p Well cant please everybody and I already got my fill last update with Hana :D
 
  • Angry
  • Like
Reactions: Phase_01 and Ale3
"CJ"

"CJ"

Conversation Conqueror
Mar 6, 2021
6,636
70,495
Pale Carnations [Ch. 4 Update 2] [Mutt & Jeff] crunched

Original / Compressed Size PC*: 6,96 GB / 3,03 GB - PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc-crunched.zip
Original / Compressed Size Mac: 6,94 GB / 3,02 GB - PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-mac-crunched.zip
= ~43,5% of the original size, image/video quality 80%(png 90+%)/60%

Download (PC*/Mac):
You must be registered to see the links


Update only (by Bøb69) crunched
For instructions check the spoiler in his post.

Original / Compressed Size: 906 MB / 357 MB - PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-Universal-update-only-crunched.7z
= ~39,4% of the original size, image/video quality 80%/60%

Download (Update only):
You must be registered to see the links
-
You must be registered to see the links


(y) My compressious likeses! (y) Give them to us you filthy little pervertses! :p

This compression is unofficial and untested, use it at your own risk.
The compressing process reduces the quality and can break the game.

*PC = Win+Linux
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
  • Yay, update!
  • Heart
Reactions: pikapii11, GershGersh, Deleted member 2395972 and 92 others
Black Metal

Black Metal

New Member
Nov 4, 2021
13
50
Is there any confirmation as of today if Hana and/or Mina are going to get sexually involved with the club activities at some point in the future? I'd love to play the game but I don't want to get invested in those characters only for them to become sluts, eventually.

I mean, the dream sequences I saw could already be considered foreshadowing, but who knows.
 
Avaron1974

Avaron1974

Resident Lesbian
Aug 22, 2018
26,935
92,930
TD1900 said:
That's an observation that's pretty much made every update and I'm not really sure how to feel about it.
Click to expand...
You summed up the issue, at least for me, here.

There is a planned trajectory and escalation to the competition
Click to expand...
You see the big picture and we only see parts of it. It's the biggest problem with anything that releases in parts, we don't know what's going to happen and can only judge by what we see.

It's not that a cattle prod is light as such but it is part of light BDSM which is something i've been doing for years and i'm as big a wuss of a girl you'll ever meet. I am a sub to my partners dom but only ever move around in the lighter side of BDSM culture and that's why I say it's tame.

In the grand scheme of sex play it is harder than most average folks will see but when I here kink club and sex competition, especially with how Kat tries to break the girls down, especially Veronica. I was just expecting her to push them a bit more.

It's pretty much a me issue, just voicing my rambles mainly. Like I said, you see where it's going and I can only go by what i'm seeing.

I think, for me at least, it mainly comes from the fact that you had them in front of a large group while that group covered them in cum which is something anyone would find humiliating and that was pretty early. That along with how hard Veronica and Kat went at each other to start with. A few shocks with a prod does seem tame by comparison.

Then we take what could be done to Ros last time with being railed and humiliated by Ian infront of a group.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ChillyWilly and TD1900
T

Tom7902000

Member
Mar 24, 2017
105
40
Really love this game but if we have a chance to make all harem choice chance would be really nice.a little bit sad rosalina almost disapear if choose mina.
And finally Mina content is out, then I subscribed.(the tease finally had a happy ending)
Fav Rank: Veronica>Hana>Mina>Felicia
 
I

Idontplay

Well-Known Member
Oct 30, 2017
1,354
1,908
TD1900 said:
That's an observation that's pretty much made every update and I'm not really sure how to feel about it.

There is a planned trajectory and escalation to the competition, and in my head everything fits together nicely in a satisfying arc, but I think exhibition 2 is what fuels that sentiment. I still stand by it on a conceptual level - a focus on mental humiliation over a physical approach - but I think I failed to execute it with enough bite in some areas. The Veronica event with the spider was perfect in my mind, but I think the other two focused too much on setting up Felicia's and Edwin's club arc. Ideally, Kathleen probably should've switched to a more physical approach when the interrogation element was a wash, but I also think people underestimate just how grueling it is to sit on bondage horse - that angle was sharp!

I feel you about the versus/gamey aspect being lacking. With a little more creativity, I probably could've accomplished the above in a more head-to-head-to-head fashion. Hopefully week 3's exhibition will be a return to form for the "competition" angle. The month is only halfway over, after all.

As for the club content in this update, because I assume that's what prompted your observation and not an update that came out a year ago:

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Or, perhaps the end of the day, I'm just a softy. :whistle:
Click to expand...
Maybe I'm playing another game named "Pale Carnation" and I have never realized that, but if I'm not wrong during the last exhibition you have practically destroyed the social life of a mother forcing her to be the "star" in a porn movie and in another episode you have almost drowned a girl just because Katheleen thought it was sexually satisfying, but to me it is very clear how you have planned to escalate the things and how to give to the player the power to trigger or not the various escalations.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lexstok, temp614699b1, fetishgirl and 5 others
Mr. Muscles

Mr. Muscles

Member
Mar 30, 2021
378
560
How do these same chapter update usually go? Is it just an expansion of the current chapter, and therefore one should play it before the next chapter (in this case, 5), or is it actually a continuation of the story?
 
B

benzene_phi73

New Member
Nov 18, 2021
8
54
I keep getting an out of memory error when Veronica is told to lick the cattle prod. The game then closes automatically. I tried starting the game from scratch, skipping. I switched off transitions. I then tried using the compressed version above with 80 percent image quality. None of it worked. I am unable to progress beyond this point. I am playing on my laptop with 16GB RAM. So memory shouldn't be an issue. This is the first time this has happened in my playthroughs. Does anybody know what to do?
 
T

Turret

Forum Fanatic
Jun 23, 2017
4,516
7,752
Black Metal said:
Is there any confirmation as of today if Hana and/or Mina are going to get sexually involved with the club activities at some point in the future? I'd love to play the game but I don't want to get invested in those characters only for them to become sluts, eventually.

I mean, the dream sequences I saw could already be considered foreshadowing, but who knows.
Click to expand...
No there is currently no confirmation on this. But even if it would come to that, it would be on a couple paths only! Choices matter in Pale Carnations. If you are going the "I am a nice guy" paths, you´ll get certain events and outcomes, if you go for the "I am an egomanical asshole" paths, you´ll get different events and outcomes of general events. Same goes for "I am neither good nor bad".
I am rather sure you can get Hana and Mina involved in Club business in later updates, but that is on you then, if it happens. If you don´t want that to happen, you will get opportunity to prevent it. As said, it depends on how you play the game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Black Metal
ProtoJoto

ProtoJoto

Newbie
Aug 25, 2021
34
267
A good update, but I would happily trade a few animations for more story progression.

Sophia is best girl: I hope there is a route to transfer ownership of her from Abel to the MC.

A reminder to the devs: there are those here who would love to support this project, but boycott Patreon. If you ever add a Subscribestar account (or some other donation platform), I will back it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dlombu, Flowing Thought and Turret
K

kirikirifan

Member
Jul 4, 2020
137
120
why is the update on Pixeldrain half a gig bigger than the others?

edit:nevermind, it was just the page showing an incorrect size
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
4.80 star(s) 536 Votes