Peasant's Quest is an RPG first and a porn game, albeit an extremely expansive one with lots of content to it, second. For some potential players, this is going to be a turn-off. If you want your main character to get laid, you either need to cheat your stats or just learn the systems and play the game.
Personally, I think this is awesome. Peasant's Quest is one of the most fully fleshed out games on F95zone right now, both in terms of sexual content and in terms of gameplay. For sexual content, there are over 20 ladies to bang (each with at least one quest and sex scene, and many with multiple quests and scenes and some you can even get pregnant and have kids with!), and a ridiculous number of pretty good images. It's not the highest quality visual art you're ever going to see, but it's unique art, better than average, and pretty dang immersive.
Gameplay-wise, it plays out like a decent RPGMaker RPG, and that's true even if you were to completely ignore the sexual content. Its quests are comparatively nonlinear (though some of them do unlock progress in others, so you can't completely ignore every quest line), the combat system has some interesting tweaks like an equipment system where most of your gear is balanced against other gear rather than having a linear upgrade path, there is a bunch of ways to get money in the game (though there aren't really any get-rich-quick schemes beyond just hunting shitloads of goblins every day for a while), it has a deep alchemy system that has both gameplay effects and optional sex scene effects, and it actually has a surprising depth of characterization, story, and world-building for what on the surface looks like a pretty generic fantasy world.
It's not perfect, certainly. Some systems unlock later than I'd like (this gets to be less of a problem the more content gets implemented after these systems show up) - fast travel, poison protection, other party members. And while I do like that the equipment is balanced rather than there always being one obviously best choice, the equipment slots still feel underutilized. There are also some people out there who think it's too grindy. I feel that a little bit in the midgame (there are a few points where you need a buttload of cash and there's just no other way to get it quickly than to grind out some goblin ears), but my sense of things is that it actually fits well with the game thematically, since it's called "Peasant's Quest" and peasants traditionally have hard lives and not a lot of resources. Also, for better or for worse, it's probably a good idea to have the walkthrough open for this game. It's so big and there's so much to do that it's pretty easy to get lost or miss something you need to progress the story. Oh, and the puzzles. Yeah. Not very interesting, nothing to write home about, pretty arbitrary. These were without a doubt the biggest frustration for me, and the best reason to have access to a walkthrough.
As far as the sexual content itself goes: look at the tags, please. If one of them is a serious problem for you, might be best to skip this game. I'm totally happy with the tags and think this game rules, but I understand that it's simply not for everybody. Which...is probably fine, actually. Not everything needs to be made to suit every single person in the world's taste. People like different stuff!
Bottom line: this is a five star game through and through. The question isn't whether or not it's a good game, but whether or not it's a good game for you specifically. If you're into the tags and can accept or even enjoy (like I do) a porn game having actual gameplay, I'd strongly urge you to give this a shot. Also, if you have a few bucks to spare and have a good time with Peasant's Quest, maybe send some cash Tinkerer's way. This is a huge game and it's been in pretty consistent development for a loooong time, so I'd encourage supporting such a solid dev.