Imagining that was considered a "peasant quest Reboot", what would you keep, what would you suggest and what do you think was missing to greatly improve not just content but game wise as well. since the current one is now rounded but a snow ball?
For example, one thing that is negative in my view is how some quests can only be done by doing multiple others and how there is no hold back that slow downs the PC progress. etc or how some storylines could be reformed to be even more insteresthing while others changed from bottom up as doesnt look to grounded/too uncanny easy.
I
like how some storylines are interconnected, and that to progress with some of the girls you have to do stuff for others and/or outside events have to happen before the next stage becomes available. It's not a sandbox game, there's a grand story being told and the best stories have separate arcs, subplots, and secondary/side/support characters with their own development. What the MC does can have an influence quite a ways away, and events outside the MC's control can affect what he does (or doesn't!) do.
A reboot would allow changes "under the hood" in addition to storylines. The dev has said a bunch of stuff used Common Events when they could have been Flags or Switches, and there's a lot more of those available now than CEs. Rebuilding using flags/switches for those could (should) allow more content before running up against the game engine's limitations. But a rebuild would take a LOT of time and effort, and the dev is essentially making PQ solo...
If there were a reboot I'd like some storyline changes. Like an alternate path to learning Summon that doesn't require asking Beth out on a date, so you can delay or even skip her storyline. Or conversely some other girl than Alice (probably new) to get caught up in Naamah's storyline, since that makes Alice's storyline up to that point irrelevant.
I'd also like more choices at various points. Like a way to acquire the map from the Mayor's mansion without stealing it. (Buy it? Probably spendy!). Or with Frida, she has to give you Balder before she will give birth. When she asks if you're trying to get with Mia you either lose a lot of her Affection or lie to her. A third option costing less Affection would be nice, like lying by omission or really anything else than "you got me" or "you're the only one for me." (Can't truthfully dedicate yourself to Frida since that would end game progress.)