Redhead+Freckles is enough for me. Not really into lots of piercings and tats. I won't reject an LI because of them, but I don't think they add to her beauty - her story, but not her beauty.
I admit it depends on the LI overall looks and the type of piercing for me. Cause I hate the hoop nipple piercing. But for some reason nipples piercing just makes some girls look alot hotter to me.
Someone like Allie I can see it being hot and cute on her , Kris would look hot as hell to me and it's the one I actually dislike about her appearance cause it feels like it's something that is missing. Maggie id hate nipple piercing it would look off and weird to me , same goes for Veronica and Alexa.
So it really just comes down to how they look imo if id like them or think it would look hot but I do I am into nipple piercing overall. but face piercing expect for 1 side of the nose is kind of a pass for me but like you I won't reject a character cause of it. when it comes to alot of tattoo's some are okay not a fan of alot of ink but when they look , they look good there is always the exception for me.