- Apr 25, 2022
- 2,613
- 8,978
This falls more into "you can't prove a negative" territory. If we're getting that technical about it, then yeah we can't "prove" what Allison has or hasn't done in the past prior to the events of the story... but given the context at this stage of the story the idea that she ever cheated on Jake seems pretty absurd to me. Throwing in some kind of weird plot twist at this point where Lily wasn't actually Jake's daughter seems like a jump the shark moment. It would ruin the story, imo.I think you don't understand the word fact! You can prove the earth is flat! You can prove with a gen test who is the father!
But you can't go in a game and request a gen test. Maybe you can give the dev the money to implement the impregnation scene and then it becomes a fact.
Currently it's a fact we don't know who the father is! It seems very likely it's the MC, but nothing more. If Allison has cheated, we have no clue about that, so I say 50:50 in terms of likelihood.
That and there are plenty of inferences in the story that can safely rule out your "Allison cheated" theory:
1) Allison very clearly feels very strongly about fidelity. Jake's cheating hurt her deeply.
2) She can't even bring herself to date other men now when she's single, let alone when she was with Jake.
3) Jake and Allison (depending on your path) fight a lot, and never once in those fights was it ever brought up that she cheated too.
4) Lily notably shares a rare genetic combo with Jake. Black hair + Blue Eyes.