My issue was more on the "how" here. We're not presented with what I think are good options, either you're a big asshole with the very first option or you're just a bad guy overall for the second time. There is no right answers anyway, I just didn't like any of the choices we had. Might as well not start dating at all to be honestI don't know if breaking up with someone is an A-hole thing to do, it sucks, but I don't think breaking up with a character ruins his redemption, cause it shows he doesn't want to be the same cheater.