kjj308

Member
Nov 2, 2022
100
169
ummm I understand your point I suppose, but it will be different for each person, incest as a fantasy really turns me on, it was something I discovered recently, but thinking about doing it with a relative in real life?? no way, the idea just seems repulsive to me, but in fantasy? oh yeah give me everything you got. So I guess some of us separate reality from fiction and others don't and that's fine.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Yes, definitely everyone is different. I tend to want to relate to the characters and try to inject myself into their shoes when making choices to see what I would have chosen.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 

cptjackrabbit

Newbie
Dec 16, 2018
17
14
This might be one of the best conversations Ive seen in this site. I really wanted to respond to something, and then Id keep reading and there would be something else to respond to, and so forth. Thus, figured it might be a bit easier to just make a post.

1. Someone said that being adult games they should be able to turn you on. While I get that viewpoint, Id disagree, personally. For me, what constitutes a good game here is if you removed the lewd, would you still enjoy it? The lewd is the bonus to a great story then. Ones that just force the scenes can be jarring to the flow of the story. I want it to be where the character makes me desire a lewd scene, not needing a lewd scene to create desire.

2. Thank god more people are saying it. Maybe if enough people say this, it make create an upward trend. Im referring to female characters "assets" God dammit do I hate the over sized T&A thing. I think it detracts from what could be gorgeous people. In a lot of these game, it might say a character has nice little tits, and Im looking at them thinking, "No, those are still DD's" Like people arent wandering around and everyone has G Cups!

3. The incest issue. I admit, I usually turn it on in options or patch. Am I a fan of incest? Not in the slightest. However, the MC lives with landlady and her 2 daughters so they are my room mates and constantly saying good morning landlady or yay landlady made me pancakes... just doesnt make a lick of sense. Not a fan of trying to bang mom, but at least the overall situation makes some sense.. Please leave Pae Carnations alone folks... its doing the right things...But that brings me to the next point.....

4. What is the obsession with mom? or friends mom? or somebody's mom? or the older teacher? or basically all the MILF content? You know how hard it is in a lot of games to avoid the mothers and milfs?

5. last bullet point, I promise. City of Broken Dreamers is probably my favorite game so far from this site. I would definetly play without the porn, and for the most part, the porn there is makes senseI enjoy the stories and characters and I dont think theres any railroading of making the MC bang anyone. Actually, I think it would be possible to skip all the sex scenes, maybe. The attractions to the MC generally make sense, and sometimes it isnt even an attraction that sets up anything. With that said, if Im not wanting a strong story or something, then I do like to go all the way into fantasy land. I know a lot of people arent into forced sex acts by whatever means. Violence, blackmail, corruption, sleeping, whatever. cool cool. I on the other hand, when Im going for just a lust filled adventure look for the cruelest and most brutal thing I can, and that can be hard to find. Euphoria kinda got there... but I wanted to see it go even further. And towards the end, the story starts to get a little weird. I want to play an absolutely depraved MC who has no qualms or remorse. What is the draw? It is absolutely not something to condone in reality. In reality most people strive to at least be decent. But in this world of fiction, let absolutely loose. its escaping the reality and just having fun. Again, not the majority of things I look for, but maybe the one out of ten.

I think that about covers it. Yeah! bye!
 

connor1518

Newbie
Apr 6, 2022
87
606
Some very well thought out and articulated posts.

I'll admit I'm very drawn to incest stories to the point some without tend to bore me unless the story line is really good, Eternum, Love of Magic and Leap of Faith come to mind but I have my own personal reasons for that.

I also very much appreciate V/Ns where the models are proportioned realistically, including the male ones. I'm not a fan of the anomalous genetic mutation penis, it hurts the story immersion. I also admit it was Olivia I was most drawn to in Radiant.

I'm most drawn to more romantic driven stories, I've been a writer of stories for more than a few years now that have been posted at various sites so the writing quality is important to me. Sometimes I'm amazed at how much some people are willing to look past sloppy, lazy, or derivative writing. Some of the more popular V/Ns have some of the worst writing. It seems as though writing a good MC is particularly hard for some Devs. They make a V/N that looks good but can't create a decent MC. (Looking at you Midnight Paradise and B.a.D. which is way over rated from a writing stand point among others)

I don't care for the sleep creep thing, I prefer MCs who show some respect to female characters they profess to care about. I don't mind slow burn stories with good character development that are well fleshed out. Too often lewd and crude are confused for scintillating and titillating. I don't pull punches as can be seen in some of my reviews such as A Wife and Mother.

I've started writing a story that I hope to turn into my first V/N. So I'll be putting my money where my mouth is.
 
Last edited:

LSC82

Well-Known Member
Jul 27, 2020
1,842
3,673
I'm gonna be a late entry into this discussion...
First i would like to say that incest is neither a requirement or a deal breaker for me, more stuff besides that will influence wether i end up liking a story or not.
With that said if there is a patch i tend to install it, because the "landlady" thing sounds utterly ridiculous.

Something people miss in this "incest or not?" discussion, incest premises aren't one and the same, some are better than others.
Radiant here, is about girls who never met their father until they were grown up, that is (imo) a good premise, i can see both sides having a lot of confusing thoughts upon having their lives shaken upside down.
The bachelor who is suddenly living with 3 hot nubile girls but is suppoused to stay away because they are his daughters.
And the girls who never had a father figure, now have to share a roof with this (suppousedly) hunk of a man and don't know how to deal with this...
Both sides aren't used to this and they've been suddenly dropped into this situation, i can understand the confusion it generates.

On the other hand we have the ever popular, son moves back home after 5(or so) years...
I can understand the mom being elated with her son being back, and taking notice of how much more grown up he looks... still from those 2 things to jumping his bones it's quite the stretch.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jorjor69

cptjackrabbit

Newbie
Dec 16, 2018
17
14
I'm gonna be a late entry into this discussion...
First i would like to say that incest is neither a requirement or a deal breaker for me, more stuff besides that will influence wether i end up liking a story or not.
With that said if there is a patch i tend to install it, because the "landlady" thing sounds utterly ridiculous.
that’s exactly what I was saying. Radiant using ward and caretaker is driving me nuts. They just sound ridiculous




Something people miss in this "incest or not?" discussion, incest premises aren't one and the same, some are better than others.
Radiant here, is about girls who never met their father until they were grown up, that is (imo) a good premise, i can see both sides having a lot of confusing thoughts upon having their lives shaken upside down.
The bachelor who is suddenly living with 3 hot nubile girls but is suppoused to stay away because they are his daughters.
And the girls who never had a father figure, now have to share a roof with this (suppousedly) hunk of a man and don't know how to deal with this...
Both sides aren't used to this and they've been suddenly dropped into this situation, i can understand the confusion it generates.

.

Another good point. These three and mc have no familial bond, whatsoever. They didn’t know the other exists. They might be blood relatives, but in the beginning, they aren’t family.
 

JLucci

Member
Mar 31, 2018
419
502
There is an update on Patr:poop:on...

But I will not go to that shitty company's site. If someone wants to grab it.
I's a public post followed by the usual patreon wallpapers:

Radiant CH5: Progress Report #3
Hey again everyone! I've recently to reflect the state of our progress, and this is the biggest one yet... as we've nearly completed the next 7 scenes, and it won't be long before we knock out the next few as well. Additionally, now that we're nearing completion, I was able to predict that the chapter will be approximately 19-20 scenes long, and I've updated the tracker to reflect that.
While this does mean that Chapter 5 is a bit shorter than the last two, the good news is that we only have approximately 7-8 more scenes to completion, and we're still on track to release in late February!
As you can see by the above previews, we're meeting a new (but important) female character! Who is this peculiar looking girl, and why the mysterious sunglasses? Perhaps her role in the story has something to do with one of the career aspirations of the triplets..? We also get a rather intense visit from our employee, Mira, whom I cannot confirm nor deny is up to something.
I would've liked to post more previews for you guys, but the others would be a bit too spoilery, so we'll have to leave it at that for now.
A quick apology for taking a while to post this one: not only did we have the holidays recently, but I've been dealing with quite a few difficult personal matters and decided to use my time wisely and focus my energy on just getting work done. That said, I'm about to post this month's wallpapers (they're spicy!): sorry they're coming so late in the month, and thanks for being so patient with us.
I love you all!
SirD.

Edit: Hooray, just what this game needs is more characters! :KEK:

Edit 2: Might as well add the images that came with it.
 
Last edited:

Squark ⚧❤️

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 16, 2017
7,020
7,808
that’s exactly what I was saying. Radiant using ward and caretaker is driving me nuts. They just sound ridiculous
I'm sure you know, but "ward" is applicable if a child is left in the care of a legal guardian (or the courts).

However, I feel "caretaker" is not quite the correct usage of the term - except in North America where it can apply to buildings, animals or people. Not being North American myself, it feels off.
 

cptjackrabbit

Newbie
Dec 16, 2018
17
14
I'm sure you know, but "ward" is applicable if a child is left in the care of a legal guardian (or the courts).

However, I feel "caretaker" is not quite the correct usage of the term - except in North America where it can apply to buildings, animals or people. Not being North American myself, it feels off.

grammatically those words aren’t wrong. It’s just they aren’t used in regular speech. At least in such a manner. Ward isn’t basically used at all. Caretaker is usually someone caring for an elderly person, if we used the common colloquial.

in many games they use landlady. Again, wouldn’t be wrong for context, just sounds stupid. A mom makes more sense for the role than landlady.
 

Filipis

Member
Nov 15, 2022
216
475
Some very well thought out and articulated posts.

I'll admit I'm very drawn to incest stories to the point some without tend to bore me unless the story line is really good, Eternum, Love of Magic and Leap of Faith come to mind but I have my own personal reasons for that.

I also very much appreciate V/Ns where the models are proportioned realistically, including the male ones. I'm not a fan of the anomalous genetic mutation penis, it hurts the story immersion. I also admit it was Olivia I was most drawn to in Radiant.

I'm most drawn to more romantic driven stories, I've been a writer of stories for more than a few years now that have been posted at various sites so the writing quality is important to me. Sometimes I'm amazed at how much some people are willing to look past sloppy, lazy, or derivative writing. Some of the more popular V/Ns have some of the worst writing. It seems as though writing a good MC is particularly hard for some Devs. They make a V/N that looks good but can't create a decent MC. (Looking at you Midnight Paradise and B.a.D. which is way over rated from a writing stand point among others)

I don't care for the sleep creep thing, I prefer MCs who show some respect to female characters they profess to care about. I don't mind slow burn stories with good character development that are well fleshed out. Too often lewd and crude are confused for scintillating and titillating. I don't pull punches as can be seen in some of my reviews such as A Wife and Mother.

I've started writing a story that I hope to turn into my first V/N. So I'll be putting my money where my mouth is.
Couldn't have articulated these thoughts better myself!
Now, on one hand, I understand why a lot of the more popular VNs have mediocre to poor writing - it's because VNs we mostly enjoy here are 3D rendered, which is a skill all on its own - and not an easy one to learn or master. So, when a VN has questionable and/or unbelievable dialogue, we look for something else to praise. And surprise: the renders and animations leave the (arguably) 2nd most important impression on us, the readers.
However, I do find myself too often skipping pointless and mind-numbing dialogue that expands the story, instead of furthering it. And, there are simply not enough character choices given to the player. Upon reflection, I would reckon that the scenes I skip most go on for what could only be an educated guess of several weeks effort of rendering, yet asks no input from the MC. I would prefer these "character building" scenes actually allow for building relationships by giving the player the option to respond in several ways (usually Love/Lust paths), and to feel the effect of those later down the line. Otherwise, the developer IMHO wasted months of rendering on scenes that achieve nothing but (in the words of cptjackrabbit) build desire through lewdness - instead of building lewdness through desire.
I can only hope, that with time, the quantity and quality of adult VNs continually improves. Technology has essentially already reached a plateau in development, the means with which to stand out is writing compelling characters & stories!
 

Son of Durin

Engaged Member
Jul 5, 2021
3,686
6,675
grammatically those words aren’t wrong. It’s just they aren’t used in regular speech. At least in such a manner. Ward isn’t basically used at all. Caretaker is usually someone caring for an elderly person, if we used the common colloquial.

in many games they use landlady. Again, wouldn’t be wrong for context, just sounds stupid. A mom makes more sense for the role than landlady.
Ward has been used that way and is a legal term used daily in the court systems, but it isn't something you see much in modern speech outside of that. Not quite archaic, but not everyday, either. It is, however, the appropriate term for an unrelated child placed legally in the care of a permanent guardian, but which that guardian does not adopt. It's different from a "foster" situation which is meant to be temporary.
 

Drew Anderson

Member
Dec 1, 2017
471
793
Ward has been used that way and is a legal term used daily in the court systems, but it isn't something you see much in modern speech outside of that. Not quite archaic, but not everyday, either. It is, however, the appropriate term for an unrelated child placed legally in the care of a permanent guardian, but which that guardian does not adopt. It's different from a "foster" situation which is meant to be temporary.
It's not everyday... Unless you're Batman with his ward Dick Grayson, aka Robin! ;) Sorry, couldn't resist.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ilhares

cptjackrabbit

Newbie
Dec 16, 2018
17
14
Ward has been used that way and is a legal term used daily in the court systems, but it isn't something you see much in modern speech outside of that. Not quite archaic, but not everyday, either. It is, however, the appropriate term for an unrelated child placed legally in the care of a permanent guardian, but which that guardian does not adopt. It's different from a "foster" situation which is meant to be temporary.
While you are pointing out technical differences in our post, I do think we are saying the same things. These words were used appropriately. That’s why I said they weren’t things in the common colloquial.


point being, words like these roboticize (Yes I made up a word) the dialogue. It doesn’t sound natural and loses appeal. Back to my classic landlady example… I’m not interested in an MC banging his mom. But I’m even less interested in hearing landladyin the same spot in conversation..hell, it’d be nice if once it was the landlady, and she lived in a different place.
 

armond

Well-Known Member
Apr 26, 2020
1,188
3,772
While you are pointing out technical differences in our post, I do think we are saying the same things. These words were used appropriately. That’s why I said they weren’t things in the common colloquial.


point being, words like these roboticize (Yes I made up a word) the dialogue. It doesn’t sound natural and loses appeal. Back to my classic landlady example… I’m not interested in an MC banging his mom. But I’m even less interested in hearing landladyin the same spot in conversation..hell, it’d be nice if once it was the landlady, and she lived in a different place.
Useing the character name would solve a lot of this but they are just replacing mom with the patron approved filler phrase, it's a lack of creativity on the wrighters part. Through exposition you can infer a relationship without saying, "oh fuck, we're related by blood lolololol"
 

Son of Durin

Engaged Member
Jul 5, 2021
3,686
6,675
While you are pointing out technical differences in our post, I do think we are saying the same things. These words were used appropriately. That’s why I said they weren’t things in the common colloquial.


point being, words like these roboticize (Yes I made up a word) the dialogue. It doesn’t sound natural and loses appeal. Back to my classic landlady example… I’m not interested in an MC banging his mom. But I’m even less interested in hearing landladyin the same spot in conversation..hell, it’d be nice if once it was the landlady, and she lived in a different place.
A better way of writing it for the non-incest path would be to use the term "wards" at the initial realization, but then use the term "the girls" or "my girls" later. The former is just a generic, but the latter gives a parental feel to things even though he would not be bio-dad in that scenario. However, games like this are written with simplistic single-word substitution for the "patch" to deal with; using better language choices would make patching more complex. I also think it's partially to get you to give up and give in even if that isn't the approach you wanted to take.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LSC82

dolfe67

Forum Fanatic
Apr 25, 2020
4,615
12,570
It's just a fuck-you to censorship. Why being creative with ways around it when this is what you want to write, an incest story. But you need to censor it to get that money on patreon.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LSC82
4.30 star(s) 271 Votes