- Jul 23, 2017
- 65
- 140
I get that he wants to change events, which is not a good idea, especially if he doesn't know what events to change. Also, changing events in 1999 to save one person might result in death of another (as I mentioned). Or any other changes. Especially if he doesn't know how some events interact. One of his actions might have saved Jenny but his other action might have changed it back.I think you might have missed the part where he WANTS to change events. You can call that dumb or dangerous if you want, but it's not like he's just randomly bumbling around and causing changes.
He wants Jenny and his dad to survive.
OK, Reckless might have been a better word.The MC is not dimwitted.
He does not do what he is told by a man he does not trust at all.
To top it off he does everything you mentioned as a point to prove that thing for a purpose.
He wanted to grab a bite because he did have time to waste AND was forced to leave without breakfast. Meaning he is hungry as a wolf.
He took pictures to try and convince darci.
He beat the guy because he was threatening his mother and her unborn child, his sister.
He played at the arcade to basically see what all that hype was about. Remember arcades died out when MC was barely a toddler. And hiding his face from the angry idiot looking for him on the streets did not hurt either.
He contacted Jenny to not come off as a douchebag AND in the hopes to save her life.
He snuck around the facility to a) try to uncover what is going on and b) look for his father.
Whether his actions actually can save his aunt and dad is irrelevant. Even if the chance is exceedingly low he will try.
And remember. He got told that he can't by the guy he does not trust further than he could throw.
Looking from the outside it may look reckless.
But dimwitted?
No.
I'm not saying that MC doesn't have reasons to do stuff - he certainly does. But having a reason to do something doesn't mean it's a good idea to do it (or that the reason is good). To me it just seemed like a series of dumb decisions without even trying to think about the consequences, especially since he caused trouble the first time by buying the phone with future/counterfeit money and he knows that people in 2019 can remember him from 1999.
If he doesn't trust the man, he shouldn't be doing his quest anyway. And anything and everything you do in the past can affect the future, that's time travel 101, whether you trust someone or not.
1) Yes, he was hungry. Again, you can survive couple of hours without food instead of risking changing the timeline.
2) Again yes, but why does he need to convince Darci? Is it worth risking that someone will notice him taking pictures? And convincing Darci increases the chance of her going with him (or even on her own) back to 1999 and given her temperament... And even if she managed to control herself, is a good idea to have more people messing with the timeline?
3) Beating up Eric is the part I'm ok with since April told MC to do it, so I would consider it "timeline safe".
Also, assuming Tiffany was pregnant with Jessica and since Jessica is alive in 2019, that means:
a) Eric wouldn't have caused any serious damage and your intervention was irrelevant (and April's advice therefore suspicious).
b) Tiffany would have been saved by someone else (again making your intervention irrelevant and April suspicious).
c) It's one of those paradoxes - MC went back in time to save Tiffany so she can take care of him in the future so he can go back in time to save her... But then it should have been part of his mission.
4) Eric was in no shape to run after him anyway. And even if I accept hiding in the arcade, then you should at least watch the door instead of playing games. And MC should definitely avoid contact with anyone.
5) Walking Jenny home ended up with her following him to the forest (and possibly further)... Yes, he couldn't have known it would happen but that just proves my point how dumb/irresponsible MC's actions are.
6) Sneaking around the facility was probably the dumbest shit of all. If he gets caught, he could miss the rendezvous. He might be searched (he has a phone from the future with pictures of stolen documents in it) and could possibly end up in jail.
I don't think the MC realizes how big of an impact his actions can have, even if they seem successful or innocuous.
And yes, we don't really know how time travel works in this game, so maybe all of this has to happen because it's already happened and it's required to happen again so the MC can travel back to 1999 from 2019 (see 3c above), thus making my complains pointless...