- Oct 16, 2017
- 263
- 157
I read the whole thing, but I don't really have a long answer in reply.Absolutely agree. And the art they use isn't even that good - it is mid-tier generic anime aesthetic that plagued rule34 in late 2000s. I was delighted to see people moving from it and names like Personalami or Sabudenego rising at the top. It lacks originality, style and is just boring with characters looking the same.
Do not misunderstand me - I do appreciate good anime aesthetic. But what made Roundscape so good and unique was the variety of styles - anyone could find something to their liking. Funnies part - it was anime-styled pictures that dragged behind back then, less animesque were top of the line. And now they vent for more consistent anime-like pictures, yet many of those are lacking.
Lets compare Roundscape Adorevia to something that pops in my mind right now: Overgrown Genesis, Fate of Irnia, Noxian Nights (paired with Kingdom of Deception for good measure) and Legend of Queen Opala (all parts). Those games have varied approaches when it come to art style:
a) OG, FoI, NN and KoD sport overall high quality of pictures and are dedicated to single art style, making them very consistent with what they deliver, yet if this is not your cup of tea - you will miss the fun. Another point is that consistent artstyle demands more in terms of quality - if your game have consistently bad pictures it won't be a matter of tea-cups, people just won't enjoy it.
b) RA and LoQO have varied artstyles with something for everyone, its not a coin toss of either or, you are likely to find something to your liking. What RA and LoQO do differently, is quality-quantity approach - RA tend to have more quantity and LoQO more quality. Yet even if quality is all over the place, variety can still remedy that by rising chances that person playing the game will find something to like.
And basically RA now goes for more consistent approach, yet without the needed level of quality to make it work.
TL;DR: they are picking stick with two short ends. It, in my opinion, does not work.
Just that, after a several years-long breaks, I was contemplating picking the game up again, only to get turned off by all the animesque looking artwork that seem to have also replaced some pre-existing scene's artwork that, in my opinion, was 10 times more exciting to look at than the animesque art that they got replaced by.
Because of the art style they are going with these days, I'm actually finding it extremely difficult to want to pick it up again, it just looks... boring, and quite frankly, some of the characters seem to look dull and even ruined compared to how hot, sexy, and good they looked in previous artworks.